9 ms·
Maybe im missing it, but the argument seems to be morality is objective because everyone thinks it is. How is that not begging the question? Then there are a b
by bawolff 6y ago
Maybe im missing it, but the argument seems to be morality is objective because everyone thinks it is. How is that not begging the question?
Then there are a bunch of pithy lines, which the author seems to treat as obvious in context revelations, but to me seem to utterly lack evidence/argument.
> "No matter how the universe had turned out, two plus two would equal four and it would have been wrong to torture people for fun."
Umm why? That seems non obvious to me.
>"Pleasure is good and suffering is bad because Reality is essentially directed toward the former and away from the latter"
Is it though? And that's ignoring the whole question of wtf does it even mean for reality to be directed in some direction.
> "My proposal is that the inherently directed nature of Reality entails that it’s objectively good for Reality when it manifests as pleasure and objectively bad for Reality when it manifests as pain."
Umm ok.
>"It is broadly agreed that (all things being equal) pleasure is good and pain is bad..."
Isn't the definition of pleasure, being good. Seems kind of circular - everyone agrees feeling good is good and feeling bad is bad.
>"The reality of objective value is a non-negotiable data-point and we are entitled to make whatever postulations are required to account for it."
'kay then.
- ukj 6y agoEvery question beggs another. Münchhausen trilemma All definitions are (meta)circular. Because language is recursive.
- radford-neal 6y agoSo far, in this brief comment and a brief comment above, you've mentioned Goodhart's law, the McNamara fallacy, and the Munchhausen trilemma. I know nothing of any of these. I think that you would communicate better if you avoided such references. I'd even venture to suggest that your internal thoughts might be improved by not shoving arguments into such pre-defined categories.
- ukj 6y agoI like terseness. Just because you haven't heard of something it doesn't preclude it from being a well-indexed idea in human folklore. Google is your friend.
- Iv 6y agoGoodhart's law/McNamara fallacy: when you put value in a measure, you create incentives to trick it. Here is aa equivalent statement, as terse and clearer, than the comment you made above.
- radford-neal 6y agoI think you overestimate the amount of effort people are willing to go to in order to decipher a cryptic comment by someone called "ukj". Seriously. I'm trying to help you here. At present, you're just wasting your time.
- ukj 6y agoMedice, cura te ipsum.
- TeMPOraL 6y agoYeah, doesn't make sense. I prefer a simpler argument for why there is a subset of morality that's universal for (vast majority of) humans: argument from shared brain architecture. We're essentially running the same wetware under the hood, at least on the time scales of human civilization. So while the universe doesn't necessarily privilege a set of values, human brains are. And that's all that really matters (until we meet aliens or start building conscious AIs) - conscious experience is a feature of brains, not laws of physics in general.
- Iv 6y agoI like the idea that morality is something that is built by mankind and that needs to be extracted by studies. For instance, economists have found the value at which US society estimates an American's life by seeing at which point risks balances costs in some hazardous investments.
- ukj 6y agoThis conception is highly susceptible to Goodhart's law. It favours the quantitative over the qualitative which is a good way to trip over the McNamara fallacy.
- Iv 6y agoI don't think so, if it is done properly. For instance you want a human life to be worth more but the only way for that to happen is to actually spend more to save human lives, which makes the value of life increase.
- ukj 6y agoWhat is your standard for "properness" ?
- Iv 6y agoIn this context, "that can't be tricked the way you propose". If you accurately measure the value human society puts on life (that is, avoiding the bias of, e.g. considering only a part of the population that may be privileged) then your only way to trick the metric is by actually increasing the value of human lives.
- abdulhaq 6y agoI think you _are_ missing the point TBH. The people who say that there is no real objective value, and that that knowledge is important, are claiming that knowing that nothing has objective value, has value.
- a1369209993 6y ago> Umm why? That seems non obvious to me. Because that's how they've defined the words "two", "four", "plus", "equals", "people", "torture", "for fun", and "wrong"? Neither of those statements makes any empirical claims about the physical arrangement of matter in the universe, so neither of them would be refuted by any possible way the universe could have turned out. > > Reality is essentially directed toward the former and away from the latter That this is false is obvious to anyone who has actually bothered to observe reality. People sometimes unnaturally and non-essentially impose such direction, but Reality itself tends toward the opposite.
- bawolff 6y agoI agree with 2+2, i disagree with torture is fun. I don't think anything is implicit in the definition, and i can imagine a (very unpleasent) world where that is the case.
- Iv 6y agoLast week, I did some philosophy: I dived into the discussions of Debian-legal of what constitutes open source and licenses apply or not to deep learning model. It was some real philosophy, applied philosophy, on complicated matters, touching technical, legal and moral aspects. It reminded me why I consider academic philosophy a fraud. I love philosophy, and places where it happens usually call it another name because the academic philosophers really perverted that word.
- bobthechef 6y ago> Maybe im missing it, but the argument seems to be morality is objective because everyone thinks it is. How is that not begging the question? Let's substitute morality with "facts". "Maybe I'm missing it, but the argument seems to be that facts are objective because everyone things they are. How is that not begging the question?" Begging the question only applies to demonstrable truths, not evident or self-evident truths. We do not and cannot and need not demonstrate first principles. The reality of morality is obvious. The only way you can doubt it is through intentional or habitual skepticism, i.e., through some kind of philosophical FUD. I can doubt the existence of my left hand, but it would be insane for me to do so and there would be no way for me to recover my acceptance of the existence of my left hand apart from abandoning my doubt because my doubt was never rational in the first place, only willed arbitrarily. That doesn't mean there isn't a way to account for morality. Now, I reject panpsychism because panpsychism is really just a rehashing of Cartesian dualism masquerading as something new. However, it might be a welcome development and provisional stepping stone toward a recovery of telos. Once we finally abandon the stupid Cartesian view of matter we've been enslaved to for 400 years, we can recover the only real understanding of the basis for morality: teleology and the natural law.
- bawolff 6y ago> The [objective] reality of morality is obvious You really think so? I don't. To me this (that morality has some ground truth and isn't just some sort of subjective opinion in how people should behave) seems like an extraordinary claim that contradicts experience. If morality is objective why can nobody, even in culturally homogonous groups, agree on what it means to be a good person?