4 ms·
> It is a slam dunk to get hoaxes accepted, if they follow the party line: That's a real bad example. If you claim to be doing a detailed survey of dog behavio
by zozbot234 6y ago
> It is a slam dunk to get hoaxes accepted, if they follow the party line:
That's a real bad example. If you claim to be doing a detailed survey of dog behavior in a park people will reasonably assume that you've put in the work, regardless of the surrounding politics. The authors did not do that; their entire "research" about canine rape culture was simply made up. That's obviously unethical behavior in any academic context.
- Retric 6y agoBehavior leading to reproducibility issues is also unethical. P hacking etc is just as bad as simply making up experimental data from scratch. It’s at a minimum wasting everyone’s time that’s reading that junk, but a waste of any funding sources for that research. The only reasonable option I see is a culture of reproducing results from independent data and blacklisting people when a high percentage of their papers turn out to be bogus. Because what’s happening today in many fields is simply wasting everyone’s time and money.
- RandoHolmes 6y agoI don't know, anything that implied dogs being raped would have been rejected by me, a layperson who grew up with dogs. Your argument seems to be more about "because some people were duped, it's ok to assume reasonable people were duped" and that doesn't seem right to me.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- Retric 6y agoEven obvious quackery like: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Masaru_Emoto https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Masaru_Emoto still wastes people’s time. Worse it tends to get spread around and keeps showing up. So just because something is obviously fake doesn’t really mean much in context. After all the goal of science is to step beyond people’s intuition to discover what’s actually happening. Thus at some level people need to actually consider very odd ideas as possible and then collect data etc.
- vpgehr 6y agoAnd yet almost anyone in the street could have identified this study as nonsense. If they would have identified it as a hoax is another question. But it is difficult to identify anything as a hoax when many "serious" studies look exactly like that.
- dleslie 6y ago> The authors did not do that; their entire "research" about canine rape culture was simply made up. That's obviously unethical behavior in any academic context. It was so incredibly absurd that the hoax ought to have been obvious from the abstract; that the journal editors and reviewers could not recognize the hideously obvious hoax right in front of their noses is the scandal.