3 ms·
They clearly tried to have this spear-regulate the ride-sharing guys without hitting anyone else but the policy is totally an "adding epicycles" style approach
by renewiltord 6y ago
They clearly tried to have this spear-regulate the ride-sharing guys without hitting anyone else but the policy is totally an "adding epicycles" style approach which is why they had to add more epicycles to exempt all those myriad occupations rather randomly.
- dragonwriter 6y ago> They clearly tried to have this spear-regulate the ride-sharing guys without hitting anyone else No, they didn't. It's true that a big point of AB5 was to limit the reach of the rule from the California Supreme Court decision in Dynamex which it codified by also adding a bunch of exceptions, but it was very (explicitly) not intended to be limited to ride-sharing; codifying Dynamex with additional exceptions instead of legislatively reversing it was because the legislature felt that classifying vulnerable workers as contractors was leading to abuses in an expanding range of fields, not just ride-sharing (or even just app-based gig-work.)
- varenc 6y agoFor others, this is the Dynamex case that started this off: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dynamex_Operations_West,_Inc._v._Superior_Court?wprov=sfti1 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dynamex_Operations_West,_Inc._...
- SamReidHughes 6y agoAB5 extended the applicability of the ABC test from wage orders to the full labor code and unemployment insurance code.
- dragonwriter 6y ago> AB5 extended the applicability of the ABC test from wage orders to the full labor code and unemployment insurance code. That's true. A big point was limiting it's reach as to working arrangements. Another was to harmonize the employee vs. contractor distinction indifferent areas of employment law, since it's really inconvenient for business if it's different for each of those areas.