5 ms·
I feel like modern high-energy physics as exemplified by CERN is a bit like NASA's Space Shuttle program: its main job is to hoover up all available money to fu
by jiggawatts 6y ago
I feel like modern high-energy physics as exemplified by CERN is a bit like NASA's Space Shuttle program: its main job is to hoover up all available money to fund the bureaucracy. Science outcomes aren't even a secondary goal, or a tertiary goal. They're waaaaaay down the list.
Similarly, ITER is going to suck up a hundred billion in science funding that could have gone into a hundred $1B programs intsead of one giant one.
- djaque 6y agoYes, I have a friend who left plasma physics and is still salty about the situation with ITER. She also said that by the time they're done, the technology is going to be outdated since it all began in the 80's. I'd disagree that they are there to pump money into administrators. Some of these problems are just really hard and requires monstrously large organizations to make headway. At worst, I'd say that they are misguided/focusing on the wrong scientific questions or in the case of ITER stuck on a path that should have been abandoned a while ago.
- willis936 6y agoIf you have the chance, ask her what a better vision of the use of funding would be. Keep in mind that the physics goals are to test high neutron flux divertors, tokamak scaling laws, and burning plasma regime stability.
- pantalaimon 6y agoAFAIK you can’t operate a tokamak continuously, only pulsed. A stellarator like Wendelstein 7-X looks like a much more promising design.
- willis936 6y agoI know. I work at the first MHD optimized stellarator :) That doesn’t mean backing out of ITER 15 years ago would have been a good idea. It would be an even worse idea to back out of it now.
- pfdietz 6y agoStellarators also have ruinously low volumetric power density, so they're not any less economically dead than tokamaks.
- mikhailfranco 6y agoSo ITER is an iterator design :)
- Robotbeat 6y agoHonestly, ITER is so bad that you're insulting the Shuttle with this comparison. Shuttle was super inefficient, but it actually launched stuff. Military, commercial, and scientific satellites. And only like a decade after the program was started, too. ITER started in 1985, won't achieve first plasma until 2025 at earliest, and they won't even start D-T fusion experiments until 2035. That's a full half a century until the START of real fusion experiments, and it could still slip. It won't even produce any electrical power. Any thermal energy produced will be vented. Shuttle is a shining example of efficiency, competence, pragmatism, and execution in comparison.
- pier25 6y agoI know nothing about physics but I was under the impression ITER was our best shot for clean sustainable energy. I'm not saying you're wrong btw, just that I had high hopes.
- pfdietz 6y agoNeither ITER, nor fusion in general, are our best shots for clean sustainable energy. They are at best very long shots, and at worst complete wastes of effort.
- AstralStorm 6y agoWhat's your option? If you say solar or wind, I'll tell you not without solid state physics experiments to multiply battery capacity by at least 10x. (Not impossible, but as much pie in the sky as fusion.) Or a global electric network. Or space solar with concomitant energy sending infrastructure. Nuclear is good for maybe 300 years. (And not exclusive with other sources.) Hydro, geothermal are nice where we can have them. Anything else, we don't even know where to start.
- pfdietz 6y agoSolar and wind. Your comment about batteries is bizarre. Batteries don't need higher capacity for stationary storage, they need to be cheap. That is not "pie in the sky" and is certainly a much easier engineering problem than fusion. And batteries are not what you'd use for long term storage; that would be hydrogen (which can be stored underground for less than the equivalent of $1/kWh of storage capacity.) Given reasonable projections of where renewables, batteries, and electrolysers will be in 10 years, one will be able to synthesize artificial baseload sources at a lower cost than nuclear fission, anywhere in the world (in some places much less). And fusion will have a very hard time being competitive even with fission.