2 ms·
I'm not willing to take it on faith that in the industries where Google has dominant market share there was formerly a better ecosystem. Many of these efforts a
by jeffbee 6y ago
I'm not willing to take it on faith that in the industries where Google has dominant market share there was formerly a better ecosystem. Many of these efforts are being driven by lobbyists for newspapers who are sad that they lost their local influence and extortionate local advertising monopolies.
It's also not obvious to me that in the realm of indexing and searching the web it would be better to have numerous worse choices instead of one big one. Say what you want anecdotally about Google search quality, but it is better than anything else on the market in objective terms. What will the searching public lose if you impair Google's ability to pay for search quality?
That's my main beef with the European line of thinking on antitrust, that it considers for some reason the well-being of certain failing companies and doesn't really seem to take into account what the public harms and benefits might be. Whereas in the American approach of the last 40 years, regulators need to show that customers are being harmed, without much regard for competitors.
- an_opabinia 6y agoHow can you tell the difference between an earnest concern for public harms and an opinion from a lobbying campaign?
- jeffbee 6y agoI don't know why, I just find it rather easy to identify astroturf campaigns run by spammers, SEO outfits, and Microsoft. Maybe it is just my age but the answer of the question "is Microsoft sincerely trying to save the Web?" is "LOL obviously not." When I read what seem to me to be rational and legitimate criticism of Google, it tends to come from a disinterested source like a law school or philosophers of ethics, or economists. But these also tend to be even-handed, recognizing that it might be globally optimal to have a single search provider, while criticizing Google for things where it is vulnerable to criticism, such as the fact that it both operates the major ads marketplace and owns the largest participant in that market.