15 ms·
I Want to Fix Goodreads
- armSixtyFour 6y agoGoodreads doesn't get enough love from Amazon, It always seemed really odd to me that the recommended books in the kindle store were better than goodreads even though it's all the same company. It seems like a wasted opportunity. There are also numerous bugs I've ran into on the app that I just work around.
- nonbirithm 6y agoHow do people build recommendation engines? Like, even when you have access to the site's entire API and can write your own client for it, there's still the fact that their recommendations are generally better. It sounds like an extremely important value-add. There are many sites that I will only use the app for because that is where the recommendations are shown. But to me taking a user profile and an article and spitting out a list of articles seems like magic. I also find it weird that in 2020 Goodreads is the status quo for book recommendations.
- searchableguy 6y agoThe best recommendation engine is other people that you know and understand.
- gbtw 6y ago> How do people build recommendation engines? Poorly, its either shovel so much shit against a wall to see what sticks (youtube) or you sorta watched this for 10 minutes to see if you liked it but you didn't but here is more (netflix). Curated lists made by humans are still nicer.
- SamBam 6y agoErr, I disagree with your assessment of Youtube's recommendation engine being "poor." It is probably the most powerful recommendation engine in the world. 5 billion YT videos, comprising 1 billion hours, are watched every day, a meteoric rise ever since they improved the recommendation engine. That recommendation engine has also been accused of contributing to the rise in polarization and conspiracy theories world-wide. So it may not be a force for good. But it's damn powerful.
- sam_lynx 6y agoPart of what makes YouTube’s recommendation algorithm so powerful is that it doesn’t necessarily have to be very good. I scrolled through my recommendations just now and only found one video after scrolling through fifteen that I was interested in watching — but that’s fine, since it’s easy to decide if you might like a video based on its title, thumbnail, and creator. However, if YouTube was as good at recommending books as it was recommending videos, I would never use its book recommendation algorithm. You necessarily have to get almost every book recommendation “correct” for it to be seen as actually useful by the user.
- SamBam 6y agoHow does that follow? I can't imagine that there are any book recommendations -- be they your friends, the Book Review section of your favorite newspaper, or whatever -- that gets things right for almost every single review. That's absurd. When I see a book recommendation, I read the associated review (if it has one), read other people's reviews, look at the author and the blurb, and, yes, even the cover. That tells me much more than a YouTube thumbnail, with only a little more time (but of course I'm going to put more time into choosing a book that might take me two weeks to finish). Indeed, my initial filter is probably much the same as a YouTube thumbnail: I skim past many recommendations based on the genre and author alone. I think if the Times Book Review always wrote reviews in which 1 out of 15 of them made me thing "I need to get that book," I'd be amazed at how much they "get" me. I wouldn't bother with anything else. Every 15 recommendations lands me another "must-read?" Sign me up! The problem listed in the article is that Goodreads is no where near 1 out of 15.
- sam_lynx 6y agoHm, I change my mind, you are correct.
- hazard 6y agoIt's not that hard. See for instance https://www.coursera.org/lecture/machine-learning/collaborative-filtering-2WoBV https://www.coursera.org/lecture/machine-learning/collaborat... on how to get started
- dtech 6y agoIt's not hard to build something that gives you recommendations. It extremely difficult to build something that works well. For consumer companies I know only Spotify and TikTok that do it well, and Youtube that does it OK-ish.
- moltar 6y agoI personally wouldn’t say that Spotify does it well. I don’t think I’ve ever gotten a good recommendation. And daily playlists are a mess.
- prepend 6y agoFor me, I only use goodreads because there’s nothing better that I’ve found. I think of it as similar to evolution, evolution is just about survival, not necessarily the best at stuff that’s not survival.
- DominikPeters 6y agoThere's an entire research field about Recommender Systems (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Recommender_system https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Recommender_system) with its own conference series (https://recsys.acm.org/ https://recsys.acm.org/).
- krrishd 6y agoI get the sense that part of the problem with book recs vs. YouTube video recs is that you can evaluate the quality of a video recommendation super quickly (click in, find out like 10 seconds in that you don't care for it, click out). With books, actioning a recommendation involves 1) getting a copy of the book (digital or physical, both cost money or at minimum the time required to pirate), 2) starting to read it (with the sunken cost of time and/or money + the drive to "give it a chance" both looming over your shoulder, costing you more time), 3) eventually either getting to the end or swallowing your pride and bailing. I think you'd start to see actually useful systems here if you could even eliminate step 1; make it easy as clicking in from a recommendation directly into reading mode. Also solves a critical issue for the engine: gauge recommendation quality by how soon people click out of the rec, as opposed to waiting for the user to go through steps 1-3, and care enough to come back and provide a rating. Way more data to work with. Of course, this all skirts the Actual Problem: the amount of IP law you'd have to trudge through in making enough books this accessible.
- krrishd 6y agoI also recently googled a quote, found it in a specific page in a book hosted on https://www.pagebypagebooks.com/ https://www.pagebypagebooks.com/, and just impulsively clicked through the whole book because it happened to capture my interest, and only "demanded" that I commit to a single page at a time. Hard to explain, but it felt more natural in that every-page-is-a-URL format to trivially bail at any page, without the weird apprehension I get from the same action in an e-reader / physical book. The website is super old/limited, but if all books were that trivial to access + click through, I think we'd see something more interesting here. Made me wonder how hard it'd be to convert the entirety of Project Gutenberg into that sort of Web 1.0 format automatically.
- nelsondev 6y ago> How do people build recommendation engines? One method, collaborative filtering with latent factor analysis, popularized by its efficacy in making recommendations on Netflix, is to use matrix multiplication to solve the problem. E.G. Let’s say you have all users (rows) x all books (columns), in a massive sparsely populated matrix, where the value is the rating that user gives a book. To make recommendations, the goal is to “guess“ what a user would rate a book they haven’t read, and if your guess is they would give it 5 stars, and then you recommend it, and the user gives it 5 stars, it’s a good recommendation. The “latent factor” idea is breaking the problem up, so in order to compute the rating matrix that is the final size N users by M books, you split it into: N users x D latent factor (cross product) D latent factor x M books = N users x M books It then becomes a machine learning problem, using a loss function plus gradient descent, to solve for that D latent factor. Customers with a similar latent factor, will have similar taste. Once you have the latent factors, you find the nearest neighbors (the closest other latent factor vectors measured by dot product or cosine similarity), to compute the nearest books. The vectors that multiply together to give the highest rating, will be the best recommendations for the user.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- moomin 6y agoEveryone wants to fix Goodreads except Amazon.
- Jemaclus 6y agoMy problem with Goodreads isn't the recommendations engine. The recommendations are fine. I'm actually skeptical that any ML recommendation engine is going to recommend better books than my friends will. The only thing I expect from a recommendation engine is discovery, by which I mean finding new things that neither I nor my friends have read that look interesting. Whether they're good is another story altogether... My problem with Goodreads is actually the site performance. It's one of the most abysmally slow sites I've ever had the displeasure of using. Loading from page to page takes so long, I wonder if they're running on 486 machines in the background. It's unfathomable to me how something that has such a monopoly on the domain can have such terrible performance. It's so bad, that I often don't even bother going to Goodreads except when my TBR pile empties out, and then I spend as little time as I can (which is a long time because it's OH MY GOD SO SLOW) so I won't have to visit it again for a while. I wish it was open source, or something, so I could contribute to improve response times...
- BelleOfTheBall 6y agoMy most hated part of Goodreads is that if you type something in search and try to click the middle mouse button to open the resulting, highlighted book in the new window... it just copies the page you're already on. It's a site for discovering books, why do I have to open the landing page 5 times if I want to open 5 books? It's so counterintuitive to me.
- captn3m0 6y agoIt isn't just me!
- WrtCdEvrydy 6y agoDiscovery engines are pretty easy if you just use clustering unless you allow transitivity (book in two clusters can be used to suggest a book in either cluster)
- watwut 6y agoIf it is so easy, why most of them sucks?
- shostack 6y agoOne of the best parts of Goodreads for me is the Listopia search. Regular search doesn't get me much, but this search is fantastic for going really niche on certain topics.
- mmanfrin 6y agoMy wish: show me all the books my friends have reviewed, and allow me to sort by number of reviews. I want to see what a plurality of my friend recommend.
- giberson 6y ago> My idea for an 11-star experience 1 in finding new books is that Goodreads knows me even better than I know myself and constantly recommends the perfect book. > goodreads shows me five books that I don’t want to read. I wonder if these two ideas are at odds with each other. Imagine for a moment that recommendation engines were solved problems, and definitely worked given the above statement. They know you better than you know yourself. Would it’s recommendations likely only include books that you obviously wanted to read? Or would they include books you didn’t know you wanted or needed to read? I mean this in terms of judging the books by their cover rather knowing about their existence. Isn’t it likely or even probable that the majority of books recommended would be based on the value they contribute to something deeper than the pure enjoyment purposes? As an aside, I remember in a college literature class I took the instructor told us that it’s up to the reader to derive value or meaning from stories. This was a class that studied short stories of early American authors. Most of which were slice of life narratives that didn’t have any apparent meaning, or commentary from the authors themselves. The exercise was to study the characters, scenery and tone and try derive what might either lie beneath the words or story themselves. Whether the ideas we deduced from the stories were accurate (and in most cases probably were not) the value Of the process was of critical thinking about the stories that made us consider and express ideas and beliefs we normally don’t. Back on topic, would a working recommendation engine likely suggest things that on the surface seemed either boring or blatantly unappealing that would provide tremendous value if we put work in to reading and studying? That being said, is it possible that current recommendation engines are already working? Most are at least driven by reading behaviors of the masses, so it seems like it might be feasible that that Steven king book that is unappealing to you is something you should actually read. (This is not including recommendations for books you have already read in different languages which seems like an obvious bug, but then again reading books you’ve already read in different languages might be an excellent way to become more fluent in a new language or gain a deeper understanding of translation of ideas between languages....) So, maybe the tech isn’t something that needs to be fixed. Maybe we just need to be open to what the tech is telling us?
- matsemann 6y agoI think you are right. Being recommended a book I've never heard about by some author I'v never heard of by some computer system, I'm probably gonna dismiss it. However, if I've seen it in a bookstore, read about it in a paper, heard a friend talk about it etc. then I might act on the recommendation. Basically being exposed to something enough times. First time and a cursory look, most things don't look to exciting. This goes for everything. Movies, restaurants, gadgets..
- anonreader123 6y agoI am a Goodreads employee. this is a burner account. i could be fired for posting. we love Goodreads and we know it is bad today. we are working to fix it. there are very few of us. we are trying. we are making big changes soon.
- zygy 6y agoMany thanks.
- jonathanwallace 6y agoBest of luck and thank you.
- recuter 6y agoHow many of you are there?
- anonreader123 6y agonot enough.
- O_H_E 6y agoMy heart by with you fellow human. Thanks for trying to make the world a little better even under less-than-ideal conditions.
- darkerside 6y agoWhat are the most important changes that your team is prioritizing? What are your biggest challenges with making them?
- anonreader123 6y agoI want to be specific but I would get fired if they saw. but we read EVERY post about us. we are being ambitious and big changes are coming. biggest challenge is there is too much to do and we have so few staff.
- 50 6y agoHaven't used it myself since it's in beta but I have been keeping my eyes on this for a while: https://beta.readng.co/ https://beta.readng.co/, https://twitter.com/readngco https://twitter.com/readngco
- buttscicles 6y agoHi, I'm building this! Thanks for sharing. It's pretty basic right at the moment and we've a lot left to build (largely a reading list only, we've got more in the works) – but here's my profile as a preview, since our marketing site & messaging needs a bit of work: https://beta.readng.co/user/joe https://beta.readng.co/user/joe
- ibn_khaldun 6y agoUser name checks out. Lots of gratuitous butt-cleavage on the site. Looks nice and I am interested. But why all the butts?????
- greggh 6y agoOne of the things I always wished was built into goodreads was a good system for running a book club. They have groups, and those are close. But it just seems like they took Facebook groups and tried to make it work for a book club. It doesn't feel right to me. Is that something thats on your roadmap?
- ilolu 6y agoreadng looks really cool. Where do you get the books data about authors, description, cover images etc ?
- johnfn 6y agoGood lord what I wouldn’t give for a better goodreads. Never has so much useful and actionable data been squandered. For example, I could write pages about how bad the “top books” lists are. The Goodreads Choice Awards are purely and literally popularity contests, for example. Why would this be the case - you have millions of user ratings, you should be using those to surface exciting and unknown books rather than throwing people back at the same few authors they already know. The lists work exactly the same way - they discard ratings entirely and only take into account the quantity of books. It would be as if you said that the top 40 is the best music because everyone listens to it. So you don’t think I’m all talk, a while back I got so fed up with this that I wrote my own script to scrape goodreads and find the actual best books, not just the most popular, and I found a wealth of really good and unknown books, including two books that are now my favorite books of all time. It was a side project that took me an hour. Why goodreads can’t do this is utterly beyond me. Aaaargh!!!
- PaulStatezny 6y agoWould you share the titles and authors of those two books?
- johnfn 6y agoInfinite jest by David foster wallace and only forwards - forget the author name off the top of my head. Infinite jest is pretty popular these days. The other I have yet to hear anyone say they have read.
- tomstuart 6y agoI’ve read Only Forward by Michael Marshall Smith. It stuck in my mind the same way that Vurt did. I still think about the man with no head sometimes, and the idea of a road being different when you’re going the other way on it.
- defen 6y agoLiking Infinite Jest suggests an interest in American literary maximalism and / or comic novels. Suggestions: The Sot-Weed Factor, Gravity’s Rainbow, Mason & Dixon, Underworld, and if you’re feeling particularly masochistic The Tunnel
- monksy 6y agoHonestly, I feel that most tech goes this way when you have a monoply. Everything has a nature lifecycle, theres new life, interest, peak, and death/replacement. However, with some of these large corps (i.e. Amazon in this case), they can choose to hamper the growth and avoid competition. A lot of our tech can/should be a lot better than what it is. Use the tech to help people collaborate/get together/share. That was the great thing about reddit in it's hayday.
- cpsempek 6y agoI'm skeptical of this person's ability to "know" what they don't want to read. E.g., they are recommended Shoe Dog and a King novel, which they claim they don't want to read. However, if other people have read similar books and rated them similarly to this person and have read Shoe Dog and that King novel and rated those well, then this person may like those books. It seems they are assuming they won't like them, but not for particularly strong reasons. One of my favorite authors is Haruki Murakami and I would have rated Colorless Tsukuru a 2 or 3. If that were the only Murakami novel I had read and I made the same assumptions this person made, I would have missed out on some of my favorite books.
- lazyasciiart 6y agoHuh, I get recommended Murakami a lot but really didn't enjoy Colorless - maybe I'll try a different one.
- pilsetnieks 6y agoTry something pre-2010. The 2010s aren't really representative of his other work nor, to be honest, quite as good as his earlier books.
- cpsempek 6y agoIf you are looking for more of magical realism Murakami has become known for, I highly recommend Hard-Boiled Wonderland, The Wind-Up Bird Chronicle. But really anything 1Q84 and earlier is good IMO.
- zeroonetwothree 6y agoColorless is one of his worst books IMO. I would recommend Hard-Boiled Wonderland and the End of the World or Kafka on the Shore.
- prepend 6y agoI feel the same way in that I wonder if maybe I would like it if I read it. For the King book, my wife read it and we talked about it and I just don’t want to read it. For the Knight book, I read the first few pages and know the Nike story and don’t want to read it. Maybe I’m missing out and they are truly amazing. But I can’t read all that they recommend just in case they suddenly get great at recommending. It’s a challenging problem and the risk of missing out is there. But I don’t know of any way to truly eliminate the risk unless I read every book recommended. And my life isn’t long enough.
- manigandham 6y agoI don't create about recommendations as much. I get those from other sources and already have enough of a backlist to last a life time. Goodreads for me is for storing my history and ratings. Same with IMDB for movies. Both sites are terrible (and owned by Amazon), but I don't see much value in clones that don't do anything completely new.
- michaelmrose 6y agoIs the recommendation engine bad on average or bad for you?
- Minor49er 6y agoOne thing I'd add about the UX is that the search bar is buried below the fold on the homepage of the desktop version. Everywhere else, even on mobile, it's at the very top. It makes it a little more difficult to just jump to their site and start searching.
- esquire_900 6y agoAfter reading and heavily agreeing with this post, I came to the conclusion that either goodreads is not really trying, or -more likely- the data is just not good enough to make decent recommendations. There are so many biases in the review data that are impossible to fix in any kind of sparse matrix recommendation algorithm. For those who want to try anyway, it might be worth downloading an existing dataset (1) (104 million reviews) and try, before worrying about scraping and api limits. The only solution (in my experience) is to get some other way of quantifying content, like Spotify does by manually labelling tracks. After some ddg I found storygraph (2), which does this. Its search engine is quite impressive, might be worth trying. [1] https://sites.google.com/eng.ucsd.edu/ucsdbookgraph/home https://sites.google.com/eng.ucsd.edu/ucsdbookgraph/home [2] https://beta.thestorygraph.com https://beta.thestorygraph.com
- kobe_bryant 6y agothe problem is that when you step out of genre fiction, you cant just recommend a book with a similar plot or setting, it needs to have a similar style of writing and sensibility and thats very hard to determine. the best way is friending/following people and learning their tastes compared to yours e: if you go to a specific book and look up similar books, goodreads actually does a pretty good job https://www.goodreads.com/book/similar/1994351-j-r https://www.goodreads.com/book/similar/1994351-j-r
- lstamour 6y agoI would think that Amazon with Look Inside The Book and Kindle eBooks has enough data to do this, if anyone can?
- sfjailbird 6y ago> the best way is friending/following people and learning their tastes compared to yours If only goodreads could somehow find others who like the same things you do and use it for recommendations! Joking aside, they might already be doing that, but if so, they suck at it. They have enormous datasets of people and their tastes, yet their recommendations always seem to be simply matching genres that you happened to like a book from. You liked Watership Down? Here are 10 other books with talking animals! If you and I can successfully identify people we share tastes with, then goodreads should be able to, too, they have even more data to base this on.
- mekarpeles 6y agoHowdy, Mek here -- I run https://openlibrary.org https://openlibrary.org over at the non-profit Internet Archive (the folks that bring you the Wayback Machine). Open Library is an free, online California Library with millions of digital books to read and borrow. It's additionally an open catalog of millions of books which you may track like goodreads. Best part? If it's not to your liking, the whole project is open source! https://github.com/internetarchive/openlibrary https://github.com/internetarchive/openlibrary Open Library has a very strong volunteer tribe of book-loving librarians, developers, and designers working to make the project better for our community. We meet once a week at 11:30am PT. Ask me for the link: mek+ol@archive.org RIGOROUS BOOK RECOMMENDATIONS: We're also cultivating a 2nd non-profit open source experiment called TheBestBookOn.com (it leverages Open Library's catalog) which allows book-lovers to ask for or make rigorous book recommendations: https://github.com/Open-Book-Genome-Project/TheBestBookOn.com https://github.com/Open-Book-Genome-Project/TheBestBookOn.co... It's a very early prototype (we discuss development during our weekly Open Library call). It's being organized by Lauren Milliken, Aasif Khan, and myself and we'd love more contributors to join the discussion: mek+bbo@archive.org
- mekarpeles 6y agoThe philosophy behind thebestbook.com (which is currently just a looks-like demo -- you should help us implement it!) follows this essay on Less Wrong: https://www.lesswrong.com/posts/xg3hXCYQPJkwHyik2/the-best-textbooks-on-every-subject https://www.lesswrong.com/posts/xg3hXCYQPJkwHyik2/the-best-t... Recommendations are better when you have enough info to draw a line rather than consider a single point. There are many websites online which give you detailed reviews. But how does their review compare to other similar books? And has this reader also read those books? Thebestbookon.com requires a reviewer to have read 3 books and justify choosing one of them as a winner (like a college basketball bracket).
- rexpop 6y agoFellow Goodreads refugees, you can import your lists into OpenLibrary.org. 1. Export: https://www.goodreads.com/review/import https://www.goodreads.com/review/import 2. Import: https://openlibrary.org/account/import https://openlibrary.org/account/import
- jacobobryant 6y ago> Why would they recommend this book? If they're using collaborative filtering, there probably isn't a simple explanation. Basically, you feed in a list of "<user id>, <book id>, <rating>" and the algorithm generates a feature vector for each book and each user. So the reason some book gets recommended is because... the dot product of that book's vector with your vector was high. You can do this easily with off-the-shelf libraries, like Surprise[1] (I'm using that lib in my startup[2]). At least this is what happens in matrix factorization methods. Recommendations from k-nearest neighbor methods can be explained more easily, but knn doesn't scale as well. This is a minor drawback of matrix factorization--people have been shown to trust recommendations more if they understand how the recommendations were generated. Twitter recently published a super interesting paper[3] about how they generate recommendations at scale, and as a bonus their method is explainable. They create a model that describes the communities in Twitter--groups of people who follow the same set of influencers. Users and items are represented by vectors, where each element of a vector describes to what degree a user/item fits in a certain community. When generating recommendations, you can get the user's top communities and then fetch items for those communities. If you generated a text description for each community, you could include that with each recommendation. [1] https://github.com/NicolasHug/Surprise https://github.com/NicolasHug/Surprise [2] https://findka.com/ https://findka.com/ [3] https://www.kdd.org/kdd2020/accepted-papers/view/simclusters-community-based-representations-for-heterogeneous-recommendatio https://www.kdd.org/kdd2020/accepted-papers/view/simclusters...
- buovjaga 6y agoThere is at least https://gitlab.com/Alamantus/Readlebee https://gitlab.com/Alamantus/Readlebee "An attempt at a viable alternative to Goodreads", in active development. Blog post from yesterday: https://robbie.antenesse.net/2020/09/11/one-year-of-readlebee.html https://robbie.antenesse.net/2020/09/11/one-year-of-readlebe... Edit: oh, there is also Bookwyrm, as mentioned in this megalist: https://git.feneas.org/feneas/fediverse/-/wikis/watchlist-for-activitypub-apps#reviewing https://git.feneas.org/feneas/fediverse/-/wikis/watchlist-fo...
- ericmcer 6y agoOne interesting facet of all these recommendation and ratings systems online (Yelp, Goodreads, Rotten Tomatoes, etc.) is that they don't provide a key value that in person recommendations do. When a person recommends a restaurant they are attaching blame for the restaurants performance to themselves. Its performance is a reflection on them and their credibility. It is very hard to replicate this on the internet, a place where people can suggest things with very little responsibility. If I strongly suggest a movie to someone and the movie sucks, I can be blamed for that. I don't know how to replicate that comfortable eschewing of responsibility that in person recommendations provide.
- rexpop 6y agoIs this a good thread under which to have a more general discussion about data ownership and access? Goodreads is a Schelling point for book reviews, reading lists, and personal catalogs, but the API leaves something to be desired, not to mention the UI. Why shouldn't the Goodreads database be accessible to other applications? Why shouldn't the data be stored locally, or on our "own cloud"? Why can't we fix what's wrong with it? It's maddening that sites' UI is locked down, unfixable.
- BlueScreenDeath 6y agoI believe my site fixes that problem but Mods here keep removing the link. Lets see if they remove it like this: AudioBookReviews . com
- Nemo_bis 6y agoThere are many Goodreads competitors. To the others already mentioned, I'll add https://inventaire.io/ https://inventaire.io/ , which is fully free software and based on open data (Wikidata). It's useful if you want to have full control on your own book catalogue while not having to produce all the data yourself.
- hganesan 6y agoI’ve been building a prototype over at https://longtweetsapp.com https://longtweetsapp.com because I’ve had the same problems. It’s hard to find books so I took a more personalized, data-driven approach, starting with Twitter networks, because I was tired of bestseller and most popular lists. It’s still early goings, but I’d love feedback - I’m dogfooding it with interesting results. Send me a note: hareesh.ganesan+longtweets@gmail.com
- paxys 6y agoBook rating and recommendations are an impossible problem to begin with. If you browse through Goodreads, you will see that everything is rated 4 stars. People only finish and rate books they like, and it's impossible to compare books of different genres, lengths, time periods, complexity etc. on the same objective scale like it is for movies or TV shows.
- lkbm 6y agoSo look at which books I finished and rated highly, find people who overlap strongly with that, and recommend the set of {their books - my books}. As I recall, this is basically what won the Netflix recommendation engine contest. There's going to be a lot of computation in crunching the numbers, but it's not hard to come up with something better than "recommend what has the highest average star rating".
- dwighttk 6y agoI don’t care about reviews or recommendations. I have a to-read list that will last me the rest of my life easily. The thing I hate about goodreads is there are two search fields one to search books you’ve read and one to search every book. I’ve wanted to search books I’ve read like 5 times in my life but for some reason I always end up using the only search books I’ve read search bar and I get no results. Just make it a checkbox or return two lists or something.
- newbie578 6y agoThe status quo regarding Goodreads and it's position in the industry is really interesting. There is not a single competent alternative to Goodreads, yet Goodreads just sucks! As simple as that, the UI is horrible, the UX is disgusting, the perfomance is that of toaster and still people are using it. I personally am using it for the last 5 years while continuously searching unsuccessfully for alternatives. If you think the website is bad, you should check out the Android app, never in my life have I seen a worse app by a popular company. I got so frustrated by Goodreads that on multiple occasions I thought of starting a competing product just to challenge the status quo, but as soon as I started dwelling deeper into it, I realized that there is just no real viable business model for it to be worth it. I guess that explains the current status of Goodreads and why there are so few competitors. How do you monetize a social network about reading books? I have spent way too much time thinking about it, yet failing to achieve a result. 1)You can't really sell books, since Amazon is already so well entrenched and honestly books aren't a really hot commodity. 2)Subscription for audiobooks? Again there is Audible, and Scribd is also doing a phenomenal business doing it, you pay $9 and listen to as many as you want audiobooks. 3)Affiliate marketing? Goodreads already does it, and it isn't really a business model with a good foundation. 4)Customized ads? This might be the "least" worst solution, although what could you advertise to people who read books? Their LTV (lifetime value of customers) isn't really high. 5)A paid social network? Good luck trying to grow a social network which asks it's users to pay $1 monthly. 6)The latest and craziest idea I had regarding it, was to make it a hybrid of Goodreads and LinkedIn. Where employers can see what types of books are their applicants reading. I.e. if I am looking to hire a backend intern, I am sooner going to hire the intern who read in his free time Effective Java, Clean Code, etc. since you can pretty much gain a good overall picture about a person by looking at the books he reads. I spent way too much time obsessing over this...
- freddie_mercury 6y ago> I realized that there is just no real viable business model for it to be worth it I think this is key. It is kind of amazing that on a site all about startups and finding "product/market fit" every single thread about goodreads completely ignores any aspect of viability and expects someone else to just spend money for purely aesthetic reasons like it is a charity project. Is goodreads perfect? Good lord no. If I owned it, would I spend money trying to improve the search or the mobile app? Hell no. Hire 5 developers at $1 million/year to...what exactly? Is a better mobile app going to translate to tens of millions of dollars of revenue somehow? It isn't like LibraryThing or StoryGraph or BookSloth or Riffle are actually any good and they have 5+ years of development to solve all the alleged issues. Yet everyone in this thread complaining about Goodreads is still using Goodreads instead of them.
- YetAnotherNick 6y agoIsn't it the same problem with Amazon? It shows me different versions of the 5 products I last viewed. And unlike, goodreads it seems like there is clear monetary value for amazon in fixing product recommendations but somehow it is the same for years.
- alehul 6y ago> I wish there was some way to note books that I don’t want to read. Minor point but there is a "Not interested" button in the screenshot shown above this paragraph. While Goodreads' initial suggestions were off-the-mark, I wonder if using that would help?
- viiralvx 6y agoA buddy of mine has started on a better designed alternative to Goodreads. It's in early access right now but it has potential and I'm looking forward to seeing what else he adds to it: https://readng.co https://readng.co
- dang 6y agoThe earlier related thread: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=24451428 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=24451428
- DavideNL 6y agoFun fact: for like 2 years long, every time i opened Goodreads.com i saw the exact same sentence: "Because Deborah liked.... she discovered...." The exact same books/text for about 2 years. Torture...
- munificent 6y ago> They recommend different versions of books I’ve read. They recommend two different versions of Lord of the Rings (one of my favorite books), but I guess they don’t know these are the same book. This is failure mode of recommendations is so common and so catastrophically useless that I do not understand how it has not been solved. I'm into photography, so every now and then I buy a lens from Amazon. Immediately after I do, every Amazon ad banner on every website in the world switches to advertising that specific lens, for like the next month (I guess until I buy something else). Lenses are very specific, expensive, and singular. There is almost no reason to ever have two of the same lens. The day after I buy a lens, it is practically the least likely product in the world that I will buy. Show me anything but that. I mean, actually, don't. I like this failure mode because it makes it easy to tune out the ads. If they showed me related gear (perhaps filters that fit the lens), I might get suckered into spending more. But, seriously, how is this not fixed?
- jon-wood 6y agoI’ve had this same thing happen with so many large purchases. If I’ve just bought a washing machine the odds of me wanting another one the next day are astronomically small, unless they think I’m in the process of starting a small laundromat.
- prepend 6y agoI think this is because the ad networks don’t have insight to your purchase data. So they don’t know if you’ve bought and converted or not, but know that people who searched for something are more likely to buy if advertised the dickens out of for the next few weeks. That’s my theory at least, but even Amazon will show ads for stuff I bought on amazon. Not sure if that’s just them being stupid.
- vhpoet 6y agoI'm trying to tackle a small part of this by building https://www.readthistwice.com https://www.readthistwice.com which gives contextual recommendations from 1300+ leaders. What I mean by contextual in this case is every recommendation comes with a verified quote from the recommender on why they recommend the book.
- jtth 6y agoEveryone's talking about recommendations. I don't use GoodReads recommendations at all. It's a social network with a focus on books where people will actually read and discuss books and book reviews. It's also a good way of chronicling what books you read. I wish they'd focus more on that part.
- sohkamyung 6y agoI use Goodreads to post my reviews of books I've read. But I'm looking for a way to post reviews for individual short stories found online or in fiction magazines, anthologies, etc. The reviews should automagically pop up whenever the story appears in any other place. But I haven't found any sites that does this. For example, I read and review Story X in anthology Y. If the story appears or appeared online at Z, printed in magazine F, etc, my review for it also appears if I look it up there. Looking for recommendations for sites that do this.
- therealdrag0 6y agoditto. There's already too many books to read and recommendations everywhere.
- hombre_fatal 6y agoYeah, it's hard for me to take the complaint too seriously. The problem with books isn't that it's hard to find the good ones. It's that you get this tremendous backlog because you're short on time.
- kerryoco 6y agoWell put, that's the comment I no longer need to write :) Also, Goodreads is OLD ! Well before good recommendation engines were standard.
- ilolu 6y agoIf one has to build a Goodreads competition, How can one go about getting books data, book cover images etc ?
- marcusverus 6y agoThe Google Books API might be a good starting place. https://developers.google.com/books/ https://developers.google.com/books/
- SXX 6y agoI think building project around such obscure Google API is too much of risk. It's can be discontinued literally any moment.
- compscistd 6y agoI saw “amazon book clubs” today as a preview and wondered how indiebound integration could help make a third party book club a reality
- nazgulnarsil 6y agoI just want to be able to find people who like the same obscure books I do.
- disposekinetics 6y agoI just checked my Goodreads recommendations. It is very good at recommending books by authors I really do not care for in genres I really enjoy. I wonder if these kinds of systems fall over for that situation.
- bootcampwhere 6y agoI've been building: https://Audiobook https://Audiobook reviews.com for another approach that gives the user a lot more freedom.
- noisy_boy 6y agoFor all the AI and machine learning being thrown in the pot of every dish being made, they still haven't figured out that if I just bought a flashlight, I'm not likely to get a double-pack to save $2 anytime soon.
- aasasd 6y agoI'd like to propose a different thing to fix first: when I open that page, I can't scroll with the keyboard unless I first click in the main content area. I.e. the focus is initially somewhere else.
- awaxman11 6y agoHas anybody ever used stack ranking to power book recommendations? Instead of rating books on a scale of 1-5 star you instead rate each book relative to every other book you’ve ever read. Some other factors that I think could be used to create a high quality book recommendation engine on top of stack ranking: number of books read (the top 5 books from someone who has read 200+ books is a stronger signal than someone who has read 10 books) and release date (give extra weight to older books to reduce recency bias). What do you think? Am I onto something or just spewing some sat night nonsense?
- sam_lynx 6y agoI think this could work, although perhaps in combination, not replacement, with the traditional ranking system. The book on the bottom of somebody’s list isn’t necessarily a bad one.
- achileas 6y agoAre all books comparable linearly like this though? I could see separate stack ranks for different genres (practical books, sci-fi, relationships, whatever), attributes (readability, teachability if applicable, subject matter interest), or more. I also can't help but think in graphs, so I could also see horizontal-ish linkages between the stacks as well. Each book, then, could have a number of attributes that get an independent stack ranking for each one, leaving you with a constellation score as well as a focused look at what the book is good at or focused on. I could see it getting unwieldy though. Thinking through this, maybe genre stacks based on some collapse of attribute ranking scores.
- switch11 6y ago3 of the things most people miss is A) The intersection between people who love books and love technology is rather small B) There is no 'monetization ramp up' when producing products for books and publishing Monetization if you are a startup in books and publishing is via either Amazon Associate - However, Amazon will kick you out if they want to enter the same business Example: https://the-digital-reader.com/2016/06/15/amazon-brings-the-hammer-down-on-discount-ebook-sites/ https://the-digital-reader.com/2016/06/15/amazon-brings-the-... Selling Ads to Authors & Publishers - However Amazon will manipulate results Example: https://the-digital-reader.com/2017/11/22/amazon-now-punishing-authors-running-bookbub-promotions/ https://the-digital-reader.com/2017/11/22/amazon-now-punishi... so there is no easy path Contrast that with something like Apps or Shopping where you can use affiliate networks and monetize right from the start. And a competitor like Google doesn't have control over the Affiliate networks (which in books, Amazon has) C) Most authors are not tech savvy and keep doing crazy things like giving exclusivity to one store and create monopolies. They then get screwed by these monopolies Why would you step into a market where A) The competitors are monopolists who have no compulsion against doing illegal things B) The participants (authors and Publishers) are in the 1950s technology wise C) The participants (authors and publishers) keep doing strange stuff like give one ebook store exclusivity CONTRAST what happened with Apps versus what happened with Books Apps Amazon wanted pricing control of apps and exclusivity. Developers gave them the middle finger Amazon tried unlimited apps (including unlimited IAP purchases if you are on subscription) and developers didn't play along. They had to close down the service Books There were FIVE major stores - Kindle, Sony, Apple, B&N, Kobo Amazon offered exclusivity to authors in return for (the comically bad incentive) - allowed to make book free for 5 days every 90 days, allowed to discount book as a special Kindle Countdown Deal for 7 days every 90 days Authors gave Amazon exclusivity. Helped it get from 30-40% market share to 60-70% market share Now completely dependent on Amazon Kindle Unlimited - Amazon won't give authors and publishers data on how many people borrow, etc. Only 'total number of pages read' Authors play along and now many are completely dependent on income from this 'subscription service' where they don't even know how many readers downloaded their book, how many read X% etc. Just one vague metric of 'total pages read by all readers' So, to do well in this market you are suited for it IF A) Your default is to take advantage of authors and publishers OR treat them like naive sheep who don't understand the basics of business B) You are willing to go up against a large monopoly that will also do illegal things without remorse Amazon just hired Keith Alexander - head of NSA during warrantless surveillance Do you really want to compete against that? C) somehow bridge the gap between books and publishing and technology while keeping in mind that most of the top quality supply is controlled by 5 large companies (the Big 5 very big publishers) You would be hard pressed to find ANY business to go into that is worse The saying - An intelligent enemy is better than a stupid friend This is an ecosystem where - your friends are naive (in effect, clueless), and your enemies are stupid (doing all sorts of illegal things because they are a monopoly and know the US does @#$$-all to monopoly power abusing companies
- theodorewiles 6y agoInstead of jumping to a recommendation engine, I would think about the analog solution (e.g. nybooks.com, newcriterion.com). Pretty much has solved my book recommendation pain point.
- Paradigma11 6y agoThe most important feature of goodreads for me is: https://www.goodreads.com/new_releases/2020/9 https://www.goodreads.com/new_releases/2020/9 This shows you new releases of authors whose books you have read. The recommendations basically crapped out on me after a few hundred books. It seems there are a few cliques (graph) of recommendations that are pretty independent and if you have read these cliques in a genre recommendations just suck. But plz give me some query syntax like https://docs.microsoft.com/en-us/windows/win32/lwef/-search-2x-wds-aqsreference https://docs.microsoft.com/en-us/windows/win32/lwef/-search-... and most importantly the ability to filter out certain tags.
- wosc 6y agoSeconded. The "new releases of authors I've read books from" is one of the things that would give me the most value -- if it actually worked properly, which for me it doesn't, since it only seems to show _some_ random new books from _some_ of "my" authors. Sigh.
- alan_n 6y agoI love goodreads, but I've wished for so long for two things way more basic than good recommendations which I don't really care about (except the finding people with similar ratings, I would kill for that): - Proper search engine (all books with x+ ratings, rated y+ start, in genre z). From what I've heard one has to scrape the site to get any useful information. - Forbidding rated reviews before release dates. This seriously skews ratings for some genres and is insanely annoying. Okay maybe three... managing shelves is super slow. I want to be able to drag and drop and have things instantly re-ordered without a reload.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- Donckele 6y agoNice write up and great Jeff Bezos story!
- hellified 6y agoYou should check out: https://beta.thestorygraph.com/ https://beta.thestorygraph.com/ It's still in beta but I've tried it and like it a lot. One thing that it's missing that is holding me back from a full jump over to it is an android app. The mobile site looks good, but I think an app would substantially improve usability.
- b0rsuk 6y agoDoes anyone know a (ML-based) recommendation system for video games? I've never heard of one, except perhaps Steam?
- lmarcos 6y agoHi HN. I come from a parallel universe in which book recommendation systems are not based on genre, ratings or communities. Book recommendations are based on their content. (A silly idea I have been thinking about: https://www.lessmarcos.com/posts/2020/09/content-based-recommendation-systems/ https://www.lessmarcos.com/posts/2020/09/content-based-recom...)
- ryzvonusef 6y agomake it like myanimelist or mydramalist, one of those sort of websites.... such websites were created by fans can cater to what fans care for: 1- Finding out what's coming next, in an easy to view format 2- Finding out what's related to the item I'm currently checking, and it's place in the overall verse's sequence 3- Damn simple tracker for the item I consume 4- Simple rating and genre system In other words, you want to fix goodreads? create a mybooklist. Because MAN it is SO hard to find out when my favorite author is having a new book coming out, or if I discover a new author, wtf is their flow of their book series, often ending in me accidentally reading the book out of order.