7 ms·
Who Was the Falling Man from 9/11? (2016)
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- RandomBacon 6y agoUnless there is some deep insight in the article, I feel like the person's identity is not something we need to know. It was a terrible situation. What benefit comes from knowing? Are we supposed to judge that person for not wanting to suffer slowly instead of taking a faster route? Or are we supposed to commend his bravery or sacrifice?
- d0mine 6y agoPeople prefer a personal story over statistics.
- srean 6y ago> Are we supposed to judge that person for not wanting to suffer slowly instead of taking a faster route? Speak for yourself there. As for me, identity makes him a person, a possessor of human qualities, something more than an increment operation on a counter.
- kryogen1c 6y ago> Speak for yourself there. What do you mean by this? OP's implication seems reasonably obvious. Are you saying it made more sense not to jump?
- srean 6y agoThat the call to be judgmental is OP's personal construction that he/she is trying to ascribe to others who likely do not share that trait.
- rendall 6y agoAgreed. It would humanize him to know who he was, what his interests were, who loved him I judge no one there. They all endured a terrifying tragedy that I hope never to comprehend. I cannot imagine what I would do if my choice were to burn in a fire or plummet hundreds of meters, but whatever my choice would be, I would begrudge no one their choices
- gammarator 6y agoMost of the article explores the question of exactly this reaction--why do we instinctively look away, even two decades later?
- Termious 6y agoUh, if you think the article is about discovering the falling man's identity, then you didn't really read the article.
- freedomben 6y agoEspecially these days when people are often so desensitized to violence, I think attaching identity does a good job of restoring our sense of humanity. When it's a distant person you know nothing of, their death may not be meaningful. When it's a husband, a father, a son, a daughter, the value of the life feels higher to us. As someone who thinks our world could greatly benefit from a big dose of empathy, compassion, and caring, I'm glad people are trying to tell these stories.
- watwut 6y ago> Are we supposed to judge that person for not wanting to suffer slowly instead of taking a faster route? Or are we supposed to commend his bravery or sacrifice? What about none of these? Why the need to assign value judgement to decision that person had to make and that did not affected other people?
- srean 6y agoSometimes one just needs to say thank you.
- gambiting 6y agoI'm always surprised that people chose to chastise and berate someone for trying to find facts and truth. The article talks about how trying to simply find out how many people jumped from the towers is met with disgust and condemnation, both in-person and online - with webpages dedicated to baiting people searching for it on google, and offering an offensive statement telling those people to get lost and that they should be ashamed of themselves for looking. I don't know, maybe something in my brain doesn't work quite right, but I never understood it - knowledge is knowledge. When we search for something, the desire to find the answer should never be shamed, even if the answer is shameful in itself.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- Pulcinella 6y agoBut they are not “just trying to find the facts,” they are running advertisements next to it in order to make money. I hope photos of my death are never used to help sell cheap t-shirts and truck bed liners.
- gambiting 6y agoThat's a....weird way of looking at it. The journalist is looking for the answers. The article they wrote is published on a website that runs ads. Yes, I suppose that technically the topic is used to make money since you wouldn't have visited the site otherwise. But it feels like saying that people are making money on Auschwitz, because there are ads along the way there - you wouldn't have seen them if you weren't going to Auschwitz, so clearly the holocaust is now selling you ads for cheap laptops, right?
- rriepe 6y agoIt's sort of like digging up the Tomb of the Unknown Soldier to find his identity.
- gambiting 6y ago
- User23 6y agoI don't mean this to be insensitive, but when I first saw that image I was struck by the resemblance to the Tarot card The Hanged Man.
- Uehreka 6y agoI read this article when it first came out four years ago. I’m not generally someone who needs/heeds trigger warnings (though I’m cool with having them for people who do) but this is probably one of the few pieces of journalism I’ve read that really viscerally fucked me up. I think it’s the way the first few paragraphs vacuum away the politics and history and just isolate these moments of true existential horror, then make you imagine them over and over again from different angles... Yeah, it’s a lot. I definitely recommend people read it. Read it because thinking about death is important. Read it because the questions about history and how we document it are important. Read it because it’s just damn good writing. But read it on a sunny afternoon with plans to do something fun later, because the headspace it puts you into isn’t somewhere you may want to stay too long. Your mileage may vary.
- JKCalhoun 6y agoAmerican — unaware there were so many photos, so much footage of falling people from September 11, 2001.