3 ms·
I'm in this camp as well: keep it for a while and see how we adjust. My initial reaction was negative. I found it harder to scan a long page of comments quic
by nkurz 16y ago
I'm in this camp as well: keep it for a while and see how we adjust.
My initial reaction was negative. I found it harder to scan a long page of comments quickly. And I'm not sure why, but I also found that I'm more resistant to vote, either positively or negatively. Maybe because the site feels more static.
The one fix I would suggest is that having the arrows disappear after voting does not feel fulfilling. It feels like my vote has been lost. Switching to displaying the darkened arrow that I chose would feel better.
Or, if more voting was thought to be a good thing, you could display the vote count only afterward. I think I'd be more inclined to vote if there was some sort of 'reward' for the action. The previous reward was seeing the number change in whatever direction I wanted to move it, but receiving information about others would probably work too.
- mooism2 16y agoI worry that if people could see vote counts after voting, they would start voting purely to see vote counts, upvoting (or downvoting) a comment not because it deserved it, but to see how many votes it had attracted.