4 ms·
I've been getting more upvotes since the scores were hidden. Maybe my comments were better, or maybe groupthink was holding people back, but either way, my karm
by dkersten 16y ago
I've been getting more upvotes since the scores were hidden. Maybe my comments were better, or maybe groupthink was holding people back, but either way, my karma has increased wince the scores were hidden, so.. I'm all for keeping it how it is. :-D
Seriously, though, I kinda like it without scores, because I don't get inadvertently suckered into voting to go along with the crowd (I try not to anyway, but sometimes it happens without thinking about it), while now I only vote if I feel the comment needs it (ie, the comment is very relevant and informative (up vote) or off topic/rude/irrelevant (down vote)).
- scott_s 16y agoI've seen the same behavior on my comments, and I think I'm upvoting more. I think what happens is that people upvote a comment based solely on their own judgement of it. I know that sometimes if I see a comment that I think is good, but it's at say, 30 points, I figure "Eh, it doesn't need any more points." Now, I have have some idea if others have voted top-level comments up based on their placement, but I still don't really know it's score. So I make sure it gets at least my vote.
- javert 16y agoTo echo the parent and grandparent of this, yeah, my personal experience of not showing comment votes has resulted in myself getting more upvotes and also feeling more engaged in voting on things.
- hristov 16y agoI have been getting the same experience. I actually got my first three digit karma comment soon after pg made the change. And I have been here for more then 2 years now. I think when there are visible comment scores people do not vote based on whether they like a comment or not, they vote based on whether a certain comment deserves the current karma or not. Thus, they are likely to downvote highly voted comments not because they disagree but because they think "this bastard does not deserve THIS much karma".