4 ms·
I have used goodreads since soon after launch. It’s probably the worst site that I use, but I prefer it’s benign neglect over the “improvements” made on the mai
by prepend 6y ago
I have used goodreads since soon after launch. It’s probably the worst site that I use, but I prefer it’s benign neglect over the “improvements” made on the main amazon site.
I just use it as a list of books of I’ve read and am reading, and to see books that my friends are reading or have read.
It’s been funny to me that the search is horrible and seems to be something worse than just regexing a list of book titles. But I eventually find what I’m looking for. It’s sucked as long as I can remember.
The recommendations are also really bad, it has never recommended a book to me that I thought was interesting or I ended up reading. This is despite having over a thousand read and rated books from me. I’ve been waiting for them to be able to search all the books I don’t know and find one that I will like.
I kind of like the site as it is quaint, but functional. It’s like a library in that way.
- a_bonobo 6y agoFor me, recommendations got remarkably better once I used 5-10 tags ('shelves') per book for about 50 books I read - after that, the per-shelf recommendations got very good.
- prepend 6y agoI never thought of that. Thanks, I’ll try it. I currently just use “read,” “want to read,” and “abandoned.”
- dorchadas 6y agoThe problem is if it's some obscure topic with a specific shelf, you can get some pretty bad books, as it seems to pull them based on other people's tags of books. Or, I can be reading academic works on Buddhism and then get recommended Alan Watts, who wasn't an academic and wasn't a Buddhist, but others tagged as 'Buddhism'. So there are still plenty of issues with it.
- matthewfelgate 6y agoWhat does this mean?
- a_bonobo 6y agoWhen you finish a book you can review it, or assign shelves. The default shelves are to-read and read but you can add many custom ones too. The shelves work like tags. Once you have a decent amount of books with tags, goodreads will start recommending books based on these tags. For example, if you have a 'non-fiction' shelf, goodreads will give you books others have rated high with the same tag at https://www.goodreads.com/recommendations/shelf/non-fiction https://www.goodreads.com/recommendations/shelf/non-fiction It's much more specific and for me works better than the 'because you read book X, you might like book Y' which is often very random.
- asicsp 6y agoI mostly use reddit [0][1][2] to build my TBR list. I follow only a few on goodreads, but my twitter timeline (which is mostly catered around book reading) comes up with nice recommendations. [0] https://www.reddit.com/r/Fantasy/ https://www.reddit.com/r/Fantasy/ [1] https://www.reddit.com/r/booksuggestions/ https://www.reddit.com/r/booksuggestions/ [2] https://www.reddit.com/r/suggestmeabook/ https://www.reddit.com/r/suggestmeabook/
- prepend 6y agoThanks, I use those subs as well. I think it’s more of whatever you call that “programmer anxious subliminal minmaxing” feeling that I get knowing that goodreads has all that info from me, and should be able to automatically help. I don’t have a shortage of books to read or anything and I have a system that works. But I suspect that there’s great books out there for me that I haven’t discovered yet and would like for technology to help with that. I mainly find books through serendipitous interactions and recommendations from friends and I read more books found accidentally than when I consciously seek out new books. It’s a problem with amazon and audible and my library too. They suck at recommending books. I think it’s just because they are happy if I just buy something, where I’m looking for five star books. So our incentives are different. I’ve spend quite a few saturdays trying to hack something from goodreads data to just do it myself. But I can’t get a good data export. I think if you just find people with at least 100 similar rating to me and then recommend books that they 5-star that would result in good stuff. The main downside of amazon buying them is that I used to wish for a breach of all their customer ratings data so I could just do the analysis on the leaked data (after de identifying the customers of course). But amazon has much better security. By the way, it seems like all the content companies are this way now. Netflix isn’t interested in me finding movies I love. Spotify is maybe the closest but I think they promote lots of stuff. I’ve been trying to think of a business model that relies on finding awesome matches, but I think there’s more money in finding marginal matches that bring customers back again. My current money is on getting local AI that I can train to serve me (instead of google, Microsoft, etc).
- Negitivefrags 6y agoI can’t think of a website in any domain where people don’t complain about recommendations. People complain about goodreads, Netflix, amazon, etc. Even things like google ads whose business is ultimately showing ads for products you might like to buy, a kind of recommendation algorithm, people constantly complain about irrelevance. And they have billions of dollars on the line for making that better, not to mention a dataset that is second to none about the internet using population. Maybe good recommendations is actually just super hard and nobody has really solved it well.
- boring_twenties 6y agoAmazon has gone down the shitter in more ways than one, but back in the day, circa 2005, I remember being downright amazed by their recommendation engine for music. Back then I would buy music on CDs. After a while I got into the habit of simply buying random stuff I've never heard of just based on their recommendation, and I don't recall a single instance when I regretted it.
- thorum 6y agoMusic recommendations seem to work OK. My Spotify discover playlists are always decent.
- brmgb 6y agoIt's hit and miss. Sometimes it's very decent. Most of the time my discover weekly playlist contains 95% of music I find plain bad.