4 ms·
I see you're already being downvoted, but I feel the same - I don't understand why does anyone have any of these devices at home. It's nuts. Yet apparently Alex
by gambiting 6y ago
I see you're already being downvoted, but I feel the same - I don't understand why does anyone have any of these devices at home. It's nuts. Yet apparently Alexa sold 50 million smart speakers or something like that.
- fergie 6y agoI read alot about them, but I have never come across one in the wild despite living in a fairly wealthy, gadget friendly environment. I agree that the whole idea of voluntarily installing something like this seems mind-blowingly nuts. Are real people actually using Alexa? If so- what for? Are there killer reasons for using Alexa like there are for, say, a Tesla or an iPhone?
- henrikschroder 6y agoIt would be very interesting to see how many bought them as a novelty, and then got tired of them and unplugged them.
- carlmr 6y agoI have three friends that own an Alexa. I think they bought it as a novelty and now it only replaces the Bluetooth speaker and looking at the weather. Still haven't seen a single reason to own one.
- quickthrowman 6y agoOne glance and swipe down in Dark Sky shows me more weather info than Alexa could tell me in two minutes, I don’t get the weather part.
- KingOfCoders 6y agoOwned three, threw all of them out. The AI was underwhelming in understanding, even finding music. We ended up using it to tell the time when sitting at the table without a computer. Now I own a wrist watch.
- dontcarethrow2 6y agoSome buy it to play music in their living spaces. My dad came back with a free Echo after moving his phone plan to Verizon. Thankfully I got him to be skeptical of it just because they are giving them away for free. Sibling got a google one for novelty. Over time they also stopped using, it got annoying having to plug it back in every time (since I dont let it stay plugged in). cus fuck google, amazon, fb, apple, microsoft, am I missing anyone? Samsung seems to stay lowkey but eff em too.
- rudiv 6y agoIMO the GP is being downvoted because irrespective of one's personal feelings regarding 'smart home' devices, it's difficult to see how someone could genuinely have never encountered any users of those devices (assuming you're living in the US). I can understand how someone extremely tech-savvy and cognizant of the privacy and other downsides of those devices may have friends who similarly would not use or purchase the same; but to have genuinely never seen one, whether it be in the home of a relative, an acquaintance, in popular television or movies - and having never read any reporting about their popularity - seems beyond the realm of possibility. Given that, the GP's question seems conceited. I can see how they might have intended to direct the question towards HN users in the assumption that most HN users would be wary of the aforementioned devices, in which case it'd be interesting to read the perspectives of those individuals who use them despite their downsides. But that isn't immediately evident.
- l33tman 6y agoWell the GP might not live in the US. I don't, and I have never seen anybody use one of those and I don't know anybody who does either, and I haven't seen them in series or movies either (except sci-fi AI movies). For all I know, an Alexa is just a device to order toilet paper from Amazon when it's out or maybe use it to turn on and off the light in the room if you're too lazy to do it yourself. Is the demographic that uses these preferentially si-valley people or is it widely spread in the US? BTW I'm not particularly against home AI assistants myself. But I'm fairly against streaming my audio to a third party that can transcribe and give everything to any snooping fourth party though :) I did read about Google doing this with their assistant's audio, it ended up at contractors doing manual transcribing.
- rudiv 6y agoI don't live in the US either. But this website is primarily US-focused, and most people on it readily assume the context for everything is the US, so I conform to the same habit. My anecdotal examples would be mostly middle-class families and college students in the US, not particularly valley-related. In my country these type of devices are on the market but not popular (only seen a couple), but they're priced out of the range of the majority of the population anyway.
- mysterydip 6y agoMy use case is small children and music. It's incredibly convenient to say "alexa, play songs by pink fong" or whatever they're in the mood for, while cleaning or cooking or what have you, compared to getting a phone or tablet out and browsing to the music app and trying to find the same song or playlist. Additionally, my oldest child can put music on for herself with her voice, but can't read or spell enough to do it otherwise.
- user5994461 6y agoSame, only seen one alexa at a friends with a child. They use it to play music. Alexa play christmas songs. Alexa pause. Alexa resume. That's all.
- BlueTemplar 6y agoYou could have this without the potential online security nightmare. I had an offline voice control WinAmp plugin ~15 years ago.
- mysterydip 6y agoIt has access to everything on amazon music, a much larger playlist than anything I own. I can also say "play show tunes" or "play 80s" and it will do that. I know about homebrew options. I've tried some of them. The problem is convincing others. They want something that works every time all the time, not something I have to fiddle with every so often. As for the security, it was my concern from day one, but when laypeople see the convenience and not some hidden boogeyman, you can't convince them otherwise. I lost that argument to my wife and it wasn't a hill I chose to die on. I'm just careful what I say openly, as you should anywhere. Plus we all carry phones around already.
- scarface74 6y agoWhether you understand why people own them, you didn’t claim to not know that people actually buy them.