17 ms·
Amazon’s Alexa for landlords is a privacy nightmare waiting to happen
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- simonjgreen 6y agoHuge presumption here that drop in won't be covered
- nieve 6y agoBut it's not entirely unwarranted given Amazon's history of their privacy declarations not being 100% reliable. Their track record isn't as bad as some companies, but I wouldn't trust them without an outside review and they're not going to let that happen for a host of reasions.
- simonjgreen 6y agoAgreed, just pointing out the basis of this article is an assumption that amazon won't have thought about drop in when thinking about their other privacy measures for this product.
- tonyedgecombe 6y agoIt’s called Alexa for Residential that, according to Amazon, “makes it easy for property managers to set up and manage Alexa-powered smart home experiences throughout their buildings.” That could get really dystopian.
- swarnie_ 6y agoWhat features dose it have? I'm used to rented properties where you get no control over things like the thermostat (which are all Hive managed) but that's roughly where i draw the line.
- hanoz 6y agoI would draw the line well before that.
- swarnie_ 6y agoWelcome to London baby. Draw whatever line you like just be prepared to sleep in the park.
- carlmr 6y ago>no control over things like the thermostat (which are all Hive managed) but that's roughly where i draw the line. I usually have the heater off except when it's below zero outside. I would be really mad if somebody heated my apartment against my will.
- have_faith 6y ago> I'm used to rented properties where you get no control over things like the thermostat In what country is this legal?
- quickthrowman 6y agoUm, the United States of America (depends on the state) In my state, landlords have to keep a property heated to a certain temperature during the winter, but there’s no law saying the landlord has to provide a thermostat. Many older buildings have a central boiler and radiators.. how do you propose thermostats in each unit with that setup?
- blibble 6y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Thermostatic_radiator_valve https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Thermostatic_radiator_valve
- tedunangst 6y agoYeah, that's great for turning off the radiator but does nothing for the pipe of pure magma running through the bathroom.
- lioeters 6y agoOne aspect I find particularly dystopian is the double-speak of "smart homes", "smart schools", "smart cities". Whenever I hear the term "smart", I associate it with the countless real-life examples of privacy violations (bordering on unconstitutional), security snafus, and the power it gives to authoritarian tendencies in private companies and public institutions.
- orthoxerox 6y agohttps://youtube.com/watch?v=iwqN3Ur-wP0 https://youtube.com/watch?v=iwqN3Ur-wP0
- jjcon 6y agoIn what way? Smart home control? Alexa demonstrably does not listen to your conversations and it would be illegal for a landlord to do so. This just seems like a nice way to build smart home abilities into a house or rental so people don’t have to bring a million bulbs/hubs/sensors with them everywhere.
- rcoveson 6y ago> Alexa demonstrably does not listen to your conversations I won't soon forget this story[0]. It listens to everything, and if it thinks it hears the start of a command it starts doing stuff with what it hears. That detection can have bugs, some of them practically unavoidable (like differentiating between a conversation about a person named Alexa and a command). Amazon themselves have said that "[voice] data is stored remotely" as opposed to on the device[1]. So it seems likely that most Alexa users have had at least some parts of a conversation in which they did not intend to involve Alexa stored on an Amazon server, and possibly reviewed by some number of employees[2]. I think the strongest thing you can say "demonstrably" about regarding Alexa is that it does not store _all_ your conversations. 0. https://www.kiro7.com/news/local/woman-says-her-amazon-device-recorded-private-conversation-sent-it-out-to-random-contact/755507974/ https://www.kiro7.com/news/local/woman-says-her-amazon-devic... 1. https://privacyinternational.org/news-analysis/2819/mystery-amazon-echo-data https://privacyinternational.org/news-analysis/2819/mystery-... 2. https://time.com/5568815/amazon-workers-listen-to-alexa/ https://time.com/5568815/amazon-workers-listen-to-alexa/
- jjcon 6y agoYou mean the story where she said send message and it did just that? Yeah accidents happen but this isn’t some nefarious amazon is spying on you story. This could happen on any smart phone and isn’t unique to smart speakers or amazon. > voice data is stored remotely No, it only sends your requests to the server after the wake word is said (so that it can process it). You can test this your self by monitoring your network traffic. It is demonstrable.
- rcoveson 6y ago
- kome 6y agopersonal curiosity: is there someone that uses those devices in real life?
- gambiting 6y agoI see you're already being downvoted, but I feel the same - I don't understand why does anyone have any of these devices at home. It's nuts. Yet apparently Alexa sold 50 million smart speakers or something like that.
- fergie 6y agoI read alot about them, but I have never come across one in the wild despite living in a fairly wealthy, gadget friendly environment. I agree that the whole idea of voluntarily installing something like this seems mind-blowingly nuts. Are real people actually using Alexa? If so- what for? Are there killer reasons for using Alexa like there are for, say, a Tesla or an iPhone?
- henrikschroder 6y agoIt would be very interesting to see how many bought them as a novelty, and then got tired of them and unplugged them.
- carlmr 6y agoI have three friends that own an Alexa. I think they bought it as a novelty and now it only replaces the Bluetooth speaker and looking at the weather. Still haven't seen a single reason to own one.
- quickthrowman 6y agoOne glance and swipe down in Dark Sky shows me more weather info than Alexa could tell me in two minutes, I don’t get the weather part.
- KingOfCoders 6y ago
- tikwidd 6y agoMy landlord installed a meth detector in my home which looks like a large smoke detector on the ceiling. It apparently communicates via the mobile network, but I have no idea how it actually measures meth. I doubt it actually measures anything (the product is made by http://www.methminder.co.nz/ http://www.methminder.co.nz/ but there is no actual information there). Point is, it makes tenants feel less secure. Which makes landlords feel more secure (ironically, products like these exploit the moral panic and lack of security that landlords feel regarding the meth crisis). Even if this Alexa for Landlords does nothing nefarious, its real purpose is to create that feeling of insecurity that landlords want. Maybe, just maybe, the landlord is listening. And we better not refuse the device because maybe they'll get the idea that we don't trust them...
- dkdk8283 6y agoWow, first time I’ve seen something like this. The pricing model is a little expensive too. What’s next? Weed detectors? War on drugs seems to be pure profiteering.
- bergstromm466 6y agoI think Sex Detectors... don't want your tenant to have sex and leave stains on your furniture! Sex is for hotels! "If you wanted to have sex, you should've checked the tenancy agreement before you signed it." Edit: this was my attempt at a joke! it's satirical
- smackay 6y agoThere is considerable scope for universities or any other organisation to ensure that assaults or even unwanted consensual activities are not taking place on their property. This raises the interesting question - now prevention is more practical and thus enforceable are we likely to see a tightening of behavioural standards and social norms either because the technology allows it or because that's the easiest way to avoid the technology. In either case it seems that a relaxed attitude to social behaviour may be on the way out.
- rbecker 6y agoThis reveals one giant cost usually not covered by rent vs. own economics: if you rent something, a car, a computer, a home, you don't control it. This is why we should all be very worried about the move towards as-a-service economies.
- tsss 6y agoIf you buy something you no longer control it either. Cars nowadays can be disabled remotely with the press of a button and are not repairable because you don't have access to the software.
- rbecker 6y agoThat is too often true. But at least you have the right to attempt to control it. Sadly even that is under attack, with laws against circumvention and "reverse engineering" (i.e. looking at how something works).
- II2II 6y agoRenting a home is a special case since housing is a necessity. It is heavily regulated because of that, but we have to be vigilent to ensure that regulations keep up with the times For most other items, the amount of control that you need really comes down to priorities. Given my use of computers, I buy the hardware and prefer open source applications since there is a large degree of control. When it comes to entertainment (games, music, etc.) rental is fine since they are not all that important. Some product categories is a blend of the two: some books I buy, others I "rent" (rather, borrow through libraries). As for Alexa for landlords, this may be a case where some laws need revision. Even if it is not used as a surveilance device, it must be classified as such since the potential is there. It doesn't matter whether that potential is used by Amazon, the landlord, or another authorized or unauthorized party.
- georgyo 6y agoPrivacy aside, this whole concept seems like it will flop. This is a great move for Amazon, but I don't really understand the benefit to renters or landlords. "Luxury" apartments in NYC used to have ipod/iphone docks in the wall the connected to the speaker system. Every single agent talked about this great feature, but it just looked awful. Besides the fact that I'm an Android user, the connector was pre lightning so at some point I'm sure the landlord has to upgrade everyone's wall dock. A feature that only some can use, and fewer will use. Only so they can seem extra fancy to a select crowd. The point of that antidote is that this Amazon "feature" will likely only be in "luxury" buildings as well. Most landlords don't even allow their rent to be paid online. I doubt they will get "alexa pay my rent" to work reliably. About half the people I know will not stand have any home spy devices in their home on principal alone, and the other half already have one. Putting this in you're building seems like a way to make half your renter base dismiss you, and redundant for the other half.
- carlmr 6y ago>Most landlords don't even allow their rent to be paid online. I felt like I traveled back to 1990 when I moved to Canada. In Germany I've never paid anything with cheque. We've always had free wire transfers. Online or offline is not visible even to the landlord. When I found out this doesn't work with Canadian banks I was flabbergasted. I moved back 10 years ago. Is this still the case in US/CAN?
- JeremyBanks 6y agoFor what it's worth, my last several landlords in Canada have accepted Interac E-Transfers (free instant domestic transfers up to $3000) for rent instead of post-dated cheques when I asked, and many of my friends say they do the same thing. I've only rented in America once, but in that case the property management company had their own online system that accepted (slow non-instant) bank transfers or (with a surcharge) credit cards.
- BlueTemplar 6y agoCovid might have changed things? A few months ago my landlord declared that cheques and cash were now forbidden.
- ralusek 6y agoI agree that this is nightmarish and gross, but I have another question. > But we all know landlords are, by default, shitty. What is with journalists for normal/non-political publications and Marxism/Maoism, particularly recently? I have literally never had a problem with a landlord. While I'm sure unpleasant landlords are as common as unpleasant people, I can't help but think that the only way to have had exclusively bad experiences with landlords would be where the tenant inherently sees the nature of their relationship as exploitative.
- ThePadawan 6y agoI can only congratulate you and offer a huge "YMMV". I personally have made really very bad experiences with multiple landlords so I can 100% of the author's sentiment. I certainly wouldn't consider it a political stance. I would say it's as much of a satirically accepted ground truth as "gyms generally try to screw you into an auto-renewing yearly contract."
- Broken_Hippo 6y agoI've had more than one landlord that insisted on stopping by once or twice a month. "stopping by" was usually hanging around outside the property, sometimes just knocking to "make sure everything is OK". And weirdly enough, I've never had this while living with a man - only when I was living alone or with another woman. It makes me feel unsafe and like I had no privacy in my private home. And my problems were pretty mild. The places I lived in were fairly well-kept. Lots of folks have issues with roaches, leaks, and a slew of other issues that fall on deaf ears. Lots of folks are actually unsafe. Lots of folks get overcharged for things that come out of a security deposit (oh, a nail hole... that'll be $300 plus paint - nevermind that we'd paint anyway). And so on. This is, of course, because in many areas, there is little to no oversight of landlords and no one really to help a tenant with issues. Decent folks being landlords are the exception, not the rule.
- ByteJockey 6y ago> Decent folks being landlords are the exception, not the rule. This sounds like you're generalizing the experiences of you and those around you just as much as the person you responded to. Do we have any data on this? Or is this just a "we don't know, so everyone goes with their own experience" sort of thing?
- _6fmb 6y agoFormer NSA chief joins Amazon's Board of Directors. https://www.theverge.com/2020/9/9/21429635/amazon-keith-alexander-board-of-directors-nsa-cyber-command https://www.theverge.com/2020/9/9/21429635/amazon-keith-alex...
- jjcon 6y agoAnd? This implying Alexa is spying on your conversations crap is getting out of hand on HN. The dude is ceo of a cybersecurity company and has very unique and deep insights into global security threats. He’s definitely someone you would want to have around to advise on security especially as foreign threats are ramping up on the digital front. Alexa, Google assistant, Siri are demonstrably not listening to your conversations, us in the tech industry should know better than to spread this sort of FUD.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- crazygringo 6y agoNone of these seem like problems to me. This is just adding some commands to Alexa for convenience, like being able to submit an apartment maintenance request. Amazon isn't making it possible for your landlord to spy on you -- first of all, as the article notes, the landlord would have to associate the Alexa account with their own, which makes no sense, since the point of Alexa is it's tied to your Amazon account, so you can order things from Amazon. (Unless my landlord wants to pay for all my shopping...) But more importantly, spying is highly illegal. I don't care about Amazon -- I trust the police and courts here. Second, Amazon has zero business reason to allow landlords to spy on their tenants. It would be a huge PR backlash for virtually zero financial benefit. So I'm not even remotely worried about that, because capitalism. Third, the idea that one day you might only be able to fulfill apartment requests through Alexa, instead of a website, is just ludicrous fearmongering. It's about as likely as requiring it all to go through an Apple Watch. Finally, one random author's opinion about whether or not an included Alexa is an amenity worth paying for is completely meaningless. Every apartment comes with a set of amenities (or not) and the market determines the ultimate rental price for that set. Landlords aren't dumb. They're not installing amenities nobody wants. If the author thinks it's not worth the price, they're just not the target demographic for that building, which is fine, but it's not exactly news that's worth publishing.
- Wolfenstein98k 6y agoI don't see what the risk is. I hate this stuff and don't have any of it in my home, but what exactly is the unique risk in this tenancy situation?
- jjcon 6y agoI agree - the situation described in the article is so so illegal. If a landlord did this they could be sued out of existence. As we move into the future smart homes are becoming ubiquitous. It is only natural that they become built into homes including rentals for those that want it. If a landlord wanted to spy on you there are far less obvious ways to do it (that are also very illegal).
- _alex_ 6y ago> But we all know landlords are, by default, shitty That’s some high quality journalism.
- devnull255 6y ago"Alexa, do not disturb." I use this feature regularly to prevent drop-ins when I don't want them.