4 ms·
If someone moves from CA to a state with no state income tax, the savings from that piece alone could make up most of the salary difference. If your gross pay i
by gnicholas 6y ago
If someone moves from CA to a state with no state income tax, the savings from that piece alone could make up most of the salary difference. If your gross pay is cut by 15% but your post-tax pay is only 5% lower, you've still got way more earning power in WA, TX, NV, or FL.
- ThrustVectoring 6y agothat logic only works if you're saving a large fraction of your paycheck. If you're spending most of your paycheck, that invariably winds up getting taxed somehow, and only the overall state tax revenue fraction matters.
- gnicholas 6y agoIt's true that states need to get revenue from somewhere, so property tax rates may be higher. But the property costs are so much lower, even high rates would result in lower tax burden. Basically, other states do not necessarily raise as much revenue as CA overall. CA provides lots of services (which you may or may not use), which contributes to the high overall taxation.
- ThrustVectoring 6y agoIt depends on a ton of variables, but it can be boiled down to two: how the tax is distributed based off of various demographics, and how much total tax is levied. Unless you have some reason to believe that the tax distribution is better for you - for instance, if you save half of your paycheck and are moving to a state without income tax - then the only thing that matters is the overall level of taxation.
- Retric 6y agoThat really depends on spending habits. If you travel out of state regularly then you receive the same benefit as savings. On top of that State spending and the relative tax burden on each income range can also vary significantly.
- thehappypm 6y agoWhere do all the taxes collected by California go? I live in Massachusetts and we have a substantially lower overall tax burden. We also have the best public schools in the country, and the highest rate of health insurance, due to our very generous MassHealth program. What is California doing with their tax dollars?
- rmk 6y agoCalifornia revenues are about $425 billion. Medi-Cal covers 1 in 3 residents. $100 Billion per year program (or about 23% of the revenues). $25 Billion a year for government employees' pensions and retiree health (note that this is not current govt employees! BTW, that's gonna continue growing without bounds). $78 Billion on education (K-12). These together account for a huge chunk of the money. Very little on infrastructure spending and such (the roads are worse than third-world those in third-world countries here). BTW, folks like Zuckerberg (the 1%) contribute roughly 50% of the revenues! If the market takes a hit, CA hurts real bad.
- ido 6y agoZuckerberg is way higher than 1%, a tiny silver of a fraction of 1%. "The 1%" are like senior engineers at FAANG or a successful dentist running their own clinic.
- rmk 6y agoThat's true. Unbelievable though it is, FAANG guys/gals are comfortably in the top 2-3%
- arshneet 6y agoIs it true that the super-rich pay higher tax rates? My understanding is most of them have great accountants, and the salaries they pay themselves are generally very low. They use loopholes (intentional or unintentional by the government) to avoid the high income tax rates. Which is why I find the whole fantasy around raising income tax rates to tax the rich to be a smokescreen, and not very well researched. It'd hardly affect the super-rich. The top 1% will mostly be salaried people who can't use the loopholes.
- acdha 6y agoYou have to look at other taxes: lots of people move to “low tax” states and then realize they’re making up the difference in property and sales taxes, or lower quality services.
- gnicholas 6y agoProperty tax rates may be higher elsewhere, but the cost of the real estate is so much lower that it more than makes up for it. I'd be interested to know if there are any low-tax states where someone can spend $25k/yr in property tax on a 3bd/2ba, which is the going rate in Palo Alto. Also, I don't think any state has sales tax rates that are much higher than SMC/SCC.
- acdha 6y agoCalifornia is not Palo Alto for a majority of its residents. My point was just that you can’t just look at the state tax rates in isolation to make an accurate comparison. There are definitely cheaper places to live but the differences are not as pronounced as they might seem - usually within a couple percent. Property costs where you want to live are likely to be a far greater impact on your budget. It’s like when Americans say they pay less in taxes than Europeans without factoring in that our healthcare costs are paid separately. Systems built around different models need to be compared carefully.
- souprock 6y agoYep. I'm in FL, working on fancy virtual machine software. I have coworkers in TX. These places are not for everybody. Lots of things that save money are just offensive to the typical CA voter. The words "Don't California my Texas" came into being because crowds of CA voters would evacuate from the mess they had created, then vote for more of the same. If they succeed, then where will they go? So don't just look at the price. You might hate the policy, culture, and law.
- dangus 6y agoJust because people repeat tropes about California or any other state doesn’t mean they’re actually based on data or fact. According this data [1], Ohio has a higher overall tax burden than California. Does anyone from Texas criticize Ohio’s tax burden? No, because Ohio isn’t part of the demonization of California as a liberal regulatory dystopia. In reality, California is a pretty normal state with normal people and many of the same problems as other states. If you’re in Texas, the overall tax rate might be only a percent or two different than California, at least according to my linked chart. https://wallethub.com/edu/states-with-highest-lowest-tax-burden/20494/ https://wallethub.com/edu/states-with-highest-lowest-tax-bur... If this data is flawed, I’ll be glad to eat my own words.
- wahern 6y agoCalifornia does have one of the most progressive taxation schemes in the country. That means the more well off complain louder. Because most people don't really understand taxes that well (for one thing, half of the nationwide population only pays FICA, which is more forced retirement savings than an income tax), they seem to assume that if the rich are complaining about high taxes then they must be suffering from high taxes, too.
- souprock 6y agoWikipedia says: "At 7.25%, California has the highest minimum statewide sales tax rate in the United States, which can total up to 10.50% with local sales taxes included." Sales tax is not normally considered progressive. With such a high sales tax, you'd expect to not also pay state income tax, and you'd expect low property taxes. This is not the case. I don't think anybody should leave California. If you vote to create a disaster, you should stay to enjoy it. No other state wants you voting to replicate that.
- deegles 6y agoUnfortunately for people in NY, you still have to pay income tax there no matter where you live in the US. If you're lucky you'll work in a state with no state income tax and it will be a wash, otherwise your tax preparer is going to have a fun time.