4 ms·
These days it might be possible to "cancel" someone for something that they didn't even say/do, although I'd hope that the victim could bounce back once the mob
by wmf 6y ago
These days it might be possible to "cancel" someone for something that they didn't even say/do, although I'd hope that the victim could bounce back once the mob moved on. Of course, you could also get killed crossing the street.
- dragonwriter 6y ago> These days it might be possible to "cancel" someone for something that they didn't even say/do It always has been. And, often the “cancelling” has been total and irreversible, not, as it often is with the “cancel culture” of recent complaints, just a reduction in current popularity with a particular segment of society (frequently accompanied by profitable celebrity status with an opposing and at least roughly equivalent power social group.) In fact, those complaining about modern “cancel culture” often make hyperbolic analogies to these historical, more total cancellings, such as lynchings.
- thaumasiotes 6y ago>> These days it might be possible to "cancel" someone for something that they didn't even say/do > It always has been. This is a significant plot point in Musashi. ( https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Musashi_(novel) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Musashi_(novel) )
- MrLeap 6y agoI really loved this book. He was cancelled so thoroughly he had to change his name, and people were STILL trying to dox him, 500 pages later.
- kryogen1c 6y ago> It always has been. this is wildly untrue. ted bundy escaped police custody (from being charged with multiple murders), moved a couple states, and kept raping and murdering for years. this was 50 years ago. if someone catches you on video on a field trip like the covington high kids, you might get death threats of such credibility that your school will have to shut down and youll have to sue major "news" networks because their "reporting" was so bad it was tantamount to libel. a grown adult celebrity called them nazis and wanted them doxed. how can you in any seriousness claim cancel culture now is the same as even 10 years ago, much less 100 or more?
- syllogism 6y agoBundy was at large for 6 days after his first escape, and a bit over 2 months in his second escape (December 31 to February 12).
- dragonwriter 6y agoEven if your supporting facts weren't wrong, you seem to be confusing “it is sometimes possible to temporarily avoid consequences for something you did do” for disproof of “it is possible to be cancelled for something you didn't do”, which it most emphatically is not.
- bargl 6y agoThere is no one definition of cancel culture. Many people don't know what they even mean when they talk about it. If we break cancel culture up into roughly before the internet and after. Being canceled (I'd call a non-violent black-sheep status) was a local phenomenon, it was in your town, your church, or your local group. You could move away to reclaim anonymity. Today, you can't hide from it, but it's as you said, a quick burst. But I think you're forgetting that these ramifications aren't just about you being hated by the internet, they can follow you by alienating friends/family. They have made people lose jobs. They take a person's worst moment and give it permanence in a way that wasn't possible in the past. I'd probably say that cancel culture requires the internet to really be a thing, because now we can take anyone who's worst moment is caught on video and have it follow them around forever. Sure the internet as a whole might not hate you for more than a week or so, but the ramifications of unwanted massive celebrity must be profound. To be clear, I'd consider cancellations to be people who are not famous and don't want to be famous. Even that level of positive reception by half of a socially powerful group might be unwanted, especially if you don't really align with them. I'll finish with this, cancel culture is a minor problem compared to those of our ancestors. But it's still something we as a society can try to work on. As individuals when we see someone being canceled, don't dog pile on them, look for context and dig deeper. Sometimes it will make you more angry there are people you're not going to like out there. Side story: When I was a kid I had a bully for all of 1 year in elementary school, he'd trip me at recess every day. One day I lost it and punched him in the face. I remember this clearly, he waited a few weeks then tripped me one more time. For most of us that'd be the end of the story, but a few years later, a family friend of mine brought him by our house and I had to play with him for an afternoon. We got to talking and playing. Just two kids playing as if we didn't know each other. I found out he had dealt with some shit I never had to, and it showed me that his behavior wasn't all his own. I don't regret punching him, I don't begrudge him being a bully for a year, but I do thank that family friend for giving me an afternoon of seeing more context. It showed me that, I don't have to like everyone, and I don't have to let people walk on me, but I do have to do my best to understand people even when I don't like them. Sorry maybe that's not relevant, but I think about the kid that I was getting thrust onto the internet for punching someone, no context, no background and I'd probably not have learned from it. Edit: context around the link. Just a really good video I watched from a person I like on this topic. Sometimes I'll haunt my threads to reply to people but I don't really feel like it tonight, so have a good night everyone. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=p26JJxvw4lM https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=p26JJxvw4lM
- rendall 6y agoI don't like when people dismiss fears of cancel culture; often with "it's just the powerless fighting back against the powerful". That's facile and disingenuous. It's not the weak fighting against the powerful. It's a bullying mob attacking the weak without restraint; and the results are death threats, career or academic destruction, depression, suicide, loss of community, friends and family. Often it's for an innocuous joke that landed poorly or didn't age well, or a misunderstanding, or nothing at all. Defending such mobbing and bullying betrays a lack of self awareness: mobs do not care for mitigating circumstances, politics, past history. The culture war battlefields are littered with the figurative corpses of former leaders of cancel culture, the mob having come for they themselves