4 ms·
I try not to look down on social science, for the most part data is data as long as you can reason about how it was collected and who by. The only thing that w
by mhh__ 6y ago
I try not to look down on social science, for the most part data is data as long as you can reason about how it was collected and who by.
The only thing that worries me a little (or a lot sometimes) is that there doesn't seem to be much "bone" for the meat to hang off of - that is, in physics, if your theory doesn't match experiment it's wrong whereas in social science you're never going to have a (mathematical) theory like that so you have to start (in effect) guessing. The data is really muddy, but thanks to recent (good) political developments whatever conclusions can be drawn from it may not be right in their eyes. For example, (apparently) merely commenting on the variation hypothesis can get you fired [https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Variability_hypothesis#Contemporary_controversies https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Variability_hypothesis#Contemp...].
- stefan_ 6y agoIf only it was all data, statistics and hypotheses in social science. As it stands, that's a relatively modern idea in the field. Take a look at some of the stuff they teach in sociology 101: https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Social_actions https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Social_actions It's all utter fiction. The long drawn out ramblings of ancient white men who formulated theories as their favorite pastime. None of it is experimentally derived because there were no experiments to begin with. You can't found a field on a corpus of creative writing.
- alextheparrot 6y agoThis is a bit of an unjust to the history of sociology, and science writ large. What Weber does is help establish, axiomatically not experimentally, the base definitions for the system of sociology. So yes, it is a fiction from another system, but it must be assumed true in that system. This is, ironically given your accusations, a purely mathematical approach to creating a field. It is taught in 101 because it is important when teaching a subject for the learner to be able to answer “And what again are we doing here?”
- closeparen 6y agoThe physical sciences have no less "old white man conjecture" in their history.
- pa7x1 6y agoThey have but is not taught as science. Physics 101 does not study Aristotles ideas as part of physics. Not because they are wrong but because they are not scientific. They start with Galileo and Newton.
- liability 6y agoThe first chemistry lecture I ever had started with something to the effect of "Chemistry emerged from alchemy, and we'll not speak of this again!"
- efavdb 6y agoI read one guess that 2/3 of the published results in social science are wrong. Suppose you tried to develop a deeper theory of these things and derived consequences from these “results” as one does in math and physics. If your corollary depends on 4 prior results, each with a 1/3 chance of actually being true — assuming no logical errors on your part — then the chance your result really is correct is (1/3)^4 <0.01. With results like this it’s not going to be easy to get much depth that holds water.
- kovac 6y agoRequiring social science theories to have a mathematical founding might be a little too much to ask the social scientists because unlike Physicists, their command of mathematics is far from adequate to do any serious exploration. I majored in Mathematics but out of curiosity I took some Psychology modules when I was in university. What I found baffling was their lack attention to details. They just seem to have an intuitive model of their subject and they were just reinforcing that intuition while overlooking any details that could have challenged it. Coming from a field where every symbol, punctuation matters, I realised to Psychologists exact details of a curve don't seem to matter much as long as the general trend made sense. Someone who really impressed me was Dan Ariely who is a behavirol economist. Even though I didn't see any mathematics in his lectures, I loved his approach to the field. I'd be quite happy if more of social science took a similar approach even if they didn't back it up with rigorous mathematics.