6 ms·
> And now that I’ve publicly admitted privacy is important to me – something I tried to avoid coming on too strong about before, for exactly this reason – some
by brundolf 6y ago
> And now that I’ve publicly admitted privacy is important to me – something I tried to avoid coming on too strong about before, for exactly this reason – some people have taken it upon themselves to post my real name all over Twitter in order to harass and threaten me.
Has anybody applied the Dark Forest metaphor to internet publicity? It's fascinating (horrifying) how simply catching the attention of too big a piece of the internet can start wreaking havoc on different parts of your life. You don't even have to have done anything controversial. Attention itself appears to be caustic, at the extreme.
- person_of_color 6y agoMore people that know about you, more likely you are to come across a psycho that will tear you down.
- unityByFreedom 6y ago> You don't even have to have done anything controversial. Attention itself appears to be caustic, at the extreme. I haven't read it but I assumed the blog was controversial based on all the concern about anonymity. Is that not the case?
- jbob2000 6y agoHe’s not controversial if you believe in reality. A good example of something that may get him attacked is his anti-creationist post, https://slatestarcodex.com/2020/05/28/creationism-unchallenged/ https://slatestarcodex.com/2020/05/28/creationism-unchalleng... . Any time you criticize the crazies you get attacked.
- the_gastropod 6y agoEhh, I generally like his reasoning and thought process. But his bread-and-butter is writing about controversial topics.
- pas 6y agoIt was "controversial" because it was a safe space for discussion about any topic - as long as participants adhered to some rules, that Scott enforced, and of course exemplified them as best as he could. So it's not hard to find something that "looks bad", even if it's really not.
- Viliam1234 6y agoThere are several independent reasons. First, people who need a psychiatrist (or doctor in general) sometimes do a simple background check on them. Like, put their name in Google and try to find some reviews, just to see if other patients were satisfied with them or not. Some topics that Scott debates would be quite inappropriate for people seeking psychiatric help. For example, imagine that you are suffering from paranoia, and you find out that your psychiatrist seriously considers the possibility that superintelligent robots may soon exterminate the humankind. Second, although Scott is generally left-wing, he is not fully 100% on the side of the left-wing orthodoxy. For example, he would write an article about how Trump is a horrible person and a disaster for America, but would also mention that a few details that the mainstream media said about him were factually incorrect. For some people, anything less than 100% compliance is unacceptable. (Often heretics are more triggering than full enemies, because the enemies at least fit into the black-and-white picture, while the heretic ruins it.) Third, in the discussions below the articles, multiple political opinions are allowed. Again, this is quite triggering for some people, because according to their logic, why would you allow anyone to express their opinion on your website, unless you actually agree with them? Of course, this is reported selectively, like "did you know there are fans of reactionary politics on SSC?!" without mentioning that they are debating there with e.g. hardcore stalinists, and that both sides are just a small minority in the mostly moderate audience. The second and third point are why some people are so eager to expose Scott's identity, and the first point is why he tries to prevent it.
- wmf 6y agoThese days it might be possible to "cancel" someone for something that they didn't even say/do, although I'd hope that the victim could bounce back once the mob moved on. Of course, you could also get killed crossing the street.
- dragonwriter 6y ago> These days it might be possible to "cancel" someone for something that they didn't even say/do It always has been. And, often the “cancelling” has been total and irreversible, not, as it often is with the “cancel culture” of recent complaints, just a reduction in current popularity with a particular segment of society (frequently accompanied by profitable celebrity status with an opposing and at least roughly equivalent power social group.) In fact, those complaining about modern “cancel culture” often make hyperbolic analogies to these historical, more total cancellings, such as lynchings.
- thaumasiotes 6y ago>> These days it might be possible to "cancel" someone for something that they didn't even say/do > It always has been. This is a significant plot point in Musashi. ( https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Musashi_(novel) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Musashi_(novel) )
- MrLeap 6y agoI really loved this book. He was cancelled so thoroughly he had to change his name, and people were STILL trying to dox him, 500 pages later.
- kryogen1c 6y ago> It always has been. this is wildly untrue. ted bundy escaped police custody (from being charged with multiple murders), moved a couple states, and kept raping and murdering for years. this was 50 years ago. if someone catches you on video on a field trip like the covington high kids, you might get death threats of such credibility that your school will have to shut down and youll have to sue major "news" networks because their "reporting" was so bad it was tantamount to libel. a grown adult celebrity called them nazis and wanted them doxed. how can you in any seriousness claim cancel culture now is the same as even 10 years ago, much less 100 or more?
- tedunangst 6y agoOne strategy might be to not hit the self destruct button prematurely. Far more people have read and shared his blog post about being doxxed than have read the NYT article.
- W8LLverINOCuty 6y agoThere's doxed ... and then there's a whole new level of doxed ... ewnow what I'm supersayin?
- stevenwliao 6y agoThe optimal strategy would probably have been radio silence, and then the blog disappearing without an explanation after a few weeks.
- pas 6y agoOptimal for what? Sure that might thwart this problematic piece but would it guarantee anything for the future? At least this way Scott was able to size up his readership and work on solving this problem for good (for himself), plus the cat is out of the bag regarding how fickle the NYT is.
- stevenwliao 6y agoOptimal for maximizing the chance of the publicity going away and him continuing his job status quo. Most people aren't going to write about a dead blog. This solution is fine now that there's no chance.
- pas 6y agoBut the blog is very important for him, just as psychiatry.
- stevenwliao 6y agoYes, but we can infer from his initial actions that he preferred keeping his job over maintaining the blog.
- KKKKkkkk1 6y agoWhat caustic attention? A popular blogger whose name is publicly available but not mentioned on the blog had his name posted on Twitter? Why does he perceive this as harassment and persecution?
- awerawerawrjhui 6y agoHave you even read his original post about why he didn't want his real name to be publicised?
- dredmorbius 6y agoWhat's the Dark Forest metaphor in this context? Liu Cixin? https://onezero.medium.com/the-dark-forest-theory-of-the-internet-7dc3e68a7cb1 https://onezero.medium.com/the-dark-forest-theory-of-the-int...