3 ms·
Google provides side loading so I can avoid their fee. Playstation and Xbox are not general computing devices.
by jedberg 6y ago
Google provides side loading so I can avoid their fee. Playstation and Xbox are not general computing devices.
- scarface74 6y agoSure you can avoid their fee. See how many customers you will get if you force them to side load - ask Epic.
- simion314 6y agoFunny, some Apple fanboys claim that if side-loading is allowed the the Apple Store will get empty and you get 10 new App Stores and others like you claim the reverse (I agree with you, allowing side loading and other stores will not empty the main store)
- Bud 6y agoWho claims this? Nobody with any credibility claims this.
- simion314 6y agoI mean people here in HN, probably most of us here have the same credibility , this person said "The problem with this logic is that every company is going to set up their own App Store. Microsoft, Epic, etc. Then for every app that I use right now on my iPhone I would have to source from several App Stores. It will make my experience very cumbersome. reply" And this is proven false since the Google Store is still very popular and I don't see people having to source 5 apps from Google store, 5 from Microsoft, 2 from Apple, 3 from Adobe. With the Epic the situation is clear, this giants are asking too much just for hosting your application and the small guys had no chance to fight this , lucky for the developers Epic started this and as we can see from this article Apple is backing down one step here, other step a month ago ...
- sjwright 6y agoThe difference is that Google’s sideloading experience is intentionally full of warnings and hurdles. Do you really think that if Apple had a court ruling against them they could get away with that? No, Epic (et al) will be very clear about third party stores being utterly seamless to install and use. That’s why we’d see a proliferation of stores on iOS.
- scarface74 6y agoSo now you want third party app stores and no warnings? Even though Epic - one of the first major apps to try side loading, actually had a security vulnerability. https://www.cnet.com/news/just-as-critics-feared-fortnite-for-android-came-with-an-epic-security-risk/ https://www.cnet.com/news/just-as-critics-feared-fortnite-fo...
- sjwright 6y agoEw, god no. I think Apple should be allowed to offer us their idea of a good product and let the marketplace choose between that, Google Android, or other competitors who believe they could do better offering open source Android. The idea of having parts of your product designed by the competitors who envy your success is utter madness.
- scarface74 6y agoIt’s not like side loading on Android has ever caused a security vulnerability when downloading an app from a reputable company like Epic. https://www.cnet.com/news/just-as-critics-feared-fortnite-for-android-came-with-an-epic-security-risk/ https://www.cnet.com/news/just-as-critics-feared-fortnite-fo... Or reputable companies have ever been convicted of falsely getting money from minors. https://www.sportskeeda.com/esports/news-fortnite-sued-tricking-minors-spending-money-judge-rules-epic https://www.sportskeeda.com/esports/news-fortnite-sued-trick...
- simion314 6y agoAnd is not like curated App Stores did not had mallware, tracking stuff inside apps, minors spending all the parents credit card on gems etc. You basically want to force a "kid mode" without an opt-out for everyone.
- scarface74 6y agoDo you run Windows PCs and complain that it isn’t open source or do you use Linux? If not, why buy an iOS device instead of an Android if it meets your needs better?
- simion314 6y agoI run Linux only for 3 years, I was dual booting before that. This is not about what shit smells better, see people (not your tribe) complained and now Apple did something , is this article surprising you because you thought Apple policies are perfect and now because of this complains the good Apple had to give up some money to improve it's PR. Remember the keyboard issues with broken keys, people like you were accusing uses that they are using it wrong and stop complaining, Apple is perfect and those genius engineers don't make mistake, Apple is always right and the complainers are trolls or guys that eat at their laptop? If you don't remember Apple was forced by lawsuits to aknowledge that their genius engineers are not perfect and were forced by those lawsuits to replace the broken parts (again Apple was not protecting the users but was trying to avoid losing money )... so if you can reflect 1 moment you could maybe(low chance though) that Apple sometime is not perfect and sometimes users that complain are in the right (it happened so it is not impossible)
- threeseed 6y agoPlaystation/Xbox are general computing devices. So is my Sony TV, Tesla car and Samsung fridge. All have an App Store and are fully capable of facilitating payments, running Microsoft Office, using SaaS apps, doing "work". Users are prevented from doing so by artificial restrictions on their App Stores which could be lifted at any time by a simple business decision. Apple allows more freedom to developers than these platforms yet somehow should be treated differently. Seems arbitrary and capricious.
- jedberg 6y agoI assume you're making this argument to be absurd and reductionist, but just in case you aren't, no, those aren't general computing platforms. Sure, they could be, with a lot of effort. But they are neither marketed nor capable of general compute today. They don't have the toolset or ecosystem to make general purpose apps. Nor do they actively encourage people to make general apps.
- threeseed 6y agoMy PS4 and Sony Android TV are general computing platforms in every sense e.g. Salesforce is open right now on my TV. It's simply that Sony won't approve non-gaming or non-entertainment apps. And if Apple were to follow the same path and block productivity apps then it would somehow stop being a general computing device ?
- design-material 6y agoI use my PS4 a more as a 'general computing device' (YouTube, Netflix, Prime, voice calls, etc) than my phone by far. Why should someone else get to dictate which of my devices is a 'general computing device' and what that means for me and my use-case?
- yazaddaruvala 6y agoI can't load Intelij, Xcode, Xamarian, JVM, etc on my iPhone or my PlayStation "without a lot of effort". What is your definition of "general" that makes one of them general, and the other one non-general? To me the only reason an iPhone seems to be "general purpose" is because the "number of developers has reached some critical mass and wants it to be". Which seems like putting the cart before the horse. Sanity Test: Should my microwave be a "general purpose" device because it is built with a Raspberry Pi and a touch screen?
- bsql 6y agoSo because they aren’t a general computing device it’s okay? Also isn’t it bit disingenuous to suggest that side loading is an option to avoid the fee? I believe that’s why Epic also sued Google. Even when end users are given the option to download from an alternative store, most people won’t because it’s still not as convenient as downloading from the play store. Your app would have to be worthwhile enough to convince users to download from a 3rd party store.