3 ms·
China's market is not closed to foreign companies. This isn't 1990 anymore. American brands are everywhere in China, from Teslas, to iPhones, to McDonalds, to
by vkou 6y ago
China's market is not closed to foreign companies. This isn't 1990 anymore.
American brands are everywhere in China, from Teslas, to iPhones, to McDonalds, to Starbucks, to the NBA, to the list goes on and on and on. Google, Facebook, Apple each make billions of dollars from China, every year.
Calling that a closed market is... Not at all accurate. It's by no means a fully[1] open market, but it's not a closed one.
[1] The definition of fully also varies from country to country. Is Canada a fully open market? No. For example, there's a lot of government protectionism surrounding media, and media infrastructure. Is the US a fully open market? No - again, not in the case of media infrastructure. Neither is an open market when it comes to food, or medical drugs. (For good reason, in my opinion - but that's just that - a political opinion. Other people have different opinions on this subject.)
- m0zg 6y ago> Google, Facebook, Apple each make billions of dollars from China, every year. How does _Facebook_ make "billions" in China in particular? It's completely banned there.
- systemvoltage 6y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_websites_blocked_in_mainland_China https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_websites_blocked_in_ma... Also, as others might point out that "Way into China is to abide by their rules and regulations" - which is not true when the restrictions imposed are to gut out the business and establish a CCP-controlled branch that serves only Chinese people. For example, Wikpedia is blocked, how is Wikipedia supposed to even enter the "market" (I know its a non-profit org). The truth is that China doesn't want western information, knowledge and values. This stance hides behind "rules and regulations".
- shard 6y agoA company doesn't have to sell things to the local population to do business there. There are many companies in China which wish to access the user base that FB has. Here is an article from NYT talking about the $5B that FB made from China during 2018: https://www.nytimes.com/2019/02/07/technology/facebook-china-internet.html https://www.nytimes.com/2019/02/07/technology/facebook-china...
- NovemberWhiskey 6y agoYou forget; users are not Facebook customers. The advertisers are Facebook customers. Facebook may not be selling ads targeted to users in China, but it's sure as heck selling ads to Chinese companies. Facebook: you're not the customer, you're the product.
- mulmen 6y agoIt's not binary. China's market is more closed (or less open) than the US.
- _jal 6y agoSure. China is doing what all nation states do - use their advantages, exploit their competitors' weaknesses. The US has (well, sometimes, to some extent) an ideological commitment to open markets. China does not. The US exploited the advantages of open markets to great success. Why would China not use the asymmetry now that they can? Two lessons: - Expecting your competitors to play by your rules is foolish. - Concepts like morality and fairness get people going, but are not very useful to apply to nation states.
- saiya-jin 6y agoNot that I disagree anyhow, but good luck with that argument here... this is US website, visited predominantly by US folks, so I don't blame them that they want to protect their companies. Even if DJI is properly on top of the drone game, at least in some parts of drone market. The thing is, as a european, I don't give a nanofraction of a f*ck about these 'privacy issues'. Everybody steals data, americans are probably the most advanced (thank you mr Snowden for disclosing this, some proper respect there). No higher moral ground there. With current US administration Europe and US ain't big friends like they used to be. US set the tone to more 'everybody for themselves'. US killed tens of millions of innocent civilians in past 50 years, destroyed whole regions of this planet for generations to come, for money, power, resources and their ideology. THAT is something I care about. So give me a break with this political games, give me the best drone, it will spy on me regardless of country of origin if it can. Same as phone, tablets, desktop (depending on software used) and so on. Welcome to 2020, it ain't nice but this is how things are.
- Scramblejams 6y agoTry walking into China with a popular video game you own and selling it there. If it's big enough to get on anyone's radar, then it won't happen. You will be required to "partner" with a Chinese-owned company who will take a bunch of cash, a bunch of your ongoing revenues, maybe a little equity, and keep things humming with the local government. (And if you think that's implying something, it is.) That gets you initial access to the market. If you want to keep that access, you'll need to toe the line. (Expect the line to move.) One example: NetEase doesn't operate Blizzard's games in China just because Blizzard thought it'd be a nice idea to share a piece of the pie.[0] Western rules around media infrastructure ownership or food production, where almost all of the regulatory business is conducted out in the open, have no comparison here. [0] https://www.gamesindustry.biz/articles/2019-10-11-publishers-risk-being-trapped-between-the-us-and-china-opinion https://www.gamesindustry.biz/articles/2019-10-11-publishers...
- libertine 6y agoYou're mentioning the largest American Brands, which do not represent the bulk of businesses. In fact they have different channels to setup their businesses and lobby their way around. When I made that comment I was referring to SME, which is also the bulk of let's say, Chinese sellers on Amazon US. Try to do what Chinese people do on Amazon, but on a Chinese platform as a SME, to sell products in China.
- vkou 6y agoYour SME will be about as successful at operating in a Chinese market, as a Croatian SME will be successful at operating in an American market. That is to say, you'd need a pretty exceptional product, that is significantly better then local alternatives to get anywhere, because you're not going to be able to compete on price, or on brand recognition. The reason Chinese SMEs are punching above their weight in foreign markets is because of their low cost of labour.
- jbay808 6y agoPeople often think it's labour, but it's much more than that. Low cost of everything. Transportation, production machinery, raw materials. And short lead times. Try buying something like a coil winder, an induction heater, a spot welder, or a heat sealer. Even in the US, you're much more likely to find Chinese equipment more competitive and more readily available. Especially for an SME.
- libertine 6y ago>Your SME will be about as successful at operating in a Chinese market, as a Croatian SME will be successful at operating in an American market Well I guess that's depends on your definition of "successful", no? Nothing stops a Croatian SME to enter the US market. >That is to say, you'd need a pretty exceptional product, that is significantly better then local alternatives to get anywhere, because you're not going to be able to compete on price, or on brand recognition. Even this is arguable because one of the biggest problems of Amazon US is the flood of low quality products, yet that doesn't stop them from being successful.