18 ms·
Apple: Apps should not require users to opt into tracking to access content
- _Microft 6y agoAnything else wouldn't be GDPR compliant anyways, would it?
- Nextgrid 6y agoIn Europe it indeed wouldn't, however GDPR enforcement has been severely lacking despite the potential for significant fines, so Apple taking matters into its own hands (and using its influence and power over the App Store) is very good news.
- Nextgrid 6y agoFull text of the clause: > 3.2.2 Unacceptable > (vi) Apps should allow a user to get what they’ve paid for without performing additional tasks, such as posting on social media, uploading contacts, checking in to the app a certain number of times, etc. Apps should not require users to rate the app, review the app, watch videos, download other apps, tap on advertisements, enable tracking, or take other similar actions in order to access functionality, content, use the app, or receive monetary or other compensation, including but not limited to gift cards and codes.
- jonplackett 6y agoAmen.
- JadeNB 6y agoIs this in the usual technical sense of MUST / SHOULD / MAY, or does 'should not' here actually mean 'may not' (as suggested by the category being 'Unacceptable', rather than 'Discouraged')? (Several other entries are phrased much less ambiguously: "Unacceptable: (i) Creating an interface …", and (ix) is explicitly "Apps must not …" (emphasis mine).)
- reaperducer 6y agoApple's guidelines are usually written in soft language to give it wiggle room in case an unexpected scenario arises. Practically-speaking, if Apple decides an app has violated this provision, the app is toast. No app company on the planet has enough lawyers to challenge Apple on such nit-pickery.
- ChrisMarshallNY 6y agoThis has been my experience, as well. I once had to delete an entire bug fix version, and turn it into a feature version, because I "shouldn't" have done something (can't remember what, exactly -I'd have to go digging through the commit comments to find it, and I don't want to do that).
- jmull 6y agoI'm just about 100% sure Apple uses "should" and "should not" in the absolute sense, not the way RFC's define it.
- jtsiskin 6y agoThe clause starts with "get what they've paid for" - does this apply to free apps?
- LeoNatan25 6y agoYou get what pay for with free garbage too.
- DoofusOfDeath 6y agoI find that policy entirely acceptable, for the same reasons I think shrink-wrap EULAs should be illegal. This makes me curious about Apple and iOS / OS X. Does Apple try to require that the user accepts an EULA for the OS after buying Apple hardware?
- easton 6y agoYes, they do. On the Mac, at least for the longest time, they put a sticker on the shrink wrap for the device that said something to the effect of "By using this device, you agree to the terms of Software License Agreement found at apple.com/legal/sla". Of course, if you didn't agree with that you could return the device or install Windows/Linux, but on the iPhone (which won't activate without agreeing), you can't since the bootloader is locked.
- placatedmayhem 6y agoIirc, those shrink wrap licenses are of questionable enforceability. The Wikipedia entry on "shrink wrap contract" agrees, but I'm not well-versed on the topic.
- DoofusOfDeath 6y agoSomething about this has always confused me... IIUC (at least in US legal system), using software without an appropriate license from the copyright holder is considered a violation of civil copyright law. Suppose that courts deemed shrink-wrap EULAs to be invalid. If the EULA is the agreement that grants end-users permission to use the copyrighted software, would the invalidation mean that users were in violation of copyright law? Or is there a right to use the software that's implicitly granted by the original purchase?
- johnday 6y agoWhat would you actually be buying, if you bought the software without being legally capable of using it?
- electriclove 6y agoThis sounds.. great!
- ggrrhh_ta 6y agoDoesn't youtube, with its ads, violate this policy?
- Nextgrid 6y agoWhen it comes to YouTube the waters are muddy. The YouTube app is just a client to a third-party web service (whose functionality falls outside of App Store rules); so in this case it can be argued that the "functionality" of the app is just the client functionality and not the content itself. Furthermore you can skip ads on YouTube after a 5-second timer, so this seems reasonably fair, though I would still not install it and recommend everyone to just use the web with a content blocker extension (AdGuard) or a third-party frontend like Invidious (https://github.com/iv-org/invidious https://github.com/iv-org/invidious).
- kevinventullo 6y agoThat seems like a pretty big loophole if applied. Taken to the logical extreme, one could make an app that streams raw user inputs to a server and streams back a video output and be allowed to do whatever they like (albeit with horrendous performance).
- derefr 6y agoApple already declared a policy against game-streaming service apps; presumably specifically to avoid this loophole where the ads, purchases, etc. are happening “remotely” and so Apple can’t get a cut of them. Presumably, if anyone tried to build a service for “streaming” non-game apps, that wouldn’t be allowed on the App Store either.
- deadmutex 6y ago> Apple already declared a policy against game-streaming service apps. I thought they did just the opposite? 4.9: Streaming games Streaming games are permitted so long as they adhere to all guidelines — for example, each game update must be submitted for review, developers must provide appropriate metadata for search, games must use in-app purchase to unlock features or functionality, etc. Of course, there is always the open Internet and web browser apps to reach all users outside of the App Store.
- dathinab 6y agoBut this also excludes letting the user chose between either watching ads or paying for the content. A not very well working but reasonable business model. Why is it incompatible? Because getting access to normally payed-extra-for content by watching apps means receiving a "monetary or other compensation"
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- a1369209993 6y ago> this also excludes letting the user chose between either watching ads or paying for the content. Good. They should clairify that content not available by paying also counts as "monetary or other compensation" for watching ads. Advertising delenda est.
- dathinab 6y agoNo not good, not everyone can or want afford paying for content. You should have the freedom to choose to pay by having ads. At least as long as it's a actually free and fair choice, i.e. the non ad payments are not overpriced.
- a1369209993 6y agoIn order to actually be a fair choice, overpriced means "greater than zero", so I suppose what you say is true, but I object to the characterization of something that you have to actively seek out for no reason other than to view it as advertising, because it dilutes the term. Advertising delenda est.
- toredash 6y agoShould. Not "must not"
- msbarnett 6y agoThe subsection this falls under is "Unacceptable" as in "Will not be accepted". The "should" in the sentence is a normative statement about values, not recommendational.
- marvel_boy 6y agoIn this legal context 'should not' means 'must not'.
- criddell 6y ago> watch videos So games that periodically stop to show a full screen ad and don't resume until the user closes the ad are in violation?
- pindab0ter 6y agoIs this for paid games? I imagine this would not apply to freemium games.
- ricardonunez 6y agoAs soon as I start using an app in a regular bases and I notice they stop me too many times to watch videos or look to timed ads, I check if they have a paid version. So this is a good solution and a good compromise for paid. For free apps, I get it because developers need to make money.
- Angostura 6y agoFeels in line with GDPR
- sizzle 6y agoWow this is why my next phone will be an iphone, so sick of apps in Android play store pestering me to rate their app after completing an action in the app or forcing me to turn on location services when I can easily enter a zip code instead.
- bmarquez 6y ago> forcing me to turn on location services when I can easily enter a zip code instead This exists on iOS too. I recently downloaded a wardrobe app that refused to let me select clothes for hot or cold weather unless I turned on location services. Also some fast food apps (either Burger King, Popeye's or Taco Bell...can't remember which one) constantly whine about location services off and introduce extra friction to type in a zip code.
- sizzle 6y agoHopefully this changes with this new announcement
- 8ytecoder 6y agoiOS 14 has an option to share location without being precise - pretty much like sharing zip. A lot of apps ask for location and I deny and enter my zip. In fact it was one of the major reasons I switched years ago.
- _-___________-_ 6y agoI don't understand why this wasn't there from the start - the majority of apps asking for location service just want to figure out what city/state/country you are in, and giving them access to your precise location just seems unnecessarily dangerous.
- Nextgrid 6y agoBack when the feature was originally introduced (I guess in the iPhone OS 3 era?), surveillance capitalism and spyware wasn't as widespread and it then took them a while to catch up (I guess there are backwards-compatibility concerns?).
- ooobit2 6y agoCan it also not require Apple to get a 30% cut when we buy something from within an app, like... oh, IDK, a Fortnite skin? Because I think requiring us to tack on a 30% tax or for the devs to take a 30% loss on something Apple has nothing to do with is also unacceptable.
- yazaddaruvala 6y agoTechnically only buying Vbucks is an “in app purchase”, using the Vbucks to buy a skin would not be. But I agree that’s a bit pedantic
- tempodox 6y agoThe Hitman Sniper app does at least one of those “unacceptable” things: They offer (not really) “free” digital items in exchange for “likes” on Facebook. And there seems to be more app functionality tied to Facebook logins. Will big players like Square Enix be made to comply with those rules or is it only the little guys?
- JiNCMG 6y agoOnce these rules are in place (like now) they will wait until the next update submission to notify them of the infractions.
- ffpip 6y agoSuch things are never going to come to Android are they? Every preinstalled app abuses every permission possible
- cmeacham98 6y agoPre-installed apps where you can't disable them or revoke their permissions are a cancer on the Android ecosystem. Especially fun when they have permissions like "access the filesystem" or "obtain device location" or "send notifications".
- ffpip 6y agoThere used to be a security app on my MIUI phone. Security apps can't do anything on android, because each app is sandboxed. But of course, it had full non-revocable permissions including physical sensors, precise location, contacts, camera and microphone. I hope someone cracks open their 'security' app and controls every MIUI device, just for them to learn their lesson.
- wadkar 6y agoI am getting a feeling that that might be the reason for it’s existence
- wvenable 6y agoAre there pre-installed apps you can't disable? I have a bunch disabled on my phone.
- cma 6y agoWith a user controlled Android phone, you can just feed apps you don't trust fake location data. But now Google has started restricting user-owned Android to a fixed number of flashes or something, or they get locked out of Google Play Services.
- expectsomuch 6y agoCan't tell if this is a serious reply.
- cblconfederate 6y agoThats a good thing. Can Apple guarantee that they themselves are not tracking their users' app preferences/behaviour either?
- scarface74 6y agoOf course they can’t guarantee it. The best they could do is give users the ability to block all internet access in an app. Currently you can only block an app from using cellular data.
- saagarjha 6y agoInterestingly in China you can block all network access…
- scarface74 6y agoThere is an option in settings on iOS to block all network access per app?
- saagarjha 6y agoYeah, on Chinese phones. I believe Wi-Fi is renamed “WLAN” but there is a setting to control what connections an app can make.
- scarface74 6y agoIt is just a China thing. I learned something new today. https://www.reddit.com/r/ios/comments/aib10i/in_china_ios_allows_you_to_turn_off_mobile_data/?utm_source=amp&utm_medium=&utm_content=comments_view_all https://www.reddit.com/r/ios/comments/aib10i/in_china_ios_al...
- Nextgrid 6y agoNope they can't. In fact to use an iOS device you pretty much need an Apple account (if you want to be able to install any apps) and that comes with a privacy policy and some extra "features" you might not know about like every sender e-mail on iOS Mail being synced to their cloud. However, at least we can find comfort in the fact that their business model so far has been against the surveillance/advertising economy and their entire marketing strategy has been based on that for the past few years, so at least they currently do not have any incentive to misuse that data even if they do collect it (and if they do eventually think about misusing it, we can hope that there would be some actual enforcement of laws such as the GDPR that would discourage them from doing so).
- beervirus 6y agoEverybody complains about the walled garden, but damn I love to see things like this.
- ProAm 6y agoDoesn't Apple track every app you install, access and run? Track you if you want to develop your own code for your own fully paid for device?
- ffpip 6y ago> Doesn't Apple track every app you install, access and run? Do you have a source on the them tracking every app a user runs? Obviously they have to collect every app I install for updates and subscriptions, but collecting every run might be too much.
- cblconfederate 6y agoDon't they verify executables for this reason? Do they provide info about whether they log this process?
- Nextgrid 6y agoI believe iOS handles this process differently. Apps are signed in advance (when the app is approved and published to the Store) and the signatures are only checked locally against a hardcoded signing key. But even on Mac when it comes to notarization, I'm pretty sure the signatures are only checked on first run and then the result of that is cached (partly for performance reasons).
- sroussey 6y agoSame on Mac AppStore.
- ffpip 6y agoWhy would they verify it everytime you run the app? It already goes through heavy review before it comes onto the app store.
- dellcybpwr 6y agoShould not vs may not. Any difference?
- mensetmanusman 6y ago“I should still be able to view where I am on this map without letting anyone know where I am”
- reaperducer 6y ago“I should still be able to view where I am on this map without letting anyone know where I am” Seems perfectly reasonable. We used to do it before there was an internet to feed our locations to. I did it on my Palm III. Heck, my car does it today. And is able to show me all the nearby coffee shops with zero internet connection, thus no snitching.
- canadianwriter 6y ago"Apps should not require users to rate the app, review the app, watch videos, download other apps, tap on advertisements, enable tracking, or take other similar actions in order to access functionality, content, use the app, or receive monetary or other compensation, including but not limited to gift cards and codes." Bunch of apps started doing the above "enable tracking" part already - good thing Apple specifically disallowed it, should nip that problem before 14 comes out.
- Nextgrid 6y agoOut of curiosity, which apps?
- dathinab 6y agoI do not think Apple should have the power to do such decisions. I do not like tracking at all. But I think this is something which needs to be handled by governments (laws/regulations) not by apple forcing their opinion about what is right onto everyone else by abusing their marked positions. In this case it might be beneficial for the users. In others cases it was not beneficial for the users at all but only for apple. Like if I remember correctly apps where not allowed to state that they are Pebble compatible because Pebble did compete with the Apple Watch at least theoretically, similar platforms like Netflix/Amazon Prime got special terms wrt. the pay cut but a Netflix/Amazon Prime for gaming wasn't allowed at all for dubious reasons (with that reasons any content gateway like browsers, newsfeeds, Netflix etc. would not be allowed) oh and guess what it seems Apple is currently working on their own Gaming/Game Streaming platform... So yes anti tracking is good. But I still belive Apple is again abusing their monopoly like positions for their own benefits, let's not forget Apple has their own app network which likely isn't affected by this.
- slipheen 6y agoGovernments ought to be the place for this level of regulation, absolutely - But right now, governments aren't regulating. In the mean time, I'm glad Apple is. If Apple wasn't doing this, no one would be.
- zoredache 6y agoNever heard of regulatory capture? If the government regulates something, that very often means that the incumbents will donate/bribe officials to pass regulations that favor the mega corps. Getting government regulations that actually favors the consumers is somewhere between difficult and impossible.
- spideymans 6y agoGovernment regulation would be at the mercy of Google and Facebook and their hoard of regulators, so I’m not convinced this would protect iOS end users better than the status quo. Facebook and similar developers might be happy about it though
- 6y ago
- 2Gkashmiri 6y agoI remember ios 5 I think brought app permissions. Essentially say app A should not get location or contacts and put this behind a password. The app couldnt do shit. Then android after late got some permissions but its still lame IMO. App can deny you access without a permission. A recent thing I have seen on android is permission protection or whatever. The system gives dummy or no access to the contacts for example instead of actual contacts. Sounds good but now every app can detect this and bugs you to allow the sameby nagging you. Look, if I want to deny app A or B access to contacts, as far as the app is concerned it should get 0 access. Not blocking or pseudo blocking but a sinkhole type "huh. Nothing here". It should not be able to detect this. Same for internet access. If I deny internet to an app, that app should think its in flight mode. Thats it. Same thing here. Say I dont want to be tracked, apps should think I have allowed access and go ahead. Why should they tailor access based on my permission to track ? My installing the app is proof I want to use the app. I just dont want it to be tied to anything. Kinda like the original "sandbox" idea
- renewiltord 6y agoOkay, but I don't want that as a user. If I accidentally say "Deny Location Permission" I want the app to say "I actually can't navigate for you without this, sorry. Want me to request the permission again?". I don't want to debug this shit - oh why is navigation not working? No thanks. Life's too short.
- reaperducer 6y agoLife is too short for you to press Settings > Privacy > Location Services > app > enable? Are you on life support or something?
- renewiltord 6y agoHaha, hilarious! But yes, I don't want to do that.
- kinkrtyavimoodh 6y agoI won't know to do that if the app doesn't tell me. How do I know it's not a bug and a problem with the permissions instead? Especially if the problem does not occur immediately after denying the permission
- ATsch 6y agoThis is already legally required by GDPR but I guess it's good for apple to check for it.
- matthewmacleod 6y agoThis is not required by GDPR.
- cblconfederate 6y agothe tracking thing is
- Nextgrid 6y agoThe GDPR so far doesn't have any enforcement for stuff like this. All the links to "enforcement tracker" (which I'm sure someone will reply with down below) have been either about a technicality like a badly worded privacy policy or the amount of the fine was peanuts compared to the size of the offending company.
- Angeo34 6y agoApple wants all the data for themselves obviously.
- RcouF1uZ4gsC 6y agoThis is one of the reasons, I am actually in favor of only having the App Store on Apple. As soon as you have another way to distribute apps on the iPhone, app developers will try to migrate to the less privacy conscious store that lets them do all their dark patterns. Sometimes, let the consumer choose does not work. For example, if governments did not regulate kids products and just said let the consumer choose, the market would be filled with unsafe products. Sometimes you need someone enforcing standards. Apple’s enforcement of standards is one of the big reasons why I choose their ecosystem.
- spideymans 6y agoCertain developers (ahem... Facebook) love to cry about Apple’s walled garden, without acknowledging that the reason that iOS and its walled garden is so popular is precisely because these large developers have proven to users that they are completely untrustworthy. If they conducted their business more responsibly, and if users could trust that these developers wouldn’t abuse their privacy and security, perhaps the mobile software ecosystem would be more open in nature.
- ugh123 6y agoCould say the same thing about these cookie-accept popups as some will just redirect you off their site if you don't accept.
- noisem4ker 6y agoThose go against the GDPR.
- ryandrake 6y agoI've always wondered why do companies call it "opt" in if it's not optional?
- perryizgr8 6y agoIt is optional, of course. The other option is to not use the app.
- prophesi 6y agoWould this also apply to forcing users to enable location for content that only partially requires it? In particular, Snapchat has some location-based filters, but even the ones that don't require location (purely cosmetic, rewind, slow-mo, etc filters) are disabled.
- daveisfera 6y ago> (iii) Artificially increasing the number of impressions or click-throughs of ads, as well as apps that are designed predominantly for the display of ads. So they're going to remove most of the games that my kids have been duped into installing from an ad in another game? ;p
- pkamb 6y ago> Apps should allow a user to get what they’ve paid for without performing additional tasks, such as [...] uploading contacts WhatsApp gates many features behind Contacts access. Do the same rules apply to everyone, even Facebook?
- coronadisaster 6y agoCan they trick you into thinking it is required?
- tempodox 6y agoNice words, but to whom do they apply? Apple just postponed the upcoming iOS 14 tracking restrictions that Facebook complained about to next year.
- egberts1 6y agoYep. Ditched a web cam because some China-made app wanted my location.
- jariel 6y agoApple's policies are starting to read like governmental regulatory documents, and their internal process like an opaque, private Judicial system. This is not good for us in the long run. We need a new version of the FCC that's smart enough to engage lightly for the most part, but heavily and smartly where necessary in this new digital age.
- andrewjl 6y agoThis is a terrific policy. I think irrespective of how good the App Store policies are, every user should be given the right to load non-App Store apps if they so choose. It's totally fine if it's buried 10-levels deep in settings. It's fine if they cannot do it easily by just clicking a random link due to security considerations. It's a good idea to make it hard to do by accident, and I expect if Apple wanted to they could create an awesome UX that preserves safety & security while respecting device owner sovereignty of what can go onto their device. Might seem like a trivial thing, but it would have made all the difference for the civil liberties protests in HK when their app got banned from the App Store.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]