4 ms·
This is great in principle, but it’s only a starting point - there are huge issues that are left unaddressed. The biggest issue is that it presents status as i
by zepto 6y ago
This is great in principle, but it’s only a starting point -
there are huge issues that are left unaddressed.
The biggest issue is that it presents status as if it can be conferred independently of power, or as if we can change the dynamics purely by changing the way we think about this.
Managers have power for many reasons - they generally do have a significant influence over subordinate’s career prospects, and they have access to all kinds of organizational information that ICs simply can’t obtain, at the very least because they can usually spend time in conversation with other managers or in meetings with people at higher levels in the organization.
Engineers obtain power through indispensable or highly valued domain expertise or institutional knowledge.
Both forms of power are real and confer status.
If you move from management to engineering and your power as a manager is not replaced with corresponding power as an engineer then you have been demoted in status, irrespective of how the organization claims to value people.
Organizations that want to deny this, even with the most positive intentions end up gaslighting their employees. I.e. saying things like “Our organization doesn’t see these moves as a demotion”, when manifestly the individual’s power and status has changed in a way they and everyone else can directly perceive.
- jgeada 6y agoICs largely wield informal power within organizations, managers have real formal power, codified in organizations charts, rules and regulations. Whenever there is conflict between the two, almost always formal power wins over informal. Not the least because managers control salaries and hire/fire decisions.
- zepto 6y agoAgreed, although on top of that there is usually an informal power structure within the formal one of the management hierarchy based on who is favored by those above them at a given time.
- mathgladiator 6y agoThe key for those with informal power is how to leverage it to leverage the formal. Get managers to trust you, and you can have both.
- user5994461 6y agoThat's still nowhere near the power of official management. At a bare minimum a manager can summon their underlings, they will come and listen because they depend on him for promotions and have to make a good impression. Try to get your teams or coworkers to do some tasks as an engineer. You will quickly realize you have no power.
- pavel_lishin 6y agoI mean, this varies team by team and company by company. To spit an anecdote into the bucket, I asked some teammates to help me take care of a problem, and they did - and I don't think I hold a particularly large cache of informal power.
- user5994461 6y agoSend a meeting invitation and see how many people show up. Preferably a videocall or a presentation, something not too attractive to come to. Then do the same thing as a random employee. See the difference in how much of your team doesn't show up and absolutely nobody from the other team across the corridor comes.
- yjftsjthsd-h 6y ago> Then do the same thing as a random employee. See the difference in how much of your team doesn't show up and absolutely nobody from the other team across the corridor comes. And then do it not as a random employee, but as the senior employee who isn't technically anyone's manager but who is known for having saved the last 3 major projects by pointing out pivotal details and coordinating with other teams, and observe that everyone who's worked with that person shows up regardless of the org chart. YMMV, but let's compare apples to apples.
- mathgladiator 6y agoIt's strange when one has this power, and managers do fear it. They learn to set expectations and modes of engagement with senior ICs. What's really fun is when you can make a bunch of managers super nervous by mentioning "You know, we should re-org this." and this can trigger all sorts of shit.
- darkerside 6y agoManagers win in the short term. In the long term, the winner is _usually_ but not always, the person who was right.
- ric2b 6y agoHard to get to the long-term if they fire you.
- TheOtherHobbes 6y agoMangers are officer class, in charge of strategy and punishment/reward, seniors are NCO class, in charge of tactics, execution, and frontline people management. Managers should also be in charge of morale and motivational management. Some understand this and are good at it, others don't and aren't.
- john4534243 6y agoIn my experience at non-FAANG organizations managers are people who don't have the capability to code and they barely managed to survive so far.