3 ms·
"bad faith stuff" is not dealt with directly. You could absolutely publish that crate right now, and I would have no inherent recourse about it. For the most p
by steveklabnik 6y ago
"bad faith stuff" is not dealt with directly. You could absolutely publish that crate right now, and I would have no inherent recourse about it.
For the most part, unless a lawyer says that it needs to be taken down, things aren't taken down. There is a small amount of wiggle room around registering a large number of packages in an automated fashion, but generally speaking, the principle is non-intervention.
- renewiltord 6y agoCool. I guess there's no real reason to solve a problem till it's a problem. Hasn't hurt me yet so optimizing for adoption doesn't seem so bad.
- dastbe 6y agoWhat qualifies as "a large number of packages"? As was posted in another thread, it seems like the packages of user https://crates.io/users/swmon https://crates.io/users/swmon would qualify? Alternative to just removing them, would the crates team be more open to transferring ownership of these packages?
- steveklabnik 6y agoThe focus in that sentence is not "a large number of packages," but the "in an automated fashion." Plus, that's only 100 packages. There are people who legitimately maintain more crates than that. > would the crates team be more open to transferring ownership of these packages? https://github.com/rust-lang/rfcs/pull/2614 https://github.com/rust-lang/rfcs/pull/2614
- dastbe 6y agoYeah, it's not obvious what the person I linked's intent is. Resale? I'm pessimistic that the above mechanism would work but I'm glad that rust is thinking about it. fwiw I also don't think namespacing necessarily solves this problem, it just shoves the squatting problem up a level.