3 ms·
If we start with the theory that universal constants are random (big if) then the question he is pushing towards doesn't make any sense. Why does a random numbe
by roenxi 6y ago
If we start with the theory that universal constants are random (big if) then the question he is pushing towards doesn't make any sense. Why does a random number take on a specific value? That is a question for philosophers, not physicists. If we were observing a truly random number then it doesn't mean anything for it to be a specific value.
It is a fair point if nobody has proven (or indeed, can prove) that something in physics is a random number. But alas that does not mean the theory is weak. It is perfectly consistent with the evidence, and mathematically satisfying.
It would be quite exciting if someone can find a reason why we observe specific values and rule out the random number idea. But at some point we know we'll run up against the impossible questions of "why does anything exist at all?", "is it possible for something to not exist?" and "what separates existence from non-existence?". We can't expect to find causal answers for everything.