4 ms·
The instruction for formatting is difficult to find, even if you know it exist https://news.ycombinator.com/formatdoc https://news.ycombinator.com/formatdoc tl;
by gus_massa 6y ago
The instruction for formatting is difficult to find, even if you know it exist https://news.ycombinator.com/formatdoc https://news.ycombinator.com/formatdoc tl;dr: not too much
You need 501 karma to downvote a comment. I think the threshold is a feature, not a bug.
Try to avoid political threads. Each one has his/her opinion and wants to donwvote any alternative.
Technical threads are more safe. Sometime people get downvoted for being wrong, but I don't like it so I upvote gray comments (unless they are offensive or very wrong).
Anyway, I use the downvote very seldom, perhaps only once per day. What do you want to downvote?
The stories fall from the front page when they get many flags. You need only 31 karma to flag. Also when a story gets much more comments that upvotes, it gets a penalty. The mods can sink a story, or remove the penalty of the flags or the automatic penalty.
- brodouevencode 6y ago> Try to avoid political threads. Each one has his/her opinion and wants to donwvote any alternative. This cannot be overstated. Things are weird now: so many folks immediately think you're the devil if you have a countering perspective. Of all things in the social space, this worries me the most.
- feralimal 6y agoVery useful - thanks! I don't want to downvote. I want to know why my comments get downvoted! How does one get that superpower? Because it absolutely seems that I bump into some sort of consensus thinking. I mean, I've been posting in the last months pretty regularly, I'm posting my genuine arguments and positions, that I have come to over years, and I can support. I think they are interesting ideas - or at least they are authentic. And yet 4 months in, I'm currently at 26 points, having scaled the heady heights of 35 points! Jeez, this seems to be a tough audience for people who I think should be open to interesting, unusual and perhaps challenging ideas! > Try to avoid political threads. Each one has his/her opinion and wants to downvote any alternative. Believe it or not, I don't think I'm political. I think I have a philosophical position. I really don't care about left or right. My philosophical position is of a skeptical bent. But, yep, this is misinterpreted as being political. Cheers.
- feralimal 6y agoPS From what you say, it seems that mods are pretty powerful. They can turn a story around or bury it or whatever.. That is all invisible to us users, right? This is to say, we can't say whether the story is authentically popular or unpopular, as we don't have that information. Gah! What happened to free speech? I know that this is a private site... I know. But still, can't we even know that we're being manipulated? Is this our life now, where we cannot be trusted to make judgements for ourselves, but instead all information must be massaged and managed for us?!!?
- gus_massa 6y agoThe mods can literally unplug the sever or modify the sorting algorithm to use the reverse order, or whatever they want.
- feralimal 6y agoYes. I just don't get why its accepted or somehow morally ok to silently manage information for others. The key word is: 'silently'. A mod should be able to manage the conversation, kick people off, delete comments etc, fine - but there should be a note to indicate how whatever bit was impacted. Otherwise, moderators are able to act like gods over a conversation or a forum, accountable to no one. Well, I suppose they will have to judge themselves, but I don't think they are really going to take themselves to task! If people are acting in good faith, they may present information that may be true AND unpleasant to accept or not per consensus opinion. The scientific method should accept the various viewpoints and converge to a better picture of reality. But that can't happen if dissenting voices are closed down. It always surprises me that scientific thinkers, such as there are on this site, are not strongly in support of lots of voices. I don't mean that HN should become a popularity contest or something, but that honest sharing of curiosity and personal experience should be encouraged, not silenced. Seriously, apart from some crap sites (eg 4chan), where can the 'unthinkable' be raised and discussed sensibly nowadays? I don't think there is anywhere.
- gus_massa 6y ago