9 ms·
Chomsky was wrong: evolutionary analysis shows languages obey few rules
- klochner 16y agoIt's impossible to have an intelligent discussion without the original paper. Chomsky didn't claim that all grammars obey the same word order, so it sounds like they're making bigger claims than they should be, assuming they're just showing that word-order is mostly lineage-dependent.
- grovulent 16y agoYeah - so the claim was that the deep structure of the grammar would be persistent - is that right? And this deep structure is something akin to that which is revealed through logical analysis. Is that the gist? I understand the related language of thought arguments better... and have for a long time thought that their empirical credentials were dubious. A straightforward syntactic analysis (as it seems to be described in the article) - isn't going to settle dog meat.
- ihodes 16y agoThe original paper is always at the bottom of Ars articles. That's one reason I subscribe. Anyway, there seems to be a growing body of evidence contrary to Chomsky's universal grammar–see Dan Everett for some more, e.g. It's interesting to see some more about it. (http://www.nature.com/nature/journal/vaop/ncurrent/full/nature09923.html http://www.nature.com/nature/journal/vaop/ncurrent/full/natu...) EDIT: As pointed out below, you probably can't view this unless you're at a university/college with access to Nature. Sorry about that. Open Access is something you should support if this pisses you off.
- mechanical_fish 16y agoI will say: Putting the link at the bottom of the article automatically makes this better than 90% of the "science journalism" I ever see. Now for problem number two: I don't have thirty-two dollars (!) to spend reading this one paper. Neither do most other people who aren't already in the field. For so long as the primary literature is behind these enormous paywalls, science will continue to consist of a tiny tiny percentage of humanity talking to themselves.
- williamdix 16y agoOh yeah! Working at a university pays off again. I'm glad you raised that point, I was about to start commenting about the text of the article and now I realize that everyone may not have access.
- crocowhile 16y agoThere you go: http://min.us/imQUkM.pdf http://min.us/imQUkM.pdf
- eagleal 16y agoThere is here on HN a user that makes freely available for download papers behind pay wall, but can't find his account name (I thought I had it bookmarked). Edit: Ok found it, http://news.ycombinator.com/user?id=freesciencenow http://news.ycombinator.com/user?id=freesciencenow
- tzs 16y agoOr check the local Barnes & Noble. The one in my small town at least has "Nature" in the magazine section, at around $20/copy (but of course you can read it while standing in the magazine section...). At first I thought "this can't be the well known peer reviewed journal!?", but it was full of full research papers and sure appeared to be a peer reviewed journal. I don't know if it is the exact same edition as universities get, or some special edition aimed at members of the general public who happen to like reading research papers. It did have a section in front full of general science news and articles, and the part with the papers didn't seem to have a table of contents which struck me as odd. This wouldn't be the first unexpected thing I have found at a "normal" bookstore. At either a small Waldon's or B. Dalton's in a mall I found a copy of Misner, Thorne, and Wheeler's tome "Gravitation".
- Qz 16y agoChomsky didn't claim that all grammars obey the same word order I didn't get the sense that the article was saying he said that. It does seem pretty clear from the article that the research suggests that the Generative theory is wrong.
- T-R 16y agoI don't get the impression that it's refuting the generative grammar theory as a whole, though, just the assertion by (many? most?) generative linguists that grammars are governed by a set of innate constraints. Granted, I'm not familiar with how much of the basis for acceptance of generative grammar theory hangs on the concept of a universal grammar.
- impendia 16y agoA friend of mine, who is a graduate student in linguistics, told me the following story. (Caveat: this is urban legend-ish; the details could have been exaggerated.) Once Chomsky was giving a lecture on different features of languages. For some feature (call it X; I forget the technical details), he boldly asserted that no human language could conceivably do X and proceeded to go on and on about why X was absolutely impossible. There was a hand from the audience. "Estonian does X."
- leoc 16y agoIt would be hard to put anything beyond a language that has 14 cases: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Estonian_grammar http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Estonian_grammar
- Florin_Andrei 16y ago> given that there aren't obvious word order patterns across languages, how does the human brain do so well at learning the rules that are a peculiarity to any one of them? That simply means there are rules at a deeper level in the brain, and they may crystallize this way, or that way, depending on the particular language. The study, if correct, simply says the rules are not apparent at the outermost level. Well, dig deeper, go closer to the hardware, and at some level the universal order should appear again. After all, my neurons don't work any different than your neurons. But I suspect the highest level where universal rules operate is higher than that.
- entangld 16y agoThere are similar analogies to bird songs. In bird studies, one bird species can be raised completely around a foreign bird species until they learn the foreign songs, yet the native fledgling will sing the new notes in their own species specific patterns (as if there is a neural template). I'm not a linguistic professional, but I imagine humans have some hardwired language patterns and others that are historical artifacts.
- nopassrecover 16y agoOr it could just be because they are different species - that means different vocal chords, different brains, different ears and so on. It's equivalent to saying "chimpanzees act like baby humans when taught to play with blocks, yet still retain distinctive means of movement".
- entangld 16y agoThat study was about the presence of a neural template (and perhaps a linguistic one). Before the study people thought it might be possible for any singing bird to sing any other bird's songs. An abstracted view of the point of the study is perhaps there is some hardwiring in our communication. Kernels of hardwiring that can't be nurtured away. In humans it would be analogous to the universal laws of linguistics. It was just something to think about. Next time I'll just link the study.
- awakeasleep 16y agoI wish I knew more about this subject. For one thing, if we're looking for a biological basis of language, what makes subject-verb order the right level to look on? Why not look at the fact that language is arranged into subjects and verbs as the relevant layer?
- lwhi 16y agoThe main argument I took from Chomsky is that the human brain is predisposed to language. I don't think proving whether language may have (/ may have not) evolved from a single root is so interesting. The interesting part for me, is that the brain is an organ that has evolved in part due to its capability to process language, which in turn has been able to affect our capacity and capability to think. I believe humans do have an innate capacity for language - and this capacity has provided us with an evolutionary advantage. Whether or not all languages are similar or different isn't the point - the fact that the brain is able to efficiently process (and evolve) language can be seen as an example of evolutionary biology whether or not the precise mechanisms are understood.
- travisp 16y agoIt's more than that there is just a predisposition for language. Chomsky argues that this predisposition is a result of a universal grammar, or set of grammar rules for organizing language that is a fundamental part of our brains: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Universal_grammar http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Universal_grammar So, for this theory, it does matter what differences and similarities there are in grammar for different languages, and how those similarities or differences came about. What this study does is show that at least for one aspect of language, word order, what might seem to be universal fundamental rules of grammar are not, and are shaped by cultural, not genetic, evolution.
- lwhi 16y agoBut I don't think a suggestion that there's such a thing as 'universal grammar' is the same as a suggestion that syntactic grammar is going to be shared between all languages. As I understand it, the unifying element of UG could be simplistic or complex - which might make the concept hard to discredit. I'm pretty certain that syntactic grammar would be the result of cultural and genetic evolution. If both factors are available to influence a language's evolution, I'd imagine that both would be likely to influence the way that language evolves to some degree. I think the most interesting part of this mystery is how the brain's capacity for language might be innate - and in this respect, looking at the resultant artefacts produced by this processing might be a bit like looking at the remnants scattered around the room after a party the night before. Perhaps the concept of a shared UG is more relevant to the process than the resulting syntactic structure?
- _delirium 16y agoMaybe I'm reading too much into it, but a genealogical analysis of language seems like a strange way to attack Chomsky's overall hypothesis. The fundamental point of the poverty-of-stimulus argument is that there must be strong inductive biases in whatever language-learning apparatus we possess, since we seem to quickly converge on something deemed grammatical in our language, with relatively few examples. Showing that a particular property varies pretty randomly across languages, correlated only with lineage, is decent evidence that that property isn't universal. That would attack some stronger possible formulations of universal grammar (which maybe Chomsky has actually advanced; I don't recall) that claim not only that we have an inductive bias in language learning, but that: here is a list of specific language features that are universal. But it doesn't show that there isn't some inductive bias, or even a generative-grammar-style inductive bias, where "human language, in all its possible variations" is a parameterized space significantly smaller than the space of all possible symbol protocols, and relatively easy for us to learn because we're hardwired with the parameterization (but not the specific parameter settings). Admittedly I am familiar with machine learning and not very familiar with current work in linguistics, so I could be totally missing some reason that makes my field's methods inapplicable to theirs, inconceivable as that might be. ;-)
- SiVal 16y agoChomsky's idea wasn't that there was a strong inductive bias in language learning, it was that language isn't learned at all; it grows in the brain, as his accolyte Pinker claims, "like teeth grow in the mouth." You don't "learn" to have teeth, do you?, Pinker asks. How can this be, when we see so obviously that kids raised by Greek speakers learn Greek while those raised by English speakers learn English? It's because, acc. to Chomsky and his followers ("Modern Linguists"), Greek and English are really the same language, and kids don't LEARN this language, called "Universal Grammar," they GROW it. What they DO learn is the values of some "parameters" that cause different instantiations of UG to appear superficially different, like Greek and English. This quickly required the definition of "language" to exclude every aspect of language except syntax, because everything else so obviously was learned and wasn't universal, and even with syntax, they ended up having to exclude the syntax actually used by real speakers really speaking. That syntax become known as "performance" as distinct from "competence", which was the universal language people really knew deep down inside but which got corrupted in real use by various noise-inducing factors. So "real language" became syntax only, and then, only carefully constructed written examples of proper, uncorrupted "competence" syntax. And with those, all native speakers could use their innate rules plus parameter settings to unanimously agree on which word sequences were valid and which were invalid. You had a rule-based syntax with universal rules, right? Except that, with each passing year, researchers outside the linguistics departments found more and more examples where native speakers disagreed over validity, and validity decisions that weren't discrete (clearly valid or clearly invalid) but were often shades of gray. (Inside linguistics departments, conformity to Chomskyism orthodoxy was usually enforced, as academia tends to do, so "linguistics research" has supported Chomsky for decades, while cognitive science hasn't.) There were so many differences among native speakers of a single language, not to mention the ever-growing catalog of diversity between languages and the way that languages gradually diverge instead of in clearly discrete jumps, and so many shades of gray in judgments among natives that the notion of parameters got more and more ridiculous, even with the notion of "language" pared down to almost nothing. Sure, you could claim that all books are the same universal book, too, as long as each character is a parameter. If so, then all languages are the same language under the surface, too, plus or minus some parameter settings. Chomsky's ridiculous language ideas would have been thrown out long ago if he hadn't been such a leftist "intellectual icon" in the leftist temples of academia and media. Instead, his theory just changed dramatically from version to version but remained unquestionably true throughout. Every few years he would significantly revamp his "program." In 2002 he seemed to abandon everything about syntax, too, except for recursion. What's unique about human language, as opposed to the general principles found in all human (and some animal) cognition, is just the innate, universal ability to handle recursion in syntax. (That paper apparently infuriated Pinker by cutting his "Language Instinct" position down to just a syntactical recursion instinct.) What a bunch of nonsense. And this paper is just one more nail in the coffin of "modern linguistics".
- thisrod 16y agoHere's my understanding of Chomsky's argument. Facts: I can write sentences that no one has ever spoken before. The rest of you will have opinions whether they are allowed in English. Those opinions will tend to agree. Conclusion: Our knowledge of English is not purely derived from the sentences we've heard. We must have had some model of a language in common when we started, and we fit the parameters to what we heard as children. I find that more convincing than anything in the linked article.
- williamdix 16y agoI think Ars and maybe the authors of the original article are way over-stating the significance of this article. I think the evidence presented in the article is convincing but it is not convincing as a refutation of UG. It seems at best to argue that head-firstness or complement-firstness are not actually features of languages.
- deleted 16y ago[deleted]
- ezy 16y agoOk, maybe this is why UG always sounds so wrongheaded to me when explained in layman's terms: Our knowledge of English is not purely derived from the sentences we've heard. If you were to take the sentences in isolation, devoid of meaning and context, I suppose you might end up being circular. But new sentences are being thrown at you all the time (the training data is ~unlimited). Even a computer can recognize common patterns unsupervised, then apply those patterns to learning other patterns on subsequent data, and finally classify examples has never seen before -- this seems weak. And doubly so if you consider that it isn't just a sentence we've heard, but a sentence about a real noun and a real verb that exists in space (at least initially). If I pick up a ball and say "ball" consistently, bam, you now have some kind of tagged input to work with. We must have had some model of a language in common when we started, and we fit the parameters to what we heard as children. Even taken the first sentence as given, why does that imply a UG? Perhaps the model is built from observed reality first, then language is built using that model? Or, maybe, to argue Chomsky's side, the "UG" is an extremely simple bias... Now, Chomsky has probably addressed these things, but to a layman, the typical justifications seem a little weak.
- williamdix 16y agoSo here is the issue that the actual article discusses. In generating sentences, you have grammars with rewrite rules like PP(Prepositional Phrase) := P(Preposition)NP(Noun Phrase). In such a rule, the preposition is the head. There is an assertion that languages have the property head-first or complement-first. In this case, the complement-first rule would instead be PP := NP(Noun Phrase) P(Preposition) So in head-first languages, we would see: PP := P NP The man is PP(in the house) VP := V NP I VP(ate the bird) And in complement-first languages, we would see: PP := NP P The man is PP(the house in) VP := NP V I VP(the bird ate) The article states that if head-first and complement-first were robust, universal features of languages, then we would expect the evolutionary model to show that the appearances of word orders demonstrating these features are dependent on each other across language families. However, it does not show this across the language families. It only shows that certain word orders created by head-firstness or complement-firstness are dependent in certain language families. I hope this was a decent enough explanation and easy for others to follow. I was a Linguistics major, so it can be hard for me to explain it well and in an easy to understand way. [edited in an attempt at formatting] [edited to provide more examples]
- neilk 16y agoThanks for this! However, I'm not seeing how this strikes at Chomsky's theory. It does give us some insight into mental machinery, that languages aren't necessarily parsimonious in reusing the same structures across NPs and VPs. But what's the significance?
- williamdix 16y agoThe Ars article way over-states the significance. It should really say something like "Chomsky was wrong, languages are not only head-first or complement-first, and they only appear that way because of cultural inheritance, not universal rules" But that's not very exciting, is it?
- T-R 16y agoI'm admittedly having a bit of trouble parsing the first sentence of your last paragraph. When you say "if head-first and complement-first were robust, universal features of languages", do you mean "head-first and complement-first cover the whole set of possibilities for the property 'word order'", or "all languages (within a family?) are one or the other", or something more like "a given language cannot contain both head-first and complement-first structures", or something different? Also, with "appearances of word orders demonstrating these features are dependent on each other across language families", in what sense do you mean that the appearances would be dependent on each other?
- Tycho 16y agoLanguage is a recursive process, and (according to GEB) a property of recursive processes tends to be wild unpredictability the deeper you go. Just thinking aloud.
- nickpinkston 16y agoSounds like languages aren't manufactured by consent ;-) Sorry - I couldn't resist ;-)
- samtp 16y agoThe phrase "Manufacturing Consent" has nothing to do with universal grammar. It is about the factors that create a news environment that favors specific interests.
- nickpinkston 16y agoYes, I fully know that. I read Chomsky's politics far more than linguistics. I was making a joke where the analogy was that: A: Languages were the 5 factors of media control cover in MC. B: "Consent" was a common set of language principles representing Chomsky's linguistics. Too much of a reach?
- brudgers 16y agoGenerative grammar, verb-noun order disproves? Against Bayesian analysis, "Wittgenstein's language games predisposed to play we are," universal grammar better describes. English still Yoda speak is.
- compay 16y agoI studied linguistics in the 90's, including a class and a few seminars with Chomsky, but left grad school after a year. At this point I'm neither a linguist nor an expert but maintain a slightly more than passive interest in the field. These kinds of crackpot articles surface every couple of years in the mainstream press, always from people who demonstrate no knowledge of Chomsky's work beyond having read the back cover of his 1965 "Aspects of the Theory of Syntax." I didn't read the original article, but as described in the Ars article, the thesis makes absolutely no sense whatsoever. The fact that we may have a hard time reconciling how languages can be diverse in their handling of subject/object/verb order doesn't disprove the concept of Universal Grammar. In fact, it's an argument for Universal Grammar that we can even have a coherent conversation about the way all languages handle subject/object/verb order - Universal Grammar is not about providing a set of rules describe all languages, it's about explaining what a possible rule is, and you have to approach that with logic rather than statistics. The Ars article talks about "languages that have been evolving for a minimum of 4,000 years," as if those languages simply sprung into existence a little more than 4 millennia ago with no relation to anything else. This is the linguistic equivalent of creationism. [Edit: expanded acronym "UG" to "Universal Grammar" for clarity]
- jxcole 16y agoSorry, but even though my passing knowledge of linguists may be far outstripped by yours, I still think you may be mistaken. The statements made by the article are related to something called Universal Grammar, it is not related to syntax theory or Chomsky hierarchies: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Universal_grammar http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Universal_grammar According to the article, Chomsky probably didn't invent universal grammar, but he was certainly a strong proponent. As to the second point, the article claims that languages have been evolving for a minimum of 4,000 years, not a maximum of four thousand years. This is a perfectly accurate statement about all known species of animals. All it really says is that we have records that lead us to know for certain that certain sets of languages had common roots as soon as 4,000 years ago, but we are not sure about their common roots before that. This sort of argument is very common in genetics; I recall reading a book about how human men can all be traced to a common ancestor 90,000 years back. This does not imply that scientists believe humans sprang into being 90,000 years ago.
- VladRussian 16y ago>Human languages are far more complex than any animal communication system we're aware of... may be we need to spend some time out of the anthropocentric box. There is a whole world outside of it.
- SlipperySlope 16y agoI'm writing a robust parser for English using the principles of construction grammar. In contrast with Chomsky, CG has as its chief characteristic a pairing between form and semantics. We learn that "bird" means the concept of bird. We learn idioms the same way: "he's a cool customer" means the concept of a person calm in pressure situations. One is indeed lucky if born into a culture with patterns between these pairings. In my opinion there is no universal grammar and if my parser eventually works for English, it will have completely different construction rules for each targeted natural language beyond English.
- grandalf 16y agoChomsky proposes only two rules: Merge and Move.
- jonknee 16y agoThe author of the paper is on Reddit and is taking questions. http://www.reddit.com/r/science/comments/gpb84/chomsky_was_wrong_evolutionary_analysis_shows/c1pa7xp http://www.reddit.com/r/science/comments/gpb84/chomsky_was_w...
- Cacti 16y agoAnd all this time, I thought the language hierarchy, and it's correspondence with math/logic categories, was the real theory. UG is kind of an irrelevant side point, sort of an argument between "strong" vs "weak". Type 0 - Recursivey enumerable. Type 1 - Context-sensitive. Type 2 - Context-free. Type 3 - Regular. As all languages fall into one of those 4 categories, and no other (so far), that seems to me to be THE definition of "following the rules" to an extreme. Once you've identified which category a language is in, the word order and semantics are pretty damned irrelevant, as any experience computer programmer can attest (Java vs C++, Python vs Ruby, etc).