3 ms·
>suggested midi keyboard Uses non-weighted keys. Nobody should have to ever suffer a non-weighted keyboard.
by snvzz 6y ago
>suggested midi keyboard
Uses non-weighted keys. Nobody should have to ever suffer a non-weighted keyboard.
- lukeh 6y agoDepends on what you're doing, cheap USB controllers are fine for "data entry".
- bregma 6y agoYes. Semi-weighted is my minimum. 88 keys if I have a choice. Less than 66 keys is like playing a 2-string guitar. Just like my computer keyboard: mechanical, clicky, and with sufficient travel and resistance to let me know a key has been pressed.
- bluGill 6y agoIf you are trying to play piano than yes. However pipe organs have never had 88 keys. Weight on pipe organ keys varied (some of the old organs with pure mechanical actions were much heavier than a piano, while modern - for 1920 - keyboards are unweighted). Key size was often smaller than a piano keyboard as well.
- snarfy 6y ago> Less than 66 keys is like playing a 2-string guitar. I've found I need an odd number of octaves. Even number of octaves is kind of useless. The songs I can play on a 3 or 4 octave device are the same, but 5 octaves opens up more. I bought a 49 key controller and had to send it back.
- marcan_42 6y agoThat's personal preference. I like my weighted keyboard when I'm playing piano, and my non-weighted keyboard when I'm playing synths. If you're just doing MIDI recording into a DAW with significant postprocessing (quantization, velocity adjustment) for styles where that is warranted, then there is little point to a weighted keyboard.
- criddell 6y agoWeighted like a piano where the lowest key is heavier than the highest key? I never understood why you would want to carry that physical limitation over to digital other than it's something you are used to.
- marcan_42 6y agoWeighted as in with a key action simulating the hammers of a piano (to some extent). Most weighted keyboards are also, as you say, graduated from the lowest to the highest note. Weighted keyboards are easier to play expressively, because the added mass allows you to impart velocity onto the key over a period of time. A non-weighted keyboard effectively reacts to how fast/hard you move your finger, with little resistance, while a weighted keyboard integrates how much force you apply to the key over the milliseconds it takes to press it. It makes a difference. It also means you can "launch" keys without having to apply force all the way down, and inertia will take it there. On the other hand, if you're playing with organ sounds of synths, a non-weighted keyboard lets you do faster glissandos and faster key repetition and rhythmic playing. So it depends on what you're doing and what you're used to.
- navbaker 6y agoThis is strictly personal preference. If you aren't already a piano player, you may find it more desirable not to have weighted keys. There's also the cost aspect, if you're just trying to get your feet wet in making music, you probably don't want to make that kind of financial investment.
- compiler-guy 6y agoNo organist on the planet is bothered by the lack of weighted keys.
- analog31 6y agoOddly enough, the old mechanical tracker organs required a fair amount of strength to play.