3 ms·
The failure lies in the ownership model: a telco company trying to build a walled garden. Other walled gardens failed as well of course including some that were
by jillesvangurp 6y ago
The failure lies in the ownership model: a telco company trying to build a walled garden. Other walled gardens failed as well of course including some that were basically much more competitive in terms of networking. E.g. AOL failed a few years later because the world outside their walled garden was more interesting. It never really stood a chance of surviving despite being much more similar to the internet at that time.
Operators trying to build walled gardens is a pattern that repeated itself until it became such a low margin business that the only operators able to make a profit were those merely offering full internet over 3G and 4G and not even bothering with the black hole of R&D needed to keep up with what was happening elsewhere. There were attempts in both standards to grandfather in a lot of stuff that is now exclusively done over IP but none of it ended up being popular. The history of mobile phone operators is just a long succession of attempts to copy things from the internet at the time and trying to turn them into walled garden things. Each of those things failed. We're not watching TV via operator provided services. We're not doing video calls via operator provided services, their game portals have long died and faded away. We're not browsing any WAP sites. Instagram wiped out what little adoption MMS ever had. None of it stood a chance.
The incentives and ownership were just wrong and the role as operators as essential middlemen just never panned out in the real world as they hoped.
Many telcos of course managed to convert themselves into successful mobile operators ultimately but their role was diminished to providing network access. My android phone has a phone stack. The only stuff that comes in via my phone number is basically recruiter cold calls. It's a small internet device with some quaint legacy features that I rarely use. Really, numeric identifiers that you have to punch in? In 2020? How is that still a thing? I remember memorizing shit like that a few decades ago.
So, minitel is merely an early and probably expensive incarnation of that. France telecom subsidized the devices and had to earn it back via regular network charges. I doubt that generated anywhere near what they hoped in revenue.
- philprx 6y agoAbsolutely all true, these notions actually share the same model: centrally controlled, no control at terminal / no open access for new entrants, consumption devices are locked to consume only, hard to “become center” or provider, etc. The networking model was a logical consequence (and practical implementation) of the the centrally controlled walled garden you describe. Many hackers were trying to escape it by becoming their own providers and also connecting with other international x25 servers and foreign hackers. For example, Assange was actually from these times. Nevertheless, it did generate much more revenue than what they initially envisioned.
- dnpp123 6y ago> Operators trying to build walled gardens is a pattern that repeated itself until Dedicated private companies (myspace, facebook, gmail, etc...) started building walled gardens.
- jillesvangurp 6y agoYeah but their business model was different: they started with a compelling garden and then users convinced themselves they needed to be in it. Basically the telcos came from another direction: "hey our users are not paying us for that stuff they are doing with some other company on our network! Lets fix it by copying that stuff in some half-assed way and then charge for it." That's a bad idea because now you are charging for stuff that users are already getting elsewhere that they don't really need you for. So, you basically end up with an empty room problem. Worse, due to the network effect some of these things don't make sense if they are operator specific. E.g. An O2 only social network or video call service is just not a thing. So, now we are talking standardization and design by committee. This is exactly why most of the stuff in 3G flopped (other than IP networking): they were years late to market with stuff that barely worked with basically noone caring about it.
- Dahoon 6y ago> My android phone has a phone stack. The only stuff that comes in via my phone number is basically recruiter cold calls. It's a small internet device with some quaint legacy features that I rarely use. Funny how people live in totally different bubbles. I see you are based in Berlin (I'm in Denmark) and I have no idea how it is there but here I -as a geek with very geeky friends- don't know anyone who use their phone as you describe. Sure a few calls are via Facebook with video and some messages too (though many are starting to refuse to use social media) but the overwhelming majority of use is normal old phone-calls, SMS and MMS. Inside my bubble things like you describe (internet based stuff) is where "old people" have moved and younger people are moving away from. Especially those who hate all the data mining done by Apple, Facebook, Google, etc. I don't have a single app on my phone with those capabilities you use and I'm not missing out. Of course I'm sure other very different bubbles are right next door :-) >Operators trying to build walled gardens is a pattern that repeated itself Apple, Facebook...
- jillesvangurp 6y agoPhone calls or text messages are rare for me. I can't remember the last time I sent an SMS message. I've not received an MMS message in over a decade and even then that was relatively rare (less than 10 times in the years that that was a thing at all). So, that stuff is completely dead as far as I'm concerned. I don't think most young people even know stuff like MMS exists. Did Apple ever bother to implement that at all on IOS? As I recall they were not in a hurry to implement that when the iphone launched originally. The only numbers I call are people like my Doctor to make an appointment because they don't do email for whatever reason (which would make a lot of business sense for them). But mostly my phone is a mini tablet for me. Young people here mainly distinguish themselves by maybe using different networks. People who hate Facebook are common. People who understand Facebook actually also runs Instagram and Whatsapp are less common. Last time I checked they are still getting a lot of daily use, also from Denmark.
- C1sc0cat 6y agoYou don't get sms notifications/reminders from your doctors / hospitals? about appointments In the UK sms messaging is a key part of a lot of taxi films work flow - who needs UBER