2 ms·
> empathy is not comprehension? Not in the sense in which the law requires you to comprehend the consequences of your actions. An insane person could feel bad
by pdonis 6y ago
> empathy is not comprehension?
Not in the sense in which the law requires you to comprehend the consequences of your actions. An insane person could feel bad after killing someone because they respond with empathy after the fact, but still not have comprehended before the fact that what they were doing was going to kill someone. The latter, if established beyond a reasonable doubt, would mean they would not meet the legal comprehension requirement.
And, conversely, a psychopath could comprehend perfectly well before the fact that what they were doing was going to kill someone, but feel nothing because they don't care. They would still meet the legal requirement for comprehension.
(Disclaimer: IANAL.)
- perl4ever 6y agoI think you're implying that somehow one has comprehension only before, and empathy only after. Why can't you have either in either order?
- pdonis 6y ago> I think you're implying that somehow one has comprehension only before, and empathy only after. No, I'm just saying that to establish legal comprehension, you can't look at empathy, because they're two different things. They might go together--in normal, sane people they almost always will go together, both before and after--but you can't rely on it, since the people you are going to ask the question about in the first place--the people for whom you might have to evaluate a possible insanity defense--are precisely the people in whom you can't rely on them going together.