15 ms·
Vinyl LPs Sell More Than CDs for the First Time in 3 Decades
- notRobot 6y agoMakes sense. Vinyl and cassettes are both cool retro tech. CDs are just... meh. I have one friend who listens to music on (or at least collects) vinyl. I have another friend who listens to casettes and makes mixtapes. I don't know anyone who uses CDs.
- SyneRyder 6y agoIt probably helps that most vinyl releases also include a free FLAC download. So you get your collector's deluxe edition with inlay signed by the band, plus a lossless quality (or even 24-bit better-than-CD) version without having to rip the download yourself. I'm sure there are some people playing vinyl, but I also bet a lot of these are never being played, it's just decorative.
- agotterer 6y agoI play vinyl! There’s something special about the the experience of taking a record out of its sleeve, the white noise while you wait for the pin to pick up, and then listening through the entire album. It’s not something I do every day. Most of my music is streamed. But I find when I stream I rarely listen to a full album. Apple killed the full album.
- samatman 6y agoDid they, though? I guess we never know if we're typical or not, but I tend to add an album at a time to my collection and listen to them that way as well. If anything is killing the album, it's that it is a somewhat artificial medium, dictated by the constraints of records and later, CDs. It seems like it's surviving on its own merits, there are a couple of albums from this year I really enjoy. But it's bound to be less popular now that it's just another way to listen to your choice of music, instead of the only way.
- asutekku 6y agoYou can go to last.fm to check any album you like and really likely you will find out that the plays are not spread evenly.
- coldtea 6y agoWell, everything in art is artificial, and most things are dictated by this or that physical constraint. That doesn't make it less important once they materialize.
- agotterer 6y agoNothing you are saying is inaccurate. People bought albums because that’s how music was historically sold and they had no alternative. My understanding is that artists also embraced that constraint and created albums to create a specific experience (vibe, song order, etc). Apple started selling individual songs and for the first time people were able to buy music without buying the whole album. So yes, Apple killed the album.
- samatman 6y agoAlright, fair enough. Though I gotta say: I was around and listening to music at the time, and it was Napster which struck the death blow. Apple came along a couple years later to put the album out of its misery. The album doesn't seem dead, so much as diminished, but I know a harmless rhetorical flourish when I see one...
- rob74 6y agoThat's done to make up for one of the major disadvantages of vinyl records: that you can't easily rip them. Ok, ripping CDs is also getting more difficult - I upgraded my desktop PC recently and then found out I need a PATA adapter card to connect my old DVD-RW drive if I want to rip CDs, but haven't gotten around to it yet. Laptops have also gotten rid of CD/DVD drives completely. Fortunately Amazon has an "AutoRip" feature for most CDs where you can download an album digitally after you have bought it from them...
- SyneRyder 6y agoYep, I know exactly what you mean - I've got a cheap portable LG USB CD/DVD drive on my desk right now, so I can convert any CDs I buy to FLAC and progressively re-rip my MP3 collection. Buying CDs is getting harder too, Amazon Australia doesn't carry many new CDs and AutoRip isn't an option in Australia. I occasionally buy vinyl, I have some vinyl Super Deluxe editions around me, and getting the free FLAC makes the purchasing decision much easier for me. I get the album in full quality to play, plus all the bonus tracks & physical merch and something to put in my display cabinet.
- Zippogriff 6y agoUSB CD+DVD burners are nearly disposable-cheap and very convenient to use, now. The "good" ones are under $30 and crappy ones as low as $15. They're barely larger than a CD jewel case, weigh ~nothing, and are powered entirely over USB, so no external power brick.
- oxygenjoe 6y agoCassette to aux in adapter? Like $10. Cd to aux in? Doesn't exist, gotta replace the head unit. CDs were a step in the wrong direction
- RodgerTheGreat 6y agoAgreed. The period between the ubiquity of 3.5" floppies and cheap USB drives was very uncomfortable for similar reasons. CD-RWs sucked.
- Tepix 6y agoIf you had a MP3 capable CD-disc change with say 6 CDs in your car, you had 60 CDs at your disposal. Usually that's way more than the number of tapes had in their cars. And the quality was a lot better than tapes. Plus if you're into audiobooks you could get away with 64kbit mono MP3 which doubles the capacity.
- matheusmoreira 6y agoThank god CDs are gone. Their only use these days is to serve as sources for perfect FLAC copies. A flash drive with digital audio files is objectively superior in every way. At least vinyl and cassette have the quality of being analog.
- systemvoltage 6y agoI much prefer CDs than records. At least you can skip the songs with a remote control, sound quality is far superior than records and the entire thing is compact and lasts forever. Relatively speaking.
- matheusmoreira 6y agoThose advantages are specific to digital audio, not CDs. You get the same features if you have a FLAC collection on a flash drive. What you said is true when compared to analog mediums like vinyl. Even the dust that's sitting on top of the record can color the audio and that's before we even consider the quality of the turntable hardware. People actually perceive vinyl as the better medium because of this.
- systemvoltage 6y agoYou're right. That's why I said, "Relatively speaking".
- saalweachter 6y agoI mostly rely on digital music in various forms, but there is one advantage to vinyl: it removes choice. It's one of those "paradox of choice" things; the more decisions you have to make, the less happy you are. When listening to a record, I just have to decide to put the record on, and then all choice is removed from me and I just sit back and enjoy the ride. I don't have to decide whether to skip a track or whether to jump from a playlist to a specific song I just thought about; the "would I rather be doing something else?" part of my brain takes a break.
- temporallobe 6y agoPersonally, I consider CDs to be retro tech, after all they go back to 1977. Though not perfect, they are the ideal audio format - uncompressed, high resolution, excellent dynamic range, DRM-free, and compact enough to reduce space while being large enough for at least some artwork. I do enjoy the “experience” of vinyl records more, but after years of messing with finicky turntables, expensive cartridges, and preamps to achieve marginally better sound, I realized CDs had perfect sound in the first place with no fuss aside from the occasional scratched discs. One of the problems I have with vinyl is that with every usage you’re degrading it. For that reason I’ve stopped playing some of my most valuable and treasured vintage records for fear of making them unplayable. I typically make a high-res recording of the vinyl and listen to that instead (and yes I realize that defeats the purpose of the all-analog signal chain, but my ears can’t tell the difference).
- matheusmoreira 6y ago> that defeats the purpose of the all-analog signal chain What is this purpose?
- User23 6y agoAnalog is continuous and digital is discrete and that implies a loss information. Theoretically at least, any digitalization in the signal chain involves a significant, if not perceptible, loss in signal information content. Personally I'm borderline tone-deaf so I can't tell the difference, but I'm not going to call the people who say they can tell the difference liars.
- fsh 6y agoIt is a misconception that digital is lossy but analog is not. In digital recording, the finite bit depth of the sampling process effectively adds a small amount of white noise to the signal (the difference between the sampled value and the true value). In analog recordings there are also plenty of noise sources, for example the grain size of a magnetic tape or the surface roughness of a vinyl. The difference is that the sampling noise level of a CD is way lower than what is physically possible for any analog medium. This is why we hear "tape hiss" and "vinyl crackle" during quiet parts of the music, but we don't hear "CD hiss". On top of that, nonlinearities anywhere within the analog signal chain introduces distortions that don't exist for a digital signal. Overall, a signal reproduced from a CD is much closer to the true signal than any analog medium could ever achieve.
- aidenn0 6y agoI'm down to buying a half dozen CDs each year. Uncompressed audio, and usually cheaper than MP3s new, and far cheaper used.
- Cthulhu_ 6y agoWe have some CD's to use in the car, said car does have bluetooth but the signal isn't very good.
- snarfy 6y agoI used to write cdrom driver software. I've been organizing my stuff and came across my old references for the redbook, yellowbook, and bluebook specs. They went right in the trash.
- systemvoltage 6y agoI got into the whole thing and now my records are shelved in the attic and tone arm has been dead for over 5 years. Records are a real pain in the ass. I understand its a hobby, good for you. https://i.pinimg.com/originals/b2/7d/cb/b27dcb7a032184951f287de69c6fd63f.jpg https://i.pinimg.com/originals/b2/7d/cb/b27dcb7a032184951f28...
- armadsen 6y agoI got into vinyl in my teens (I'm in my mid 30s now), before the "vinyl revival" really started. I still listen to and buy it as much as I ever did, and my collection is quite large. I also listen to digital music, both streaming and stuff ripped from my CDs, downloaded from download cards that come with vinyl, and digitized directly from my LPs. There's certainly room for both. But when I put music on for the family, or want to sit down and really listen to a record, it's always on vinyl. To each their own, but this statistic itself shows that there are plenty of people who truly enjoy and find value in vinyl.
- dsubburam 6y agoDoes vinyl work well for classical music (what I listen to mostly)? I've seen posts like the following saying that the large dynamic range isn't captured well (in particular, soft sections sound too noisy): https://forum.audiogon.com/discussions/what-s-wrong-with-classical-music-on-vinyl https://forum.audiogon.com/discussions/what-s-wrong-with-cla... Curious to hear your/others' more recent/informed experience.
- nijaru 6y agoI’m no expert audio engineer, but the dynamic range of vinyl is limited by the space between the grooves. That being said, it shouldn’t have any effect on the quality of the audio, just the difference in volume of the loudest and softest parts.
- siquick 6y agoThe saturation applied to a lot of pressings (which gives vinyl its supposed warmth) usually adds weight to the low frequencies and rounds off some of the high frequencies so I can't really see that translating too well to something with such a wide dynamic range. It's far from a perfect representation of the recording. Perfect sound quality isn't really why you should be buying vinyl - there's far too many points of failure in the signal chain from the pressing of the record, the stylus, the preamp and the speakers. You'd be better off getting a nice soundcard and playing CDs or 24 Bit WAV/AIFF files from your laptop. Quote by John Peel. “Somebody was trying to tell me that CDs are better than vinyl because they don’t have any surface noise. I said, ‘Listen, mate, life has surface noise'”
- mikece 6y agoThere is the concept that constraints drive artists to make better art within the defined limits. Vinyl has so much less tonal and dynamic information recording capacity than CDs... today’s artists spend more effort and energy “exploring the limits” rather than creating great art. Outside of classical music and opera, what forms of music are unquestionably better on CD than vinyl or cassette?
- aidenn0 6y agoI have some Dire Straits albums from around 1990 on CD, and they sound amazing. Mastering seemed to go way downhill in the late 90s. Cassette has no advantage for me other than nostalgia, and the fact that a lot of music wouldn't exist without such a cheaply available recording medium. [Edit] corrected year from 1900 -> 1990
- scns 6y agonice typo. Made me laugh. Had to comment on it even though i know humour is frowned upon. [edit] added explanation.
- mikece 6y agoIt’s late and I’ve been drinking red wine... what did I misspell?
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- aidenn0 6y agoIt was my typo. I have no CDs from 1900...
- aidenn0 6y agoHumor isn't frowned upon, but comments that are limited to pure wit are, just because everybody likes them in the small, but nobody wants them to dominate the discussion in the large.
- siquick 6y agoBeen buying records pretty much non-stop since 97. Aside from a few pictures, photos and gig ticket stubs, they're pretty much the only physical form of reference to my cultural interests I have from the last 25 years. This is probably anecdotal, but I can recall a huge amount of my collection pretty much instantly when someone asks me which records I have by artist X, or which records did I buy in 2019. I have the complete opposite for books I read on my Kindle - if someone asks me which books I read last year or who the author of the last book I read was then I find it a challenge to recall. The tangibility of physical media just seems to give me a better connection to the album, artist, label and songs. But yes, moving house is an absolute pain and it's a ridiculously expensive hobby.
- function_seven 6y ago> but I can recall a huge amount of my collection pretty much instantly when someone asks me which records I have by artist X, or which records did I buy in 2019. When I first started buying CDs, in 1992 or so, I kept them in the order purchased. By the time I went to college, I had about 150 albums on one long rack. No groupings by artist, or publish date, or genre, or anything like that. Just ordered by when I acquired them.* It was a strange system, but I was surprised how easily I could locate any of them, and I think you're right. The tangibility of it. Now I have probably 20 times as much music on my phone (plus access to everything else on Apple Music). And It's harder than ever to decide what I want to listen to. I strongly suspect I wouldn't have this issue if my entire library was physically in front of me. (* Things got muddy when I'd get 10 or 12 CDs at a time, by repeatedly joining Columbia House or BMG under new fake names. Those just grouped together in the rack in a random order within the subset)
- siquick 6y ago> Now I have probably 20 times as much music on my phone (plus access to everything else on Apple Music). And It's harder than ever to decide what I want to listen to. I strongly suspect I wouldn't have this issue if my entire library was physically in front of me. I got rid of Spotify a couple of months ago and started fresh with Tidal. I purposely haven't build a single playlist and just have a collection of 20/30 albums on rotation saved. I've found the whole thing really liberating - I was so reliant on the playlists that I'd built up on Spotify over the last decade and was pretty bored with my own taste. A lot of people I know rely on their Spotify playlists for music so much that if you put them in charge of the music at a party then they would barely be able to think of 5 songs off the top of their head.
- LeoPanthera 6y agoBy dollar value, not by units sold. In 1H 2020, CDs sold: 10.2 million, records sold: 8.8 million. So the headline is extremely misleading.
- armadsen 6y agoYeah, I agree that's misleading, but I don't know about extremely. The fact that sales are within a few 10s of percent is pretty remarkable, and I say that as someone who has been avidly buying vinyl since the early 2000s when CDs were still selling an order of magnitude or more units. Of course, vinyl sales have grown, but just as importantly online music sales and streaming have caused CD sales to decrease sharply over the past 10-15 years.
- RedShift1 6y agoIf only they would master CD's properly... The loudness wars really killed the audio quality and persists to this day. That's probably one of the reasons why people associate harsh and sharp to digital audio, even though CD made before the loudness wars sound absolutely brilliant.
- stan_rogers 6y agoNo, the very earliest brick-wall filtered CDs were far, far worse, and largely where the CD's poor reputation came from. The ability to oversample and downsample largely dealt with the truly grating effects of phase shift in the higher frequencies (harmonics being nowhere near in proper phase with the fundamental tones). The godawful remasters once the technical problems were overcome just added insult to injury, really.
- AdmiralGinge 6y agoEither way, it seems like the whole debate is kind of misplaced. Analogue and digital systems have pros and cons, but crappy mastering will make almost every single one of them irrelevant in terms of sound quality. Personally I think vinyl often sounds better simply because it takes a higher quality of engineering to make it work at all. It's the limitations of the medium that mean you can't just compress it halfway to buggery and crank the loudness up like you can with a CD.
- globular-toast 6y agoIt is a shame. CDs have a number of real advantages over vinyl records and dynamic range is a big one. But most pop/rock CDs take no advantage of it at all. I have some classical CDs that would never work on vinyl, though.
- Mizza 6y agoI love records. There are plenty of reasons why records are great that don't usually get mentioned here. * The big one: There is tons of music out there that isn't on streaming services. If you like punk, breakcore, UK dubstep, noise, really anything even a little bit out of the mainstream, or from the past - you can't find the best stuff on any streaming services. If I could only make one point, this would be it. Spotify! Doesn't! Haven't! Everything! You'll never dance around your living room to the good version of This Bike is a Pipebomb's 'Better Off Dead', because you don't have the split 7". * Vinyl is a good value store. If you keep good care of your records - and you have good taste - you'll find that your collection _appreciates_ in value over time, unlike other forms which _depreciate_. Some of the records I picked up in high school are worth over a hundred bucks now! Not that I plan on ever selling them, but it's nice to know I could. * Vinyl is something to do while traveling! It's great going to another country or city and browsing the record shops and finding something you're after, or something funky looking in the $2 bin. Random finds in dollar bins are a bit like Magic: The Gathering cards - usually crap, but occasionally brilliant. Plus, whenever you take it out, you get to remember the trip you got it on. * Sampling. I make hip hop, and samples from vinyls just sound better with that real grit. They just do. Records! Yeah!
- Cthulhu_ 6y agoI have a handful of records in a sturdy box for collection purposes, probably nothing fancy and it's all on Spotify and co as well, but I like having physical copies, and if you get physical copies because of collecting, vinyl is really good. Should get a player sometime, maybe. Anyway all of my vinyl is fairly modern (>2000's). I do scour the secondhand shops sometimes but all the good stuff will have been sniped by the staff (they'll just pay a token amount or just squirrel it away) for their own collection or to be sold on ebay.
- vmception 6y ago> Spotify! Doesn't! Haven't! Everything! You'll never dance around your living room to the good version of This Bike is a Pipebomb's 'Better Off Dead' the secret ingredient is piracy
- 6y ago
- ponker 6y agoMy favorite thing about vinyl collecting is that there's no digital obsolescence. You can build a record player out of a motor and a piece of paper. It's like having a paper book vs. an e-book or photographic slides vs. a terabyte of JPEGs.
- ss64 6y agoThis is a good point, I think only a handful of factories are still making CD transports. They are readable in computers but only because of compatibility with the DVD disc and those are already disappearing from most new devices. It seems entirely possible that within our lifetimes it may no longer be possible to buy a CD player.
- tialaramex 6y agoThe text in the book whether paper or electronic is digital, like PCM or JPEG. The slides and vinyl decay gradually and irrecoverably even within a lifetime. You can illustrate the principle well enough with your player built "out of a motor and a piece of paper" but the music will be too distorted to want to listen to it. So I don't think this has much practical meaning. The use of digital data means the CD transport is completely independent of the music on a CD, if you aren't interested in spinning plastic discs and laser diodes you can dispense with that part and keep all the audio as it was - and indeed of course in fact we mostly did. The sound of vinyl is wedded to the physical manifestation, the grooves, the stylus, the rotating disc, but PCM data doesn't care how it is stored.
- ponker 6y agoTrue all this. But still there's a joy in holding a record or photographic slide because there's no inscrutable digital device in between the artifact and its sensory experience. If you have a hard drive of photos you need a device that you can't build, can't see (at the transistor level), and probably can't fully understand to see the photos. And a hard drive of photos looks the same as a hard drive of songs -- the specialist media has a form molded to its content. Can't describe the joy. Just like it.
- boyadjian 6y agoSome people like vinyl sound, because good turntables adds bass and treble, by the mechanical resonance of the arm for the bass, and the electric resonance between the inductance of the cartridge, and the capacitance of the cable between turntable and amplifier for the treble. This used to compensate for poor response curve from loudspeakers. But with good loudspeakers, that have a flat response curve, CD sound is superior. All this vinyl hype is just marketing.
- mtts 6y agoGuy I know owned (owns) a music store. In the late 90s, he thought he knew were things were going. He started saving up for his pension, thinking that by 2015 or so no one would be buying cds anymore. Now, he says, his music store is doing better than ever. He was correct in that no one buys cds anymore, but vinyl is selling like crazy. The store, which has always been popular ever since the 1980s, is making crazy amounts of money and his pension is becoming very comfortable. Only thing he can’t come to terms with, however, is that his younger patrons for some reason insist on buying Dire Straits records. He can’t for the life of him figure out how something that used to be a signifier of having absolutely no taste in music has become so popular with music connoisseurs.
- coldtea 6y agoWell, it was only a "signifier of having absolutely no taste in music has become so popular with music connoisseurs" only to snobs. Similar to how disco and electronic music was supposed to be for people with no taste, and then all those e.g. post-punk groups admitted 15 and 20 years later to liking it all along...
- fuzzfactor 6y agoEdison did come up with a number of things that were intended to stand the test of time. I can imagine guitar connoisseurs find out about Dire Straits after seeing Knopfler on YouTube. He's old enough to be a grandpa now but that's not your grandpa's MTV.
- samplatt 6y agoYour bar is way too high if Dire Straits is the bar for poor taste. Even for the 90's. Mark Knopfler's americana-spirit might be a bit much for some people, but ALL those guys are A-class musicians and they've never done a bad song.
- xioxox 6y agoTwisting by the Pool? :-) I don't dislike any others. I think this poor taste thing seems to occur if something becomes too popular, it becomes poor taste in the eyes of many people, even if that thing is actually good. I'm not convinced anyone can seriously listen to Telegraph Road and say that doesn't have artistic merit. Similarly there is Phil Collins that has a huge background in prog rock and is a top class musician, that is now maligned by many people because he wrote some highly catchy and accessible pop songs.
- anilakar 6y agoAnecdote: I acquired a crowdfunded, limited run LP earlier this year, and it's one of the two audio recordings I've ever bought in physical format during the fifteen years I've managed my personal finance. I already owned the same album in FLAC and only wanted to support the artist. The other one was a CD album that I also owned in a digital format, but which had to exist as a physical copy in order to be eligible for radio playback under the bulk license at that time.
- coldtea 6y agoWell, with psycical formats dwindling to little as a total of sales, it makes sense that the more collectible/nostalgic/hip(ster) one will win over the other that mainly had covenience on its side (and which is now better served by streaming)
- lmedinas 6y agoI think this is really interesting information. As Vinyl has less quality than CDs, uses more space and its way more expensive. But I guess some people like to get the immersion of buying a piece of music and enjoying it in a more vintage way, of course there is nothing wrong with it. On the other hand i find also interesting the discussion between streaming vs physical and what motivates people to go physical when there are less and less motivation to keep people buying physical. I speak even for myself where i hate the idea of paying 10 Euros a month to have all "borrowed" music i want as long as i keep paying it. On the other hand buying 1-2 CDs per month exceeds the 10 Euros budget but at least i own the media, after one year would be more expensive than Apple Music 1y subscription. Difficult to decide which one is more reasonable.
- Xylakant 6y ago> As Vinyl has less quality than CDs, uses more space and its way more expensive. Owning and listening to vinyl is a different experience. Parts of it is show. The modern vinyl pressings often come in a beautiful packaging, nice booklets, something to marvel at. You can look at your shelf and contemplate what you’d like to listen to, in a way that scrolling through a playlist doesn’t. You also pretty much have to listen to the album in the order the artist intended to - no shuffle, no playlists, no skip. CDs to the contrary offer little difference to digital and still use space. So if you’re buying for the physical experience, it makes sense to go for vinyl.
- mytailorisrich 6y ago> So if you’re buying for the physical experience, it makes sense to go for vinyl. I still buy CDs because I want to own a physical medium and CDs are far superior and more practical than vinyls. It's also actually easier to 'contemplate' a shelf of CDs than one of vinyls. ;) I think it is that practicality that actually makes CDs less desirable than vinyls by some. Vinyls are not very practicals and require a ritual to play, and that's what some people are looking for and that is visible in other trends (coffee, tea brewing, etc.). I think that 'less practical' is often seen as 'more authentic'.
- chrisbolt 6y agoPrevious prediction was by the end of 2019, off by a few months Discussion: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=20908197 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=20908197
- sixhobbits 6y agoI'm sad that I clicked on this article and the parent one and neither had a basic line graph showing the trend. It would answer so many questions I have about whether on is trending up etc
- jmull3n 6y agoI'm a DJ that likes pretty underground house and techno. Most of the vinyl I purchase isn't available in any other form, and will tend to be made in a limited quantity. I find that this creates much more memorable performances that make them stand out from others. Vinyl's fun to DJ using turntables but I can't say the same with CD's. They're just inconvenient and I'd rather use an USB that stores more files. I think there's also a pretty big myth around vinyl sounding better, which might contribute to the popularity of it.
- schrijver 6y agoFor me the trend of labels releasing vinyl-only limited edition feels quite elitist, i.e. if you’re somehow not ‘in the know’ than you don’t get to enjoy the music. I prefer labels offering the choice between a limited edition vinyl and an unlimited edition digital download. That way the people that care about owning and spinning the rare object still get that experience and those who discover the record two months later can still buy the digital version and experience it. It happens all the time that I discover music on Bandcamp, and since I’m not a super connoisseur it has been released for some time and the vinyl has long since sold out, but I can buy the digital version and enjoy it and spin it at parties and thus share the experience.
- globular-toast 6y agoBack in the day, it wasn't done due to elitism but rather necessity. Vinyl was the only distribution format for club tracks because of the unique way the DJ can physically manipulate the record for the purposes of beat matching, cutting and scratching. Since a mass production of vinyl incurs a large initial overhead lower quality "white labels" were produced in small numbers for newer releases. Nowadays I'm sure it's just done for marketing purposes, though, as there's no reason not to release the track digitally.
- schrijver 6y ago> Back in the day, it wasn't done due to elitism but rather necessity. For sure. I should have mentioned the current trend, as vinyl-only labels are having something of a resurgence.
- qalmakka 6y agoI think the main reason CDs outpaced vinyl records in sales in the last decades was convenience. CDs are smaller, players are more compact and they can be read and burnt by computers easily and on the cheap. Nowadays you can just connect your phone to your car and stereo using bluetooth, or stream everything everywhere from Spotify or Apple or Youtube, so physical media such as the CD or a record has become more of an experience than a necessity, and I think that taking a record out of its sleeve and playing it is much more satisfying than just popping a CD in; it's a pleasurable experience in itself, and not just a way to play music. I think it's like how riding a horse has become a leisure activity nowadays, because people don't need them as a tool for their daily activities any more.
- dfxm12 6y ago...and as CD burners and players become less ubiquitous, it follows that CD's are becoming less convenient. New cars still have CD players, but not necessarily new computers or home audio players. In the mid 90s, there were at least 5 CD players in the house: 2 stereos, 1 discman, PSX, PC. Now I have 1: PS4.
- antfarm 6y agoI grew up with records and cassettes, but got rid of the few that I still owned about ten years ago. MP3's and streaming were much more convenient and everything was available in an instance. I kept the ~50 CD's as they don't take up much room. Three years ago, I started buying records again, the first being Bitches Brew by Miles Davis. My main interest in music nowadays is in Fusion Jazz, R&B, Funk and Soul Music from the early 1970's. I also got a decent Dual turntable from the 1980's to go with the nostalgic vibe. To me, playing a record is a totally different and more conscious experience than playing a song on Spotify. Even just the necessity to remove the previous record before playing the next one feels archaic in these days where everything is available immediately. Limited availability is similiarly humbling: not owning every record I would like to, but also not even being able to acquire every record I'd like, as some are simply not available or expensive collector's items. Then of course there is the haptic sensation, plus all the information you can get from studying the album cover. My generation's music discovery was full of surprises, when you had a record played for you at the record store that you mainly picked for the weird cover graphics or artist's name. But the most important reason for me to buy records is to one day allow my daughter to discover this strange music from more than half a century ago that was always playing in the house when she was still young. Good luck trying to convince a teenager to have a listen at your Spotify playlist ;)
- agumonkey 6y agoThere's also a paradox in that now that we can have infinite songs anytime anywhere, music seems much less cultural relevant than in the past.
- dusted 6y agoI bought Ladytron's new album, i got FLAC+Cassette.. I have a cassette player in my car, and was looking forward to listening to it there. I was very dissapointed to find the tape of absolutely horrible (by tape!) quality, it sounded so bad I couldn't use it.. Totally a gimmick. I ended up just recording the flac files onto another, blank tape and they sound just fine (by tape standards, actually, by most standards). I hope the new-vinyl is not as gimmicky as new-cassette.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- menybuvico 6y agoThe mastering of the newer generation of metal records is usually done for digital, and they don't really re-master anything for the vinyl release. Most new vinyls sound OK, but in most cases a record released in the late 70's or late 80's will blow a new one straight out of the water. Many, many vinyls come with digital downloads, though. Personally, I like having a physical media to hold on too. I'm almost too old to hear any actual difference anyway. :D
- TheOtherHobbes 6y agoMainstream cassettes have always been duped at 4X or even 8X real speed on industrial copiers, with predictable results. You'll get much better quality from hand-made micro-run solo efforts, but the corporates don't do those.
- mywittyname 6y agoCassettes are kind of a unique creature. Dolby invented a lot of technologies that greatly improved the sound quality of cassette tapes. However, my understanding is that none of these technologies are widely used anymore in the consumer market. So anything you buy made after like 2000, be it cassette or player, will have terrible sound quality unless it's designed for studio use. Is it possible that you used an old, higher-end cassette player to record the blank tape?
- kekebo 6y agoThere is a bit of a sad downside to vinyl: it seems to release toxic chemicals into the air where its being played or even just stored [0]. I hope there are ways to find alternative materials because I thoroughly enjoy the medium overall. [0] https://youtu.be/aZ2czFuIYmQ?t=681 https://youtu.be/aZ2czFuIYmQ?t=681
- matthewfelgate 6y agoAwaits personal anecdote to contradict prevailing trend.
- himinlomax 6y agoBetter title: CDs now sell even less than LPs.
- globular-toast 6y agoNeither title paints the whole picture. Vinyl LP sales have been growing year after year for more than a decade now.
- Tepix 6y agoI've considered buying Vinyl LPs not to listen to them but to hang them on the wall and enjoy the large cover artwork.
- the_other 6y agoI recently made the decision to only buy 2nd hand vinyl (and thus not often), and for all my new music to be digital. Bandcamp, Bleep.com and Beatbport are simply amazing in their own ways. Digital music is easier to carry (I sometimes DJ). I also wonder if digital has a lower environmental burden overall, compared with new vinyl. I've not done any research; in fact, I don't even know how to begin such research. I used to love "albums". I've definitely moved to playing more singles. Partly through DJing again, partly through the convenience of Spotify... but I think mostly because there's so much new music that if I'm listening to an album and don't enjoy half of it, that's time I could have used finding the good singles from another album. I don't claim this is a good practice, only that it's a novel perspective I've gained recently and offer it up for inspection.
- sjm 6y agoFor me it's vinyl for the albums I _really love_, and digital/streaming for anything else. I understand buying digital ultimately supports the artists more, but as a library/collection, digital files just can't compare to LPs or even CDs.
- 52-6F-62 6y agoI do the same. And most new LPs come with digital downloads anyway. These days I have kept my existing album downloads but I sub to Apple Music so I can grab almost anything on the fly, download it so I’m not constantly streaming (I listen to whole albums, not shuffles or playlists really) and listen to that often at work or on the move but buy LPs for everything else. It can just be an expensive hobby so it’s usually pretty filtered. Also used LP shopping is just a hell of a lot of fun. Seeing how much good stuff you can find for what it would cost for a new copy elsewhere.
- crispyambulance 6y agoIt's not too shocking. To be fair, CD's, Vinyl and Cassette are all legacy media at this point. A real shocker would be a decline of streaming in favor of Vinyl/CD. That ain't ever gonna happen. Welcome to the future.
- bob1029 6y agoI wouldn't be so sure about all of this. I just bought a copy of the You Only Live Twice soundtrack in physical CD format because my streaming provider (Spotify) only offers 3 tracks from the album. Repeat this story for anything not created in the last 20 years. The realization that I could permanently lose access to some older media just by way of my streaming providers not caring to continue carrying the tracks has reignited my datahoarder spirit animal. For some reason the thought of losing access to movies and TV shows is substantially less troubling to me than the thought of losing access to more obscure forms of music.
- grilledcheez 6y agoI think it is worth pointing out that the figures are from the US only. I wonder how this compares to the rest of the world.
- thrownaway954 6y agoit's great that it's selling more than cds, but that's like being the best in the losers bracket. i don't know a single person in my life who actually buys vinyl records. everyone i know has a spotify or panadora account.
- Balgair 6y agoOne thing I've noticed is that the quality of vinyl presses for recent songs is not good. It seems worse with colored records like pinks and reds and the like. I had to return an album three times to get a record that wouldn't skip all over!
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- sli 6y agoThis doesn't really surprise me. Between music streaming, cars more commonly having extra inputs (AUX, USB, Bluetooth), the market for CDs is probably shrinking while vinyl appeals to the same enthusiasts year after year.
- glitcher 6y ago> The supremacy of vinyl over CDs is the result of several factors. And then goes on to cover none of those factors. I like the topic and am interested in more info, but this tiny article is written very poorly. I would love to read a deep dive on the pros and cons of the two, especially about how each medium holds up over the long term. Isn't vinyl much better for archival purposes because cd's can start to disintegrate over time? Or have manufacturing processes improved?
- brundolf 6y agoSpeaking anecdotally: people I know who buy vinyl tend to do it for the novelty/because they're audiophiles. These are the kind of people who buy/build fancy sound systems specifically for listening to music. They usually get a vinyl record player to go with it. Whereas CDs are stuck in this awkward middle-ground: they're not as evocative/interesting as records for the enthusiast, but they're not as convenient as streaming or even MP3's for the casual listener. Personally I still buy a CD on occasion when I want to actually own an album, because it's a high-quality source that's easy to get onto a computer. But there aren't a ton of usecases for doing so these days.
- chrisseaton 6y ago> because it's a high-quality source I wonder - does anyone produce and distribute streaming audio at a higher quality than CD? A lot of people talk like CD audio is a definitive source, but I mean it's still a limited sampling rate and a limited bit-depth.
- thatcat 6y agoThe full bit-depth is present on the audio cd. You can buy 24-bit 196 hz flac from tidal as a download or you can rip it from a cd.
- chrisseaton 6y ago> The full bit-depth is present on the audio cd. You can buy 24-bit 196 hz flac from tidal as a download or you can rip it from a cd. Well this is exactly what I mean... what do you mean by 'full' bit-depth? It's finite. It's 16-bit on a CD. It could be higher. If you rip 24-bit audio from a 16-bit CD... you don't actually get any more data, do you? What would be the point in doing that? I'm asking - does anyone sell audio mastered and distributed at 24-bit? Or 32-bit? Better than CD quality. According to the comments here 'yes' so it clearly isn't 'full'.
- OldHand2018 6y agoI remember reading a story about some folks setting up a manufacturing/pressing shop a year or two ago. From what I remember, pressing vinyl has a high error rate/low yield and that newer equipment improves upon this, driving down the costs significantly. You can probably assume that people are setting these up in most every mid-sized or larger city, possibly even some small ones as well. So it's likely that with a mature supply chain and a distributed manufacturing base, vinyl will be able to have a wider variety of music and low prices (even more so than now). I doubt that CD manufacturing facilities are seeing any expansion at all; probably still consolidating and controlled only by the large labels.
- taylodl 6y agoI don't buy CDs any longer, I certainly don't buy LPs (the last time I bought an LP was in the early 90's), and I don't stream. I do buy a lot of music on iTunes. I've stopped buying select songs too, preferring to buy albums. You get to know the artist and their work better. When listening to music I tend to listen to albums. For better or for worse my iPhone is now my sole music player. The audio engineers mastering for iTunes are doing an excellent job.