4 ms·
The personal income tax rate in CO is 4.63%, and in CA it tops out over 13%. The executives who are going to be selling stock in the next couple years will save
by gnicholas 6y ago
The personal income tax rate in CO is 4.63%, and in CA it tops out over 13%. The executives who are going to be selling stock in the next couple years will save nearly 10% in taxes if they relocate to CO.
The CA FTB will likely go after some of them, on the grounds that they "earned" the stock/options while living in CA. In my prior life as a tax lawyer, I saw the FTB get beaten on this, but they probably still pursue the cases because there's so much money at stake.
- codezero 6y agoI know someone who knows someone who had a big exit recently and he said he moved and because of the tax situation, he's unlikely to even visit California for a few years, is there anything about the law that protects someone if they never return to the state, or is that bs? Good chance they don't want to come back for other reasons I guess!
- gnicholas 6y agoIt wouldn't matter if he came back to visit. It's more important that he change his driver's license, voter registration, move his family, bring his pets, not own real estate here, etc. The state's theory (that I recall) doesn't relate to future visits to CA — it's all about what happened in the past. BTW, I'm happy to make a referral to anyone who ends up targeted by the FTB on this issue. My former colleague, who is still a tax lawyer, nailed the FTB in court when they went after one of his clients on this.
- codezero 6y agoThanks for the answer, and the referral offer - I doubt my SV lottery tickets will ever win, and I'm staying in CA anyways, but maybe a friend might need help one day.
- nostrademons 6y ago"Residency" is based on what fraction of your time you spend in the state. It's easier to make a case that you're not a resident if you can say "Wait a minute, I haven't even set foot in the state of California in the last 2 years!" It's not that it's a hard & fast rule or loophole, it's that the law is one of those things that includes some discretion & wiggle-room, and you're less likely to be on the wrong side of the FTB & court's interpretation of it if there are facts you can point to that clearly suggest "not a resident".
- codezero 6y agoAh that makes sense, sounds like it's just a cover your ass element, especially if you accidentally left some other loose end about.
- seiferteric 6y agoThere may be a 10 year retroactive wealth tax coming soon and that is sure to scare a lot of wealthy people away.
- brobinson 6y agoIt's important to have a _very_ clean severing of ties with CA: https://www.ftb.ca.gov/forms/2018/18_1031.pdf https://www.ftb.ca.gov/forms/2018/18_1031.pdf
- malandrew 6y agoCan you provide details on what legal arguments were used to beat the CA FTB?
- gnicholas 6y agoIt's been a while, and I was never a state tax guy (fed/intl for me). I imagine the theory is based on how states divvy up income between them. Imagine you move from CA to CO, and in 2021 you live entirely in CO. Well, CO is going to say anything you earned during 2021 is fully theirs to tax. So if you sell $10M of stock, they'll want their 4%. But if CA says they want 13% of your $10M, on the grounds that you "earned" it while living in CA, then that's not fair to you.
- joshuamorton 6y agoWhy isn't it fair to you? Usually the laws are such that you pay the max, not the sum, of the two state taxes.
- gnicholas 6y agoWell in theory you'd pay the max of two states that you legitimately owe taxes to. But if one state that you should not owe taxes to decides to assess you, the other state (CO in my example) would not just roll over and give up their revenue. So instead you get handed two separate tax bills (and post 2018, you can't deduct more than $10k in SALT, making this hurt even more).
- joshuamorton 6y agoI think one of us is misunderstanding something. If CA and CO both claim you owe them money, you pay the value to CO, and then you only owe the difference to CA, so the most state tax you pay is 13%. CO gets 4% and CA gets 13-4%=9%. I've filed my taxes split between CA and another state before and that's what you do. If CA comes after you for not filing taxes, you may owe fines, but you can still deduct other state tax when filing CA state taxes. SALT isn't relevant. Like to give an example, if I found a startup in SV, and run it their for 5 years, move to Denver and go public and cash in my options as a CO resident, I'd argue that most of that money was earned while in CA. California enforcing that doesn't seem unfair as long as they treat it the same as any other income (allow you to deduct other state tax)