4 ms·
This is arguing that Docker is "harmful" because the components it builds on existed before. That makes no sense at all. Only when I got to the 5th section did
by remram 6y ago
This is arguing that Docker is "harmful" because the components it builds on existed before. That makes no sense at all.
Only when I got to the 5th section did it make some sort of argument, which ended up being about Docker not using an init system to manage daemons, and the usual problem this brings to badly-written images (process reaping). Ignoring the fact that plenty of daemon managers exist, and are used both with and without Docker, like supervisord.
- jmnicolas 6y agoThe way I see it, Docker adds complexity. The more your systems are complex the more brittle they are.
- jcelerier 6y agowho cares when it saves days by the dozens. Even if docker burned all the hard drive in my home right now for some reason, the amount of time gained when I get an user reporting a bug on $OLD_UBUNTU where I can just run `docker run -it ubuntu:14.04` and start reproducing in a couple seconds, that would still be worth it.
- rmetzler 6y agoI somehow broke ruby on my Mac so I can’t use cursor keys in irb. No big problem, just do a quick docker run -it —-rm ruby and I can try some code in the repl. Yes, I‘m sure I could fix it somehow, but I didn’t have time for it today, I just needed to get this short script working.
- TurningCanadian 6y agoLike with any layer of abstraction, you can't mention the complexity it adds without also mentioning the complexity it removes. It has encouraged people to move to a more immutable architecture, which makes many types of common problems easier to solve.
- remram 6y agoAdding complexity you don't need is a bad thing, but the alternative presented is what exactly? Build packages of my software for each distribution my customers use, and tell them to write custom scripts that will bootstrap chroots on each production machine, install the software in there with the distro's package manager, then set up systemd unit files that will run those with systemd-nspawn?
- Joker_vD 6y agoGoodness gracious, again with those "zombie processes"... I think one of the biggest UNIX design flaws is the PID management (the most appalling part is the need for PID 1 to constantly be reaping the orphaned children). Why does no other OS need such a silly contraption? Why file descriptors don't need such treatment? Oh, right, because they're per-process, not system-wide.