5 ms·
Civ4 was highly flawed IMO, because the tactics revolved around setting up giant "death stacks". There were a few units that could attack a whole stack, but ~2
by dragontamer 6y ago
Civ4 was highly flawed IMO, because the tactics revolved around setting up giant "death stacks".
There were a few units that could attack a whole stack, but ~20 musketeers in the midgame was practically impossible to defend against aside from having your own stack of ~20 musketeers.
Civ3 and Civ2 had the right idea: Kill-stack the entire stack if you group your units together like that. There was much richer play of combat in Civ3 and Civ2. It was non-intuitive, and players complained grossly about kill-stacks... but lets be frank: the game was better with kill-stacks.
----
Between Lenard Nemoy as the narrator and the incredible music, I'd think 4 was the best production value of the entire series however. Civ6 comes in at 2nd place, pretty good music and Sean Bean is pretty decent too. Just not as good as Civ4 IMO.
-------
Civ6's issues is the "flattening" of the entire tree. Nothing feels different until you reach airplanes. Riflemen are just reskinned Musketeers, who are reskinned Swordmen, who are just reskinned Warriors.
Tanks are just reskinned Knights, who were reskinned Chariots.
In Civ6, there are basically only the following units: Anti-city Siege (Catapult / Bombard / Artillery), Warriors (Warrior, Swordmen, Musketeer, Riflemen, Mech. Infantry), Heavy Cavalry (Chariot, Knights, Tanks), Light Cavalry (Horsemen, Cavalry, Helicopters), and ranged-units (Slinger, Archer, Crossbowman, Field Cannon).
Eventually, airplanes take over the siege and ranged roles (Biplane / Fighters ultimately play like faster Archers, while Bombers play like better Catapults). But otherwise, there's not much difference to combat through the ages.
-------
Furthermore, Civ6 doesn't allow any exponential growth strategies. Aka: Wide vs Tall, or whatnot. In previous games (Civ1 through 5), buildings provided multiplicative bonuses.
So Library was +100% science for the city (or some other multiplier, depending on which version of the game). This means that Libraries had a "threshold", where they were useless for small cities (+100% science on 1-Sci base production is just +1 science), but powerful for large cities (+100% off of a city with 20 science is +20 science).
But there's none of that "play" in Civ6. Its wide-wide-wide for the win. Sure, Civ6 has increasing costs for settlers / builders to try and make the "wide" strategy weaker... but that just slows down the player. It doesn't actually change the fact that wide is the only way to play.
-------
Builders only can make 3-improvements before they disappear (unless you have Feudalism or Pyramids: increaasing the limit by +2 or +1).
In contrast, Civ3 through Civ5 had Workers (and Civ1 / Civ2 had settlers) that can continuously upgrade your city throughout all the ages. Workers vs Military was a key balance throughout the game.
While in Civ6, its basically "Builders until they become too expensive", and maybe "Play Feudalism Card every now and then to cheat some extra improvements out of your builders". There's no depth to the decision.
- ardit33 6y agoYou seem to crap on all of them. Not sure they are major problems of the game, or nitpicking. Which one is good/worth to play for a novice?
- dragontamer 6y agoStrangely enough, I like FreeCiv the most. Its mostly based on Civ2, but it takes a few nice features like boarders from the later games. There's a huge degree of customization. The main issue of FreeCiv is that its an open source game with poor music / graphics compared to Civ6. --------- Civ6 is the best graphically by far. Its available on a wide variety of platforms. Arguably, the simplified combat system is better for a beginner (but for me, I just get bored with it a lot faster). I guess Civ6 might be best for a beginner: the modern community is on Civ6, its got the music and graphics you'd expect from a AAA-game. But as far as actually thinking about strategy, build orders, and competitive play? I think FreeCiv (Civ2) is the deeper game by all measures.
- mr-ron 6y agoThat poster is definitely nitpicking. Ive seen most people point to V as the goto for novices. Its cheap, super engaging like all Civs are, and misses a lot of of the nitpicky flaws that are prevalent in VI
- iso1631 6y ago> It doesn't actually change the fact that wide is the only way to play. You can win civ6 without even settling a city.
- dragontamer 6y agoComputer players in Civ6 are... pretty poor opponents. While Prince CPUs start on even grounds (1-warrior / 1 settler start, no combat bonuses), but are incredibly poor at making decisions. CPUs fail to take terrain into account, they are pretty bad about aiming at weak units (settlers / builders), and they send their units into the slaughterhouse one-by-one instead of waiting for a tactical edge. Case in point: I've played multiple games where Prince-CPUs are hemmed in by barbarians and unable to expand for 100-turns, leading to a no-effort win from me. In contrast, Diety CPUs are "fake difficulty". Their tactics are identical to the low-quality Prince CPUs, but instead have a 5-warrior/3-settler start, a solid +4 strength (aka +15% damage) bonus applied to all units unconditionally, and +100% culture/science throughout the game. Needless to say, Deity level CPUs are the epitome of "fake difficulty" in Civ6. Its incredibly poor tactics wrapped up with just stupid amounts of bonuses over the human player. I'm honestly not very impressed. At least they don't get barbarian-rushed into nothingness. --------- Anyway, I find it unlikely that you'd be able to play "city free" vs a human player. The CPU players seem "exploitable", they have holes in their gameplans (even at the Diety level) that don't really feel strategic to me. I can believe you that you can beat CPUs "city free", but I don't really consider such a game to be an accomplishment due to the weak AI of Civ6.