3 ms·
Your immune system evolved in an environment where it has stuff to do constantly, when it doesn’t have stuff to do it gets bored and finds stuff to do... from t
by colechristensen 6y ago
Your immune system evolved in an environment where it has stuff to do constantly, when it doesn’t have stuff to do it gets bored and finds stuff to do... from the mild inconvenience of allergies to deadly autoimmune diseases.
And when it comes down to it, government doesn’t have the authority to tell you what to wear in public, inside a business during a pandemic probably, but regularly? You’re going to find some real solid constitutional objections that are better off not tested.
- maxerickson 6y agoWe literally make people wear clothes. Especially women.
- whateveracct 6y agoSeriously how can someone think that mask requirements cannot be legal given this precedent haha
- colechristensen 6y agoBecause covering your junk is based on judeo-christian morals which are reflected in our law in ways that certain “obscene” things have historically fallen outside of free expression rights... those are going away and you won’t successfully argue that not wearing a mask is obscene.
- pmoriarty 6y agoNo one actually causes the death of someone else by not covering up an "obscene" part of their body. And, as in the case of Typhoid Mary, people have been deprived of their liberty for being a threat to public health. So I wouldn't be too sure about the courts siding with the anti-maskers.
- colechristensen 6y agoYes, quarantine has been successfully defended on individuals, small groups, or specific areas. “Quarantine” on whole populations has not and would not be. It has nothing to do with being anti-mask, your government just doesn’t have the power to force everyone to wear masks for half the year because somebody thinks it’sa good idea to prevent their kids from getting minor infections.
- pmoriarty 6y agoThe direct effect of COVID-19 on kids is not the issue, but the fact that they can spread it to vulnerable adults, including their teachers, parents, and grandparents, and whoever they infect could infect even more. This has and will continue to cause lots of older people to die, even if the kids themselves remain mostly unharmed. As for the government's power, see what they did in WW2. They had major propaganda campaigns to get everyone on board (like "Loose Lips Sink Ships", Presidential "fireside chat" addresses, and propaganda posters everywhere, etc), a united and determined Congress, and actual leadership that helped the entire nation become aware and engaged with the war effort. If there was this kind of leadership, media effort, and peer-pressure today as there was during WW2, along with laws and actual enforcement against non-compliant anti-maskers, then you can believe there'd be a hell of a lot less anti-maskers even trying to get out of wearing a mask, never mind staging mass anti-mask protests (with Presidential encouragement!). The political bickering, selfishness, and incompetency in the US has already resulted in literally hundreds of thousands of unnecessary deaths, and will probably cause hundreds of thousands if not millions more.
- LargoLasskhyfv 6y agoWhile I'm not against mandatory wearing of masks while in public(when necessary), I feel they should have been distributed by emergency services, or placed on pallets in supermarkets, at gas stations, like it happened with telephone books and yellow pages in the past. Same goes for disinfectant. Why should I have to pay overblown prices for that stuff?
- vkou 6y ago
- colechristensen 6y agoWe make people cover certain small parts of their bodies which were historically found “obscene” to expose which circumvents the free expression right and those requirements don’t exist in many places and are generally eroding. You can’t make the same argument about masks. Even now nowhere is it actually required to wear a mask in public. Go read an order, they’re all written in ways that say “you must” but carve out exceptions which make them impossible to enforce if they were backed by enforcement at all. This isn’t true inside commercial establishments but only in public. If tested in court they would all fall flat that dont rely specifically on the government power to regulate commerce.
- maxerickson 6y agoI suppose my heckling comes down to being skeptical that you are as adamant about shouting down nipple restrictions.
- colechristensen 6y agoNot to be crass but young men leading the charge on the free the nipple campaigns seems counter productive... I’ll leave that filed under causes I support but will leave the fighting to those with skin in the game.
- basch 6y agomillions of years of evolution wasnt expecting densely populated metros and near instantaneous world travel. the speed with which we can traverse the world in the last 100 years, at scale, changes everything.
- colechristensen 6y agoDense cities with no sanitation and global travel existed thousands of years ago, epidemics were frequent and easily actually much worse from a spreading potential, i don’t think the fact that a disease took six months to span continents instead of days or weeks really does change much in a significant way. Evidence of epidemic diseases exist just as long as evidence of human civilization. People are over rating the current situation compared to historical contexts. It is not that it is not bad, it simply might just be the new normal. Or to put it other way, humans might have experienced a brief holiday in low disease risk which is over.