3 ms·
The timeline is that the merger approval happened and sometime after that, the new principles were published. If we assume positive intent, someone at DOJ was
by toast0 6y ago
The timeline is that the merger approval happened and sometime after that, the new principles were published.
If we assume positive intent, someone at DOJ was tired of approvals like the T-Mobile deal, and was able to (somehow) build concensus to an announcement of new principles. These newly announced principles are quite a bit different than the old ones, so we shouldn't be surprised that old deals don't align, that's kind of the point.
It's also not too surprising that an old deal finalized a few months before the new principles finalized. Everything is on a long pipeline, and it gets done when it's done, changing principles in the middle is hard --- especially when the new ones are unpublished and you had already done significant work under the old ones.
- baryphonic 6y agoNot to mention, imagine the legal headache for the DOJ to stop a merger on as-yet unpublished principles. "Arbitrary & capricious" and various violations of rules like the Administrative Procedures Act would be thrown out in court. It's a little sketchy as is that the DOJ can change its criteria without any decision in Congress, but at least this is closer to following the contours of the law as is rather than arbitrary decision-making.
- quantified 6y agoIt’s a very charitable assumption. New principles were not necessary to block.