4 ms·
I think that tools like Emacs and Vim are aimed at people who recognize that very often over the next few decades of their careers they are going to have a need
by tzs 6y ago
I think that tools like Emacs and Vim are aimed at people who recognize that very often over the next few decades of their careers they are going to have a need for powerful, complex, flexible text editing, and so even if they have no interest in learning the software for its own sake its worth putting in the up front effort because it will pay off later.
For a lot of tools, both in software and other fields, there are three different classes of user.
1. Those with fairly straightforward tasks that they just want to get done.
2. Those who mostly have staightforward tasks, but occasionally have something a bit more complex but not too complex.
3. Those that need to handle everything from simple to ridiculously complicated.
Take electrical testing tools for example. For a lot of people a simple battery tester is all they need (class #1). If you want to test a battery and have never used a battery tester before, it will either be obvious what to do, or a glance at the instructions will tell you.
Some people need a bit more on occasion, and for them we have a class #2 tool, the multimeter [1]. You can still pretty easily test a battery with one, but the first time you probably will have to spend a minute or two in the manual, learning what voltage setting you want (the V with the ~ over it, or the V with the dashed and non-dashed line over it?) and which holes to plug the probes into.
Some people need a lot more. They have a class #3 tool, the oscilloscope [2]. You can check a battery with an oscilloscope, but if it is your first time you are going to spend a lot of time in the manual before you get there.
Emacs and Vim are class #3 tools.
[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Multimeter#/media/File:Fluke87-V_Multimeter.jpg https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Multimeter#/media/File:Fluke87...
[2] https://www.tequipment.net/Rigol/MSO1104Z-KIT/Mixed-Signal-Oscilloscopes-(MSO)/?v=7403 https://www.tequipment.net/Rigol/MSO1104Z-KIT/Mixed-Signal-O...
- oblio 6y agoThe thing is, you need AutoCAD (or equivalent) to be a productive engineer in certain fields. You don't need Emacs or Vim to be an incredibly successful software engineer. It's actually the opposite, Emacs and Vim users are a minority among successful software engineers. So they are only a specific kind of power tool. More than that, they can't even handle the "ridiculously complicated". Common examples are trying to use them with projects containing millions of lines of Java or C# code.
- tzs 6y agoYes, you don't need Emacs or Vim to be a successful software engineer. If you are good enough you don't need anything more than a basic editor, a compiler/interpreter for a language, and libraries for that language that let it talk to whatever you need to do I/O with. But using a more advanced editor can make it easier. If you are going to be doing software engineering for a few decades all the times you have to do some repetitive task in a simple editor that would have been quicker in a more powerful editor adds up.
- oblio 6y agoYou've misunderstood me. I'm not arguing that Notepad + msc.exe are more powerful than Emacs or Vim. I'm arguing that IntelliJ/Visual Studio are more powerful than Emacs or Vim. The Emacs and Vim architectures are antiquated and the volume of effort put into developing them (and their ecosystems) are outclassed by modern IDEs, especially for languages that scale to large numbers of developers working together (Java, C#). Emacs and Vim are poor man's IDEs compared to actual IDEs for these cases. Emacs and Vim are mostly popular amongst C/C++ developers, where the ecosystems are generally baroque, forced by the need to integrate with embedded systems with limited toolchains or with libraries/frameworks that are very limited, and amongst developers working with dynamic languages, where you generally have small teams. Or large teams and a ton of headaches :-)
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- MarcScott 6y agoI'm not a C/C++ developer, but I spend most of my time in Emacs. Most of my development time is spent in Python, and Emacs serves as an excellent IDE for the language. However, that in itself is not my reason for preferring Emacs. It's also my markdown editor, often my file manager, my PDF viewer, my image viewer, my git interface, IRC client, email client... I could go on, but I'll stop there. Emacs is not and has never been an IDE, it's a highly versatile and extensible text-editor. You can't compare apples and oranges.
- 6y ago