3 ms·
My takeaway: in-person leadership is a charisma game where somebody fools everyone into letting them be boss. Perhaps to the detriment of the project and goals
by JoeAltmaier 6y ago
My takeaway: in-person leadership is a charisma game where somebody fools everyone into letting them be boss. Perhaps to the detriment of the project and goals.
Virtual leadership is based on performance and productivity. It related directly to achieving goals.
Another big win for virtual work? It factors pointless, harmful charisma out of the equation?
- jordache 6y ago100% wrong and no doubt myopic to your own personal and likely limited experiences. a venn diagram of good leader qualities and charismatic qualities has non-trivial overlap. A leader lacking people skills has a very limited ceiling in what he/she can affect.
- JoeAltmaier 6y agoExplain the OP then? Almost a perfect experiment in removing charisma from the work equation - everybody works remotely and communicates through a limited channel. And things get better. And perhaps delve into 'charismatic' as it relates to loud, aggressive or overbearing.
- jordache 6y agoone can convey charisma through digital/remote channels. Just because the physical connection is gone, it does not mean a robotic / formulaic approach is now the only way to lead/manage humans
- JoeAltmaier 6y agoIt reduces the effect. It becomes possible to squelch the loudmouth, take turns talking, hear from everyone. It removes physical intimidation and most body language. Nobody is suggesting 'robotic' or 'formulaic'.
- xauronx 6y agoIn my experience the "loudmouth" in-person is the same way on a video call. They always get their two cents in, and are sure to jump in regardless of whether or not another person is patiently waiting their turn.
- nblayer 6y agoWhere do these Venn diagrams come from? Some glossy Gartner Group business quadrant presentation? Charisma does one thing: Make other people work for you and let you steal their output and take credit for their successes. The leaders of the successful Asian tech nations don't seem that charismatic, but rather competent and intelligent. The West should take note.
- jordache 6y agorational intuition of what motivates people - You complement the meats of motivation (pay, meaningful work) with a leader that possess strong people skills, charisma, and you have the conditions for a potential best case scenario outcome.
- bstaunton 6y agoAlso the potential for the worst case scenario, as many charismatic dictators show. And in two companies I worked at, the minute a charismatic, clueless bureaucrat swaggered in, took over the orgs and started barking orders (in a polite and charismatic fuck-you way), all top developers left, as if by magic.
- JoeAltmaier 6y agoLets be honest: how many horror stories do we all have, about in-person leaders that were selected because they were the loudest, or most aggressive, or talked over everybody else, or sucked up to the big boss? Does that happen 10% of the time? 30%? 60%? If virtual work reduces that effect, its all to the benefit of the workers and the work, in my view. It seems a slam-dunk.