3 ms·
When I visited Pompei and Herculaneum my first thought is I couldn't help but to think how stupid humans are for rebuilding those towns in exactly the same plac
by dheera 6y ago
When I visited Pompei and Herculaneum my first thought is I couldn't help but to think how stupid humans are for rebuilding those towns in exactly the same place, and even closer to the volcano than the ancient destroyed towns.
Farms, I get it -- fertile soil -- but why cities? Did people not learn from the historical records of their time, to draw lines around the boundaries of destruction and not build again within those lines?
- taneq 6y agoI feel a bit the same about other similar hazards. Cities built on flood plains that regularly get washed away. Cities built on volcanic hotspots with regular serious earthquakes. Cities, as you say, in the shadow of active volcanoes. But people always seem to think "it won't happen again."
- dheera 6y agoAlso reminds me of this thing I saw in satellite maps near Mt. Shasta. Train track cutting right through a lava flow, and a highway (that might serve as a valuable escape route) cutting right next to it. Seriously? Are humans that stupid? The very FIRST thing I see when I look at this satellite map is "oh shit lava how about we stay the hell away from it" https://i.imgur.com/U6y0Q4O.jpg https://i.imgur.com/U6y0Q4O.jpg
- PopeDotNinja 6y agoThe airport in Kona on Hawaii is built on a lava flow from Hualalai’s last major eruption about 200 years ago. Hualalai is still considered an active volcano, too. Maybe they’ve got a force field they haven’t told anyone about.
- lol2143651 6y agoHawaii's volcano is a shield volcano. It doesn't suddenly explode into a pyroclastic flow. You have very different concerns.
- kaybe 6y agoHawaii has fairly liquid lava, which means that the dissolved gas can escape safely and not build up pressure for a big sudden explosion. Accordingly, while the airport may not be safe, the people should be since they can move away from any incoming lava in time. The volcanoes with more viscous lava (such as Vesuvius) are much more dangerous in comparison.
- PopeDotNinja 6y agoInteresting, thanks for the info.
- thrusong 6y agoI live in the Canadian city of Winnipeg which is built upon the intersection of two large rivers and their flood plains. We have the Red River Floodway (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Red_River_Floodway https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Red_River_Floodway) which has been quite successful, however, we're getting more floodwater every year and now we sometimes face severe flooding on the Assiniboine River. This all used to be at the bottom of a giant lake and probably will go back to that at some point, but we've done a pretty good job at preventing billions in losses.
- musikele 6y agoHi there, I live around 30 km from Pompeii and I'm in a "safe zone". I'm only expected to receive some ashes in case of eruption (if the eruption is like the one of 1600, that is more probable but less strong than the one of 79BC). After a few years after the eruption, nobody knew the exact location of Pompeii and Ercolanum, and also for quite some time these two areas were unhabitated and used only for farming. The emperor at the time of the eruption, Tito, tried to rebuild the cities but nobody wanted to live there anymore. They only found out that Pompeii was there around 1500-1600. The repopulation of the area has happened during the last century, mainly because Italy was, after the second world war, in an economic boom and people built houses (and factories) without any permit. Politics was usually corrupted or "closed their eyes" for votes. And here we are. At the point we are now, it is impossible to relocate this huge amount of people (around 2M) anywhere. The evacuation plan itself is a joke, due to the nature of the eruptions of a stratovolcano. So, let's hope for the best, as there's nothing we can do to prepare for the worse.
- arethuza 6y agoAren't there multiple volcanoes in that area? I thought the biggest risk at the moment was supposed to be the Phlegraean Fields rather than Vesuvius https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Phlegraean_Fields https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Phlegraean_Fields
- musikele 6y agoVesuvius is the most problematic because in the past it showed a 25 years cycle between eruptions, but the eruption of ~1975 was missed (last was in 1944 and lava capped the eruptive canal). Anyway, this Vulcanic area is the most populated in the world and evacuating will be a mess. Every time I hyke to the Vesuvius top, guides explain that there are other active vulcanos in the area; they are all considered active and may harm at any moment. The Phlegraean Fields are problematic because they generate a lot of bradyseism (and in some places the ground went underwater for about 10 meters!), but for now they are considered quiescent. Ischia island also is a volcano, that has erupted last time around 700 BC. Finally, there's an underwater volcano called Marsilii, that can generate a tsunami. All these volcanos are stricly monitored.
- throwawaysea 6y agoThe same can (and should) be asked of American cities that regularly get destroyed by hurricanes or floods.