16 ms·
Portland adopts landmark facial recognition ordinances
- hirundo 6y ago"What makes Portland's legislation stand out from other cities is that we're prohibiting facial recognition technology use by private entities in public accommodations," Prohibition is too strict. Better would be to allow opt in, so that my hotel, gym, uber, pizza parlor, etc., could recognize me and customize their service accordingly if I consent.
- kstrauser 6y agoAs a practical matter, how could opt in work? Suppose you've opted in and I haven't. We both walk into the pizza parlor. How does the system know that you've opted in without attempting to recognize both of us?
- hirundo 6y agoFailing to recognize someone does not detract from their privacy. If they fail to recognize everyone who isn't opted in, who is harmed?
- farisjarrah 6y agoThe problem with this argument is the assumption that everyone gets a facial scan and the computer processes the data all the same, in order to recognize whether the individual is recognizable or not. How can we be sure that that data is not getting saved for later? The system is too ripe for abuse and everyone loses their privacy.
- Pfhreak 6y agoSure it does. Failing to recognize someone at scale can very much impact someone's privacy. Holes in data are, in and of themselves information. For example, if an unrecognized face was logged on 47th street, then an unrecognized face was logged on 50th, then 52nd, then 55th (where a crime occurred), then back down to 47th, you might be able to draw some patterns about where to look for your suspect even if they hadn't opted in. Edit: Also, you are trusting that the system isn't storing markers for people it doesn't recognize. My concern would be that if I opt in later, suddenly all my past history becomes discoverable. That's a lot of trust to put in the hands of private firms (or the police), neither of which I'm comfortable holding that information.
- kortex 6y agoExcellently put. Also, just because it didn't generate a facial ID hit, doesn't mean they can't use ReID and track the descriptor vector. In fact if I were a not-quite ethical user of facerec, I'd flag and bin all vectors and image chips that failed to ID. I work on facerec and ReID. But it's for deep fake detection and the like, blue team stuff. But the deep ID technologies are very concerning to me in general.
- pc86 6y agoHonestly this is a really, really good point I hadn't thought of (and well articulated) and I think you've changed my mind on prohibition v. opt-in.
- stbtrax 6y agoIt will try to recognize you but you will not be in the database, so it will say match not found. Presumably nothing would be stored about you in that interaction
- TooCleverByHalf 6y ago> Presumably nothing would be stored about you in that interaction Given how prevalent the tracking of users is, anonymous or otherwise, I'd be extremely pessimistic about this assumption.
- kstrauser 6y agoSame here. I don't want the system to even try to recognize me. No one's doing this stuff on site, which means that they'd be uploading my face to a cloud provider and using their system, which means they'd be doing the things people are having a problem with in the first place.
- markovbot 6y agoAnd no one would ever lie about such things for a profit.
- thrwn_frthr_awy 6y agoAre there logs?
- tkzed49 6y agoI'm suspicious having seen how the GDPR is effectively being circumvented by making nonessential cookies more or less opt-out, and by making the process so annoying that the average person doesn't care enough to do it. It's a lot easier to enforce "not allowed" than "do it in a user-friendly way". Plus, in a public place, how do you only apply facial recognition technology to a single person? It seems like in most cases, you must first apply it to everyone else nearby to discriminate them from anyone who opted in.
- MereInterest 6y agoThe GDPR isn't being circumvented in those cases. It is being blatantly and flagrantly violated. The GDPR explicitly requires that refusal to be tracked have no more friction than accepting being tracked. If the banner has a "Accept and Continue" button, then it must have a "Refuse and Continue" button as well. Adding any more steps than that is a violation, not merely a circumvention.
- lbotos 6y agoI may be naive and misunderstanding, but if a private entity is using facial recognition on their property, that doesn't appear to be prohibited? Like if a gym wanted to do a face scan to "log you in" that seems like that'd be permissible? I'm not a lawyer. I found the actual draft: D.“Places of Public Accommodation” 1.means: Any place or service offering to the public accommodations, advantages, facilities, or privileges whether in the nature of goods, services, lodgings, amusements, transportation or otherwise. 2.does not include: An institution, bona fide club, private residence, or place of accommodation that is in its nature distinctly private. https://static1.squarespace.com/static/5967c18bff7c50a0244ff42c/t/5f3ad787ba3fd27776e444af/1597691785249/Ordinance+to+ban+use+of+FRT+in+Places+of+Public+Accommodation+plus+code+amendment+-Final.pdf https://static1.squarespace.com/static/5967c18bff7c50a0244ff...
- kstrauser 6y agoIANAL, but I think "distinctly private" here means your house, or the private clubhouse you rent with some friends, etc. In other words, places that the general public isn't welcome to visit (as opposed to even a gym where anyone with $100 can sign up).
- fiter 6y agoA private country club would certainly fall under this exemption, but a normal gym might not unless it's already qualifying for the private club tax exemption.
- Reelin 6y agoApproximately, a business that's open to the public is considered to be a public space, even if it's on private property. A restaurant dining room is public, but the kitchen would be private (IIUC). A private club (ie you register for membership and only members are allowed inside) is private. (Aside: That's how indoor smoking establishments like hookah bars get around anti-smoking laws in Washington state.) This leaves me uncertain about gyms - that seems more like a country club than a restaurant or hotel?
- lwneal 6y agoA problem with opt-in data collection is that whenever the law allows a user to opt in, businesses will require the user to opt in. A ban on facial recognition doesn't mean much if every hotel, gym, and pizza parlor has a shrink-wrap contract or cookie banner [1] forcing you to opt in to their data collection if you want a room or a pizza. [1] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23090393 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23090393
- justchilly 6y ago...which is fine and well within their rights. Businesses don't have to offer people any services if those people don't want to follow their rules. Under federal anti-discrimination laws, businesses can refuse service to any person for any reason, unless the business is discriminating against a protected class.
- trevyn 6y agoAnd we are changing those rights, which is fine and well within our rights.
- toomuchtodo 6y agoIt is so refreshing to see this asserted, that citizens can update the societal contract through legislation when deemed necessary instead of simply being at the mercy of corporate interests.
- pc86 6y agoThis is literally the point of legislation and I haven't seen the opposite asserted even once.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- fiblye 6y ago
- fulafel 6y agoGood opt-in regulation doesn't exist currently - think of all the click-through legalese and cookie popups/gdpr consent popups etc. We'd need something like a once in a lifetime registered consent that service providers would be required to respect quietly and provide non-degraded service to people without the opt-in. Even this would probably require multiple rounds of regulation iteration to fix the loopholes.
- willvarfar 6y agoWould the scanner have to do the recognition stuff _before_ it knows whether the person on-camera has actually opted in?
- throwawaysea 6y agoThis seems unconstitutional. It amounts to blocking photography in public spaces and using those photos as you see fit. It also seems very untimely. Portland is exactly the type of city that needs surveillance, to identify and arrest criminals who are committing property damage, theft, and arson as part of daily riots.
- kstrauser 6y agoWhere's your constitutional right to photograph me and use my photo on your billboard if you see fit? If you don't believe that's OK, and it's clearly not, then we can agree that there are limits to your right to use photographs you've taken of someone. Also, I've heard approximately zero people from Portland calling for more police presence, even if it would cut down on the non-Portlanders traveling there to start problems. From what I can tell, they're not asking for or welcoming of that kind of "help".
- markkanof 6y agoI live in Portland. I don’t live downtown where most of the videos you see are coming from, but I do live in a neighborhood very close to downtown. Over the past few months there have been a bunch of smashed windows (and presumably theft) at many of the businesses on the main street, graffiti is out of control, theft appears to be increasing as well. This is all just in my neighborhood. There are also the fires being set downtown and other violence between various battling groups. I can’t say for sure that putting more police on the streets would solve all these problems, but we need to do something. We are not headed on a good trajectory but for whatever reason it seems like our political leaders are in support of this destruction. We do need help.
- scribbles99 6y agoKeeping right wing terrorists out of the city would be a start.
- jococo1 6y ago
- markovbot 6y agoThis is excellent, and remarkable! I'm hopeful that similar legislation will be considered by other cities. It is unfortunate that providing people such basic protections from some of the worst evils of surveillance capitalism.
- kepler1 6y agoWhat qualifies as part of the facial recognition chain? Does source video count? Because I could see an interpretation in which people filming police activities and the people they arrest as no longer being allowed. What about that?
- nl 6y agoIf they are running automatic facial recognition on the video then yes, it's banned.
- jackinloadup 6y agoThe social media loophole seems ripe for exploit. As long as the destination of the content goes to a social platform it's all free game. I wonder what they will consider a social platform as people develop new systems to get around this law. Cuz logic and unknown reasons.
- xupybd 6y agoYeah that is a silly loophole. If it's dangerous enough to ban ( and it is) how can social media be a justifiable exception. Unless they implicitly trust the people that run social media companies for some reason?
- Reelin 6y agoMy guess is that they lack the jurisdiction to regulate how (for example) Facebook processes images on their platform. Rather, the ordinance only applies to entities while they are within the city. So without the social media exception, it would likely be illegal for any individual within city limits to take a picture with the intent to upload it to Facebook. That would make for some interesting fallout to say the least.
- Reelin 6y agoA lot of the comments here seem conflicting, to say the least. The article has: > use by private entities in public accommodations Which still doesn't fully explain it for me. In an HN comment someone linked what appears to be the ordinance in question: (https://static1.squarespace.com/static/5967c18bff7c50a0244ff42c/t/5f3ad787ba3fd27776e444af/1597691785249/Ordinance+to+ban+use+of+FRT+in+Places+of+Public+Accommodation+plus+code+amendment+-Final.pdf https://static1.squarespace.com/static/5967c18bff7c50a0244ff...) That says (§34.10.020 D) that a place of public accommodation is a "place or service" offering various things. I'm not quite sure how to interpret the wording "advantages, facilities, or privileges" though. In addition to public businesses, I'm assuming that would include city parks (they seem like facilities), but what about roads and sidewalks? I guess those offer "advantages" and "privileges", at least? But regarding the context of the earlier comments in this chain, it seems like intent would be the key factor. Recording video with the intent to run facial recognition against it, whether it was to be done by you or someone else, would presumably qualify as a violation. So what about recording large quantities of video without intending to run facial recognition, for example a dash cam, but then later running it against a specific segment in response to an incident?
- randallsquared 6y agoIt won't be this year, or next, but fairly soon these laws are going to implicitly restrict people who are using Neuralink 2030 from opening their eyes.
- markovbot 6y agoProbably a pretty good reason not to get whatever the hell a "Neuralink 2030" is
- bashallah 6y agoMusk’s internal spotify
- hombre_fatal 6y agoWe're living in the gold ages before everything we do within eyeshot of anyone is recorded like that Black Mirror episode anyone can review/share anything they've seen with their own eyes. And it's going to be very interesting, to say the least. This facial recognition war is just the start of our attempt to engineer ethics for the new era. I mean, just imagine how sex will be different in this world.
- alexwennerberg 6y ago> We're living in the gold ages before everything we do within eyeshot of anyone is recorded like that Black Mirror episode anyone can review/share anything they've seen with their own eyes. I very much doubt that. Just because it may be technically possible to some degree at some point doesn’t mean that anyone would be interested in it. It’s technically possible today to wear a mic and record everything you hear and say for your entire life, but no one does that, and most people would find anyone that did very weird.
- Reelin 6y ago> It’s technically possible today to wear a mic and record everything you hear and say for your entire life, but no one does that, and most people would find anyone that did very weird. I suspect that is largely due to technical limitations. Devices only recently became small enough, and battery life would still be a limiting factor for (say) your phone meaning you would need to carry a second device. Then there's the issue with placement - modern microphones still don't seem to work when obstructed by (for example) your pocket. Contrast this with the (hypothetical) option to record everything using your phone, without meaningfully impacting its battery life, while it was still in your pocket. I think most people would actually opt to do that, even if it was technically illegal in their jurisdiction. There's just not really any downside and a whole bunch of potential upsides from the perspective of an individual.
- erentz 6y agoHow does this apply to something like Facebook scanning someone else’s photo and detecting my face in it? So for an entity present in Portland they cannot run facial recognition in a public place in Portland. But what if entity A is partnered with entity B. Entity B procures images of people in public in Portland city limits and places them on a server in another state. Entity A, which is conveniently headquartered elsewhere takes the data from the server and runs facial recognition. This is clearly facial recognition of persons in public in Portland. But it’s not by a Portland business and the computing isn’t done in Portland either.
- cwzwarich 6y agoDoesn’t Facebook have a Portland office?
- pc86 6y agoSocial media is specifically excluded.
- jonas21 6y agoThere's a specific exception for social media applications: > 34.10.040 Exceptions. > The prohibition in this Chapter does not apply to use of Face Recognition Technologies: > A. To the extent necessary for a Private Entity to comply with federal, state, or local laws; > B. For user verification purposes by an individual to access the individual’s own personal or employer issued communication and electronic devices; or > C. In automatic face detection services in social media applications. [1] That seems like it would include what Facebook is doing -- but the ordinance never defines a "social media application" and also uses face detection and face recognition interchangeably in some places, so it's hard to say for sure what it allows. [1] https://static1.squarespace.com/static/5967c18bff7c50a0244ff42c/t/5f3ad787ba3fd27776e444af/1597691785249/Ordinance+to+ban+use+of+FRT+in+Places+of+Public+Accommodation+plus+code+amendment+-Final.pdf https://static1.squarespace.com/static/5967c18bff7c50a0244ff...
- erentz 6y agoSo that would mean things like Clearview [1] wouldn’t be legal on any person or photograph taken in Portland. Which is great for privacy, but I wonder how they’d enforce that. [1] https://www.nytimes.com/2020/01/18/technology/clearview-privacy-facial-recognition.html https://www.nytimes.com/2020/01/18/technology/clearview-priv...
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- dang 6y agoAll: please don't turn this thread into an ideological flamewar. It's an interesting story and it's possible to have a curious conversation about it, so let's do that instead. https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html
- jMyles 6y agoThis is absurd. If taking a photograph in a public place is protected 1st amendment activity (and it is), then this amounts to telling me how I am allowed to think about what data I already have a right to have. I have a lot of respect for Hardesty (and I vigorously volunteer in PBEM NET, a department she oversees), but I also notice that this comes on the heels of local efforts to use facial recognition tech to identify abusive police officers, who have been authorized (!) to cover their badge numbers here.
- alex_young 6y agoHow does the first amendment protect your right to photograph others, and even if it does somehow, how does it protect your doing whatever you want with that photo? If you take a photo of someone and don’t obtain their permission to use it aren’t you violating their right to privacy, which is clearly secured by the forth amendment?
- jMyles 6y ago> How does the first amendment protect your right to photograph others I'll leave you to read the numerous SCOTUS rulings (and, for the purposes of freedom in other jurisdictions, analogous court rulings) instead of trying to explain myself. In short: the fact that a photon bounces off of your face does not entitle you to control every person who might capture it, in perpetuity, throughout time and space. I was born with eyes capable of a materially identical task as a CMOS sensor: must I look away any time you I see you in public? Must I refrain from remembering that I saw you? If I testify that you shot my friends and neighbors with impact munitions - a nightly occurrence in this city - will it be as reliable as if I had photographed you and compared your face to an index of known violent repressive forces in Portland? I find this logic to be the maximal case for ego: to believe it, you have to believe that light itself is made for you alone. > how does it protect your doing whatever you want with that photo Do you generally dispute that people have a right to think about and process data however they wish? Must I cover my ears if a state secret is uttered by a journalist or friend? Must I refrain from thinking critically about whether it implicates a powerful person in criminal activity? Well, isn't it the same if we, the people of Portland, seek to compile photographs of police officers who have been repeatedly abusing and terrorizing us and use them to recognize their faces? > their right to privacy, which is clearly secured by the forth amendment? I know of no such plausible argument being made about the faces of people appearing in public, and certainly no actual jurisprudence in the Western legal tradition. When in public, you can be reported on. You can be photographed and recorded. If you decide to spray chemical weapons at people, you can be held accountable.
- stjohnswarts 6y agoI can certainly get behind anything that lowers the amount of surveillance that is happening. Good on Portland for respecting the rights of regular everyday people instead of over-policing government and corporate entities.
- cactus2093 6y agoDoes this have that big an impact on surveillance though? You can still set up all the cameras you want to record in public spaces (which i think is a good thing, I.e. this allows people to film police just as much as it allows always-on surveillance that can be used by police). I don’t really understand why the law needs to take such a strong form. If it said something like “you cannot convict someone on purely a facial recognition match”, that would be a reasonable law and protect against the kind of bias in AI that people are rightly worried about. You still need a human witness, or need the whole jury to agree that the face in a video is the suspect. Maybe the law can even make sure that a facial recognition match in a video is not even admissible evidence in a trial. But really facial recognition is just an automation tool. So this is a law that says you’re not allowed to make use of a more efficient tool to solve problems. Instead of doing an automated scan of available video footage to look for a suspect’s face, we’ll just pay police officers for a hundred hours of overtime to pour over footage manually until they find a match. (And of course, if bias is the concern, there will continue to be bias in which cases the police and DA feel are worth investing those resources in, and in manually identifying a match). I just don’t see how this kind of law that basically says “everyone must pretend this ubiquitous technology doesn’t exist at all” is such a clear win. And of course enforcing it as it becomes more and more ubiquitous will be near impossible.
- stjohnswarts 6y agoIt has to start somewhere :) . I think cameras should be banned wholesale for any use other than watching -your- property. No police cams, no public street cams, etc. There is just too much potential for government abuse. It is the job of police, FBI, NSA etc to do everything they can to capture/stop crooks (of their various areas of interest). The Constitution (and general common sense human rights) gets in the way of that and they will use every tactic they can to get around it and stay legal or in a gray zone. This just gives more incentive to them abuse their mandates. This is why there needs to be a hard well defined wall against public surveillance by any government entity without a very very specific warrant. This includes them using anything obtained from a business. I mean down to the crime/individual/specific area of the street. As it stands they want a web of cameras with auto identification and tracking of everyone "just in case". That goes against any sense of liberty to live your life as you see fit as long as you aren't breaking the law. You really should not have to worry -at all- that big brother is watching, listening, recording, or any of that until you start breaking the law.
- Areading314 6y agoIf you're looking for tech that will change the world, a good signal is when people try to ban it.
- triceratops 6y agoNot all "change the world" developments are for the better.
- kebman 6y agoThou shalt not make a machine in the likeness of a human mind. [1] 'Tis but the first overture in the Butlerian Jihad. [1]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dune_(franchise)#The_Butlerian_Jihad https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dune_(franchise)#The_Butlerian...
- AniseAbyss 6y agoIx is descended from the US.
- jxcole 6y agoI'm curious how laws like this would handle jurisdiction. If I take a photo in Portland and send the data to Morocco where facial recognition is used and the results are sent back to Portland, have I violated anything?
- coolspot 6y agoiANAL, but I would imagine local laws are applied locally. For example, I can buy an AR-15 without a pistol grip in California, travel to any free state and attach a pistol grip to that rifle. Doing that I would not violate California law, even though AR-15 with pistol grip is illegal in CA.
- d33lio 6y agoUnfortunately, virtue signaling legislation like this never really has any teeth... Similar to how creative commons falls apart as soon as a bottom of the barrel lawyer takes an axe to it. Nonetheless hopefully they feel all warm and fuzzy inside now that they've "defeated" the evil forces of facial recognition?
- m-watson 6y agoWhat makes it simply virtue signalling? And what kind of teeth do you want? It isn't the strongest but allowing individuals to sue[0] is a lot stronger than just saying "please don't do this." It isn't necessarily about defeating the evil forces of facial recognition but it is about trying to get a handle of the situation before it gets way out of control. [0] https://onezero.medium.com/portlands-radical-facial-recognition-proposal-bans-the-tech-from-airbnbs-restaurants-stores-and-32ada95430b6 https://onezero.medium.com/portlands-radical-facial-recognit...
- dang 6y agoPlease don't post unsubstantive and/or flamebait comments to HN. There's no information here. If you wanted to say something specific about how this is like Creative Commons, for example, that might be interesting. But shallow denunciation isn't interesting, however intense you make it. https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html
- OzCrimson 6y agoI'm listening to this podcast about the ban and it's loaded with concerns. https://xraypod.com/show/banned-in-pdx/biz-and-tech-groups-across-the-country-fight-portland-s-facial-recognition-ban https://xraypod.com/show/banned-in-pdx/biz-and-tech-groups-a... For one, the lobbyists and pro-tech groups that are against the ban, have nothing to say about what happens when the tech is wrong. They're painting a perfect world where the tech is solid and used for things like identifying missing children. The podcast describes the high level of false positives in the algorithms. They say "top performing" algorithms are pretty good, but generally speaking ... no. Not good. And there's the implementation. How does this get rolled out? Who's responsible for breaches? Who can access the data? Will anyone be able to sell access to the data? But I always come back to: what happens when it's wrong? And I don't expect perfection. KNOWING that this tech is flawed, it's important to ask "what level of flawed is acceptable?"
- colpabar 6y ago> Will anyone be able to sell access to the data? This is an extremely concerning point, and one that a lot of people (myself included) wouldn't even think about. If you search for "dmv" on this site, there are several posts within the last year about DMVs all over the country selling personal info. I really doubt police departments wouldn't do the same with this data.