4 ms·
I just applied. I don't want my add-on "promoted". I just want to get rid of the Mozilla message: "This is not monitored for security through Mozilla's Recommen
by Animats 6y ago
I just applied. I don't want my add-on "promoted". I just want to get rid of the Mozilla message: "This is not monitored for security through Mozilla's Recommended Extensions program. Make sure you trust it before installing."
I wrote back to Mozilla: "This is an old add-on. I just want to get rid of the warning label. How much will that cost me?"
I feel like I'm asking the extortionist goon how much it's going to cost me to not be beaten up.
- laksdjfkasljdf 6y agoWhat's so bad about reminding people to "Make sure you trust it before installing"?
- AnthonyMouse 6y agoThe part where there is only one party who can make the scary warning go away and doing so requires paying them.
- chrisweekly 6y agoto be fair, that one party is trying to account for a pretty diverse set of constraints. I'm not in the "they can do no wrong" camp, but it's pretty easy to beat up on nearly any company or entity involved w software (name one and I'll list a handful of gripes). much harder to mostly get it right, as I think mozilla does.
- Spivak 6y agoHow would you want the system structured? You’re paying for Mozilla to vouch for your add-on and say that it’s safe. I mean you could try to do a web of trust kinda thing but you would still end up paying someone. I get where you’re coming from that they could just not have the scary warning but the fact that it’s hosted on Mozilla’s site without a warning already lends a lot of legitimacy to what should be seen as “some random person’s add on.”
- Animats 6y agoMozilla used to have volunteer add-on reviewers, which meant slow turnaround, but worked OK.
- laksdjfkasljdf 6y agoyou ignored my argument that the warning is valid, not scary.
- AnthonyMouse 6y agoIt's scary independent of whether it's valid. And that's the problem. It's like putting a sign in front of a retail store that says "make sure you trust the proprietor before patronizing this store" -- it's not saying anything that isn't true, but it's also going to be a direct cause of fewer people patronizing the store, even if the proprietor is trustworthy. If the sign then only comes down by paying money to the party who put up the sign, well, now it's a racket.
- surround 6y agoMeanwhile, commercially owned extensions which are terrible for privacy and security, like Grammarly and Honey, are going to get promoted by Mozilla. The open-source projects with no income are the ones getting hurt.
- Cyphase 6y agoHow are the Grammarly[1] or Honey[2] addons terrible for security? I can guess why you say they're terrible for privacy, but they both mention what data they share on the addon page. So it seems not so much that they are violating users privacy, but that you think people should be more concerned with the amount of privacy they give up. For the record, I am pro-privacy, and would never want to use addons like these that send my browsing and other data to a third-party. And I know the vast majority of people don't read privacy statements and might not fully realize the amount of privacy they're giving up. But that's a much bigger problem than Mozilla giving these addons that openly collect this data a Verified tag. Also, the tag will ostensibly indicate some level of verification that the addon isn't doing anything sneaky (on the client side), so it's not "just" promotion, according to the announcement. If you don't believe Mozilla is going to do that verification well/honestly, that's a different discussion. Regarding open-source projects, I share your concern, but would be interested to see some evidence that they will be hurt by this. [1] https://addons.mozilla.org/en-US/firefox/addon/grammarly-1/ https://addons.mozilla.org/en-US/firefox/addon/grammarly-1/ [2] https://addons.mozilla.org/en-US/firefox/addon/honey/ https://addons.mozilla.org/en-US/firefox/addon/honey/
- gilrain 6y agoOpen source extensions already wait weeks or, more often, months to be reviewed and have that scary warning removed. As this program is planned, any commercial or other well-funded extensions will be jumping the queue ahead of them. That seems strictly worse, unless they also pay to play.
- cassepipe 6y agoWell the Mozilla add-on website maybe isn't the only way to distribute webextensions. Mozilla already hosts and lists the add-ons for free. It seems only normal it warns users that no verification has been made as they might assume since it's on an official website. Extensions may be hosted elsewhere and reviewed by online communities too. For example, the Krabby extension that add Kakoune keybindings to web navigation is hosted on github.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- bachmeier 6y agoThis is a very developer-centric view. I have no idea what extension you're trying to get people to install, but your complaint is ridiculous. I've run into more than one extension with tons of good reviews that did things like hijack links. You don't even know what's going on when it happens, or why.