3 ms·
The way you've put this bears more resemblance to religion than anything else. "Markets" are real things. I can walk to them, or navigate to their website, or
by samatman 6y ago
The way you've put this bears more resemblance to religion than anything else.
"Markets" are real things. I can walk to them, or navigate to their website, or call them up.
You are claiming that there is an invisible, metaphysical "the market", which exists in the Platonic world of forms, that governs the behavior of these genuine markets.
This is like reading "The Gods of the Copybook Headings", and founding a religion which worships and offers sacrifice to those gods!
This "the market" you refer to is an abstraction of the behavior of real markets. It can give us all sorts of guidance as to what will happen when various rules are applied, or not, to these real markets; but comparing these broad heuristic rules to thermodynamics has me suspecting you don't understand either thermodynamics nor macroeconomics.
Every market has rules. Invariably, you are not allowed to stab a vendor and take their stuff. Sometimes there are things you can't sell; sometimes only Dutch auction is allowed, and so on ad infinitum.
This is simply a market with different rules from those governing other stock markets. We're all free to speculate on the consequences those different rules will have; perhaps they will summon literal Gods of the Copybook Headings, which will return upon us with actual terror and slaughter.
The safe bet is that prediction and reality will be divergent. This is economics, not thermodynamics, after all.
- throwaway_fc 6y ago> The way you've put this bears more resemblance to religion than anything else. The connection with religion goes deeper that it seems. Mission, vision / visionary, iconic (product), (job) creator, charismatic, angel (investors). All these words had a purely religious meaning 200 years ago. This is not just natural evolution of the language. Other fields don't have this amount of religious words at all.
- tome 6y agoOn the contrary, he/she is claiming that "the market" is an emergent behaviour of the dynamics of a system. We set up "market" and instigate rules. "The market" is what happens subsequently.
- Cederfjard 6y ago>We're all free to speculate on the consequences those different rules will have To echo what my sibling commenter said, those consequences are what the grandparent comment is referring to as the emergent market - because it's not possible to control or accurately predict the behavior of every single actor. It was a rebuttal to a statement saying we don't need to consider markets as pure forces of nature, because how we set them up can affect the outcome. I think everyone in this conversation agrees that it's both true that the design of a market affects how people act in it, as well as it being impossible to predict or control perfectly. The question is to what extent it actually is possible.
- centimeter 6y agoIf you think emergent behaviors are "invisible" and "metaphysical", this suggests a modeling deficiency on your part rather than anything interesting about the real world. > This "the market" you refer to is an abstraction of the behavior of real markets The market isn't an abstraction at all - it's a handle for the emergent behavior of the sum total of all economic activity.