3 ms·
I agree that if you dug into the engineering the math probably works[1]. It's just a weird culture to be out on the floor substituting random materials in a loa
by jeffbee 6y ago
I agree that if you dug into the engineering the math probably works[1]. It's just a weird culture to be out on the floor substituting random materials in a load-bearing, if perhaps not life-safety-critical, part.
1: Compressive strength of wood perpendicular to the grain varies but you can estimate with a healthy safety margin about 200 PSI. 100x - 1000x weaker than metals, but still not zero.
- sokoloff 6y agoI (pretty strongly) suspect that engineers were involved, rather than this being an assembly line worker floor-level decision. The same company that erected a factory-in-a-tent (unconventional but also appropriate) to hit aggressive production targets seems like one that would consider and execute appropriate but unconventional substitutions.
- hcknwscommenter 6y ago"Compressive strength of wood . . ." I guarantee you that the materiel is not "wood" and is indeed much weaker in all relevant parameters. And I suspect that no one at TESLA has any real handle on the compressive strength of this material.
- jeffbee 6y agoYou think so? MDF is stronger than wood in compression and isotropic which is nice.