3 ms·
4K video is awesome. Probably wasted on a phone, but I can instantly see the difference between 1080p and 4K on anything larger. I'm pretty sure that it's righ
by samatman 6y ago
4K video is awesome. Probably wasted on a phone, but I can instantly see the difference between 1080p and 4K on anything larger.
I'm pretty sure that it's right on the diminishing returns margin, however. I don't have an 8K resolution device to try it out on, but that's because everything I use is in the 'retina' zone of pixel density, I never see a genuine pixel under normal circumstances. (Actually my TV isn't 4K but if I cared at all it would be).
For what I use my phone for, the only thing which could improve in a way I would notice is the camera. That won't be true for everyone, games in particular have an essentially unlimited appetite for specs, but this is just to say that the state of the art as of four years ago is still just fine by me.
- FractalParadigm 6y agoThe biggest difference with 4K IMO isn't the resolution itself, but the features that typically come with 4K content. HDR and 10-bit colour especially make for a noticeably better picture than the pixels ever will.
- RinTohsaka 6y agoThat and the higher bitrate! e.g. youtube
- eru 6y agoAnd, of course, the higher bitrate directly ties into our topic at hand. The increase resolution is just a side effect.
- agumonkey 6y agowhat if I told you I voluntarily set youtube to 480p or even 360p ?
- samatman 6y agoI would say: Rock on with your potatocam aesthetic! Downsampling a high-resolution video is always possible, the reverse is an... unsolved problem.
- agumonkey 6y agoIIRC there were 4k upscaling demos but I'm past the point of pixel resolution, my interests are not in pristine visuals but a blend of surprises in content and composition.
- samatman 6y agoUpscaling is 'real' in the sense that it exists, and for animation in particular the results can be quite satisfying. But the technology to add missing detail will never exist; we must be content with a realistic facsimile.
- eru 6y ago> But the technology to add missing detail will never exist; we must be content with a realistic facsimile. You are right in a sense. But there are some details that are in the pixels but that your eyes can't see. You can upscale to make them visible to the eyes. See https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Compressed_sensing https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Compressed_sensing
- charrondev 6y agoI normally browse the comments on certain channels while watching, and with the video taking up only the upper third of the screen, I can’t tell a real difference between 480 and 1080. If I flip to landscape though it can be noticeably, significantly worse.
- ashtonkem 6y agoBased on back of the envelope math I did based on known ideal viewing distances, most TVs are too far away to be able to get all the benefit out of even 4K. Something between 4K and 1080P would be the “ideal” balance between bandwidth and resolution. For monitors, the maximum resolution is a bit behind 4K (since monitors are closer than TVs), and I suspect that’s why Apple offers a 5K iMac. I didn’t estimate this for mobile devices.