5 ms·
Interesting. Does Facebook already have separate infrastructure for Europe, but just forwards user data to the US mothership? Or is the infrastructure all "mixe
by tyingq 6y ago
Interesting. Does Facebook already have separate infrastructure for Europe, but just forwards user data to the US mothership? Or is the infrastructure all "mixed together"? I'm curious how hard it would be to comply.
- ffpip 6y agoThe framework for transfering data is called 'Privacy Shield'. It was ruled to be not effective by the EU recently, so a new framework for data transfer is to be agreed on. Wiki - https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/EU-US_Privacy_Shield https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/EU-US_Privacy_Shield News- https://duckduckgo.com/?t=ffab&q=privacy+shield+&iar=news&ia=news https://duckduckgo.com/?t=ffab&q=privacy+shield+&iar=news&ia...
- zonethundery 6y agoPrivacy shield was one framework (now invalid, as parent notes) among a few. FB is dependent on standard contractual clauses which are generally valid (per schrems ii) but potentially invalid if the recipient is subject to FISA 702 warrants. Schrems ii put the burden of making that validity determination on member states' data protection authorities. The Irish DPC didn't want to make this decision (for reasons), kicking the can to the CJEU, which eventually resolved Schrems II and remanded the decision on FB's SCC's back to the DPC.
- broeng 6y agoYes, it will be interesting to follow the SCC's (Standard Contractual Clauses). But, even though they were upheld, it is still up to the data exporter to guerantee before every transfer, that the SCC will provide an "essentially equivalent" protection to that offerend in the EU with GDPR for instance. It will also be dependant on all circumstances of the SCC whether the protections offered by it is enough, for instance if the receiving end could be compelled by the government, for instance, to hand over the data. It is hard to imagine a SCC that could provide "essentially equivalent" protection if the other end is an American company, given the authority the US government can exert over it.
- zonethundery 6y agoI mostly agree- its very hard to imagine any SCC for a communication service/social network surviving this kind of complaint. Not so sure about other kinds of things.
- saddlerustle 6y agoFacebook's infrastructure is one global transparently replicated database. Siloing data by legal jurisdiction is a huge engineering change. Fortunately they have a head start - there was a big project to enable this for when they still had hopes of operating in China. It's kind of sad to think that this is now going to be used for Europe.
- echlebek 6y agoI don't see how it's sad for anyone but Facebook.
- saddlerustle 6y agoSome of us still believe in a borderless internet
- libertine 6y agoYou see data protection as a border?
- Spivak 6y agoData for people in $country must stay in $country is essentially a border. It’s not about the actual protections but the fact that the EU considers data that would be legal to collect and store in the EU illegal to store in the US.
- libertine 6y agoWell if data wasn't being mishandled, poorly managed and devalued without any legal repercussion we wouldn't have reached this point. Plus it's not in $country is in $region, if all countries made an effort to adopt GDPR data could be stored anywhere. EU is looking for their citizens data, since no one else seems to care that much (other than China but for completely different reasons). Unless you think that the protocol of tech giants to poor data protection is fine, when they are saying: "Ups, we're sorry :(... it won't happen again!"