3 ms·
Well, his argument is unconvincing -- it only proves that there is no normed division algebra on R^3. Division algebra on R^3 would be interesting and maybe use
by xyzzyz 16y ago
Well, his argument is unconvincing -- it only proves that there is no normed division algebra on R^3. Division algebra on R^3 would be interesting and maybe useful even without norm. However, its existence is still impossible. One can prove it for instance by noticing that if it existed, then {1, v, v^2} for any non-scalar v would span whole R^3 (the hardest part of proof), so v^3 would be a linear combination of them, say v^3 = a 1 + b v + c v^2 for some a, b, c \in R. Then v is the zero of polynomial f(x) = x^3 - c x^2 - b^x - a. But deg f = 3, so it has real zero, so for some q, w, p \in R, f(x) = (x-q)(x^2 + w x + p), and 0 = f(v) = (v-q)(v^2 + w v + p 1), and factors on the right side are non-zero, so we have non-trivial zero divisors which is imposible in division algebra.
There is also a theorem due to H. Hopf, stating that the only finite dimensional, commutative division algebras over R are C and R itself, but the only proof I know requires pretty heavy topological machinery.