16 ms·
A big problem is the marketing around 5G is a total clusterfuck, to the great detriment of consumers. As I understand it, the "true" original definition of 5G
by hn_throwaway_99 6y ago
A big problem is the marketing around 5G is a total clusterfuck, to the great detriment of consumers.
As I understand it, the "true" original definition of 5G was millimeter wave technology. From the PCMag article this is based on:
> Millimeter-wave uses very weak, short-range panels that are easily blocked by obstacles. In our tests, millimeter-wave doesn't generally penetrate buildings, and even has trouble with glass; we had our drivers keep their windows down, with the phones facing out, so the network even had a chance.
That is, this kind of 5G is essentially useless now, and will be for a long time until buildings/cars/subways etc. are built with repeaters that would make indoor coverage possible.
However, I definitely don't understand all the various versions of "5G" so it's difficult for me to understand which tech is used by which phones and carriers.
- sroussey 6y agoNo, true 5G is a basket of technologies. Sub-6 is about beam-forming — instead of sending your signal in all directions, it sends only in the direction of your device (and visa-versa which is why antenna design is a larger cost on mobile than before). Now the base station can use the same bandwidth for another device located in a different direction. Over time this will get better and have compounding effects. And that’s just one item in the basket. mmWave is another. There are several.
- newhouseb 6y agoLTE already has a fair bit of beam-forming standard, 5G dramatically increases the number of antennas used to do so (allowing you to beam-form more efficiently /precisely) Another bucket is coding schemes: LTE uses Turbo and Convolutional Coding, whereas 5G adds Polar and LDPC codes to the mix which bring us closer to the Shannon Limit (theoretical maximum data capacity given a certain SNR).
- snovv_crash 6y agoOn the tower side they've been using multiple directional antennas per base station since the 2G days. Beamforming is only going to help on the mobile side.
- Nokinside 6y agoNo. 5G marketing is concentrating on new high-band, because first 5G installations are deployed into new high-band. 5G spectrum covers also low-band and-mid band spectrum from 1G through 4G LTE frequencies. 5G installations in the countryside will have low-band that is more efficient than 4G/LTE. You can have _less_ base stations than LTE, not more in the low-band. 5G NR is more efficient radio interface in all bandwidths.