3 ms·
>>> Like this one, it’s not understood how it can exist. I don't like that phrase. It suggests the possibility that this galaxy might not exist, that this cou
by sandworm101 6y ago
>>> Like this one, it’s not understood how it can exist.
I don't like that phrase. It suggests the possibility that this galaxy might not exist, that this could be observational error. I think it does exist. We understand exactly how it exists because we can observe it existing. The more accurate phrasing might be "it's not understood how it could have evolved so quickly".
- CDSlice 6y agoI think the phrase is fine since according to our best models of galaxy formation these galaxies should not be able to exist and yet they do. As such we don't understand how these galaxies can exist and need to do more research to come up with better models that can explain the existence of these galaxies.
- undersuit 6y agoThe article also states that a galaxy making stars at the rate of this new one shouldn't be a disc galaxy. >the theoretical models are wrong, or at least (and more likely) incomplete.
- newacct583 6y ago> that this could be observational error This could absolutely be observation error. Messups in science happen all the time. You never take a single data point at face value without question, in any field. The spectrum might be polluted by another more distant object, the line matching might have been faked by some other intervening medium, the modelling for the lensing galaxy could be wrong. I agree, it looks good. But it could totally be a mistake.
- Avamander 6y agoYou can never sum up an entire paper in one sentence with all the nuance.
- crusso 6y agoObservational error is always a good speculation. It seems to be at the heart of most of these "impossible physics" stories. Remember not long ago when neutrinos were thought to have been observed moving faster than the speed of light? Cold fusion? Before people jump on the idea of re-evaluating Einstein's theories, it's always good to get more people looking at the data, independently verifying it, thinking about it. In a few months, it's likely that this blip will disappear like most others.