3 ms·
Puppet isn’t fit for purpose in 2020. Testing Puppet manifests locally is (was) THE WORST. Hiera and r10k really shouldn’t exist in 2020. IIRC you essentially
by nunez 6y ago
Puppet isn’t fit for purpose in 2020.
Testing Puppet manifests locally is (was) THE WORST. Hiera and r10k really shouldn’t exist in 2020. IIRC you essentially need long-lived Git branches for managing different envs for different playbooks.
Ansible is just SSH and a binary. pip install and I’m done. This is great for building VMs, base Docker images, app deployments, whatever you need. Puppet has their own wire protocol and is very dependent on a client-server relationship. You need to edit config files and fake a puppet master. That’s work.
- xorcist 6y agoThe each their own, these tools are conceptually simple but as you found out, there is a lot to learn. What kind of branching strategy is most suitable is given from how your testing is organized, not which particular tools are chosen. Ansible is completely equivalent to Puppet or Chef in this regard. They are all the same family of tools. Many find Ansible easier to get started with due to its agentless defaults, but there are some (perhaps Spotify was most well known at the time) who run Puppet agentless too. Having a server, something like Tower, is necessary as soon as you want to manage distributed configuration for clusters, and if you manage monitoring and backup systems.