4 ms·
> create a giant compressed gas reservoir underground. The McIntosh CAES plant began in 1991 and from my understanding, has been widely viewed as successful. h
by dragontamer 6y ago
> create a giant compressed gas reservoir underground.
The McIntosh CAES plant began in 1991 and from my understanding, has been widely viewed as successful. https://www.smithsonianmag.com/innovation/salt-power-plant-most-valuable-180964307/ https://www.smithsonianmag.com/innovation/salt-power-plant-m...
That's 110 MWs for 26 hours. Probably not 2.8 GW-hrs of energy storage (they can't sustain 110MWs for all 26 hours), but this plant is probably GW-hr range. I'm pretty sure all of Li-Ion right now is less than 2GW-hrs for the entirety of the USA.
---------
The 290 MW plant in Huntorf Germany (1978) also is successful.
--------
There's a 2nd, 300MW+ plant (that's 300MW power for multiple hours. So near GW-hr scale as well). This is the more recent Apex Bethel Energy Center you were badmouthing earlier. Its not fully built yet, but given the history of CAES, I'm optimistic.
--------
There aren't many CAES plants in the world. But from what I can tell, they are all safe and successful. The one issue is that you need to reheat the air as it leaves the caverns: compressing it underground reduces its temperature. A bit of natural gas is used in this heating process, but not nearly as much as an actual natural-gas plant.
------------
The "Rail up a hill" project is 50MWs with 12.5 MWhr storage capacity: https://s3.amazonaws.com/siteninja/multitenant/assets/21126/files/original/ARES_Nevada_Technical_Specification_Sheet.pdf https://s3.amazonaws.com/siteninja/multitenant/assets/21126/...
50MWs is somewhat small, but there's something to be said about the simplicity and ease-of-deployment of rail energy storage. Those 50MWs were spec'd out with only 7 trains. It isn't too hard to imagine scaling the system up to support more than 7 trains.
- reincarnate0x14 6y agoIndeed; I'm not sure why exactly so few of the CAES plants have been built, it's well understood, has minimal safety problems, and doesn't seem unreasonably expensive. If I had to wager an uneducated guess, workable salt mines may not be located anywhere the power pricing makes sense for long term storage offsetting like that.
- jbay808 6y agoCompressed air storage has very bad efficiency, due to the adiabatic heating and cooling when the pressure changes.
- owenversteeg 6y agoYeah, I have to say I'm actually pretty impressed with the "rail up a hill" thing. Sure, 50MW isn't a ton, but it takes up nearly no space, infrastructure is very simple (5 miles of plain electrified track and that's it!), doesn't even need a crazy grade (7%), and most importantly: locomotives are cheap. IIRC, less than a million bucks for a good DC electric one, used. So you can be up and running pretty cheap and simple. I'd love to see people running more of these setups. Especially in places where DC locomotives are cheap (former CIS countries), this could be even more cost effective.