4 ms·
Isn't this the exact same concept as a dam which pumps water back up when you have excess power? Also how heavy does that weight have to be to be able to store
by wqsz7xn 6y ago
Isn't this the exact same concept as a dam which pumps water back up when you have excess power? Also how heavy does that weight have to be to be able to store enough energy worth digging a hole that large? Can you even get a weight heavy enough to store a significant amount of energy?
- Baeocystin 6y agoSame concept, but the tl;dr is that no, you can't, unless you're talking hydro from a dam in a good location. It's not just a not-so good idea, it's an orders-of-magnitude-awful idea when you compare it to just about any other form of energy storage per dollar.
- reincarnate0x14 6y agoAnything involving dams typically also has to involve water release schedules, which at least in some parts of the western US will produce some of the most vicious political battles you can imagine.
- syllable_studio 6y agoYou can in fact! Pumped hydro is already the cheapest form of energy storage - about 95% of all energy storage is pumped hydro. We can't build more pumped hydro because it's not feasible to build enough dams. (We've used up the best locations) The US Gov has studied plenty of research showing that underground pumped hydro is cost effective and obviates the need for dams. (See my white paper here: https://github.com/syllable-hq/uphs-feasibility-study https://github.com/syllable-hq/uphs-feasibility-study) So startups like Gravitricity (and Terrament, my startup) are innovating on what is already well-researched territory.