3 ms·
Yes of course gorgeous user interface design matters. But pitching two calculators up against each other is missing the point. Beauty matters when everything e
by ThomPete 16y ago
Yes of course gorgeous user interface design matters. But pitching two calculators up against each other is missing the point.
Beauty matters when everything else is equal. It's very easy to make something a simple as as calculator look good if you got the chops, because the UI have been solved for you.
But interface design is not just about how it looks. It's about how it works. And I will take something that works over something that looks good any day.
- valisystem 16y agoTo resonate on your comment : when thinking about UI design, I personally never dissociate visual and behavior. The UI behavior has to comply with the visual metaphor it manipulates. This is quite hard to do properly for people (like me) that does not master one of the discipline : UI behavior is controlled by code, and with a slight lack of care, it slips easily in a spaghetti nightmare if you want something finely tuned, and UI visuals, well, also needs great skills. A team that manages to set up a cooperation for those two competence will bring you great UIs.
- ThomPete 16y agoExactly. But there is one area that I wish more developers would explore and that is the ability to code proper transitions. To actually sit down and do some research into motion graphics. Right now that area is primarily explored by flash developers and there are many really cool geeky things you can do to optimize transitions. If you really wanna shine as a developer with these kind of interfaces, learn how to optimize your transitions. Why is this important? Because it's what happens between the clicks that going to create the feel of the product.
- ericmoritz 16y agoThe winning todo app looks to complicated to me.
- dhimes 16y agoI like how the "work" icon is a wine glass!! And for my taste, I like the metronome on the right better, and the calculator buttons on the right calculator better (but the little display on the left calculator is nice).
- tvon 16y agoYou may want to view the Calcbot demo here: http://tapbots.com/software/calcbot/#overview http://tapbots.com/software/calcbot/#overview It's nothing revolutionary, but they did go above and beyond the typical calculator app with their tape history. In other words, I'd agree with you if all the app was could be seen in the comparison screenshots, but the fact is the attention to detail in Calcbot went well beyond just the aesthetics. It works and looks good.
- ThomPete 16y agoI am not saying you can't have both. Just that claiming that as long as your app is gorgeous you will win is missing quite a lot in the argument. I say this as a designer btw not as a developer.
- tvon 16y agoAh, good point, I thought you were dismissing it because it was a simple app. My mistake.