6 ms·
At an individual level, it's a choice. At the societal level, it's not. You need 2.1 kids per person for society to continue existing. That's true more or less
by rayiner 6y ago
At an individual level, it's a choice. At the societal level, it's not. You need 2.1 kids per person for society to continue existing. That's true more or less however you slice it--even if you take lots of immigrants, those immigrants are going to have to have kids (or you're externalizing the cost of child raising onto other societies). This is a hard scientific limit that you're not going to get around.
From the perspective of analyzing society, therefore, treating having children as a choice is unworkable. If your societal design doesn't accommodate 2.1 kids per person, its useless. It's like designing an electric car that can't be recharged. Nobody cares what other characteristics it has.
- CydeWeys 6y agoI just want to say, thanks for your posts in here. You're making excellent points. I don't even need to respond to this guy's comment personally because you've handled it so well here.
- shock 6y ago> You need 2.1 kids per person for society to continue existing. I don't understand this statement. Is it 2.1 kids per person or per family/couple? Has society collapsed in countries where the average is below the 2.1 figure you are quoting? If you are talking about the extinction of the human race and not societal collapse, then I don't buy for a second the argument that someone choosing whether to have children or not is making the choice based on the "human race extinction" factor. When making choices, most humans could care less for their 2-days-in-the-future-self, nevermind caring for the human race.
- satyrnein 6y agoReplacement rate is usually described as 2.1 children per woman. Basically every 2 person couple needs to have 2.1 kids, because some die of accidents, etc. Going below that doesn't cause instant societal collapse, but if you look at Japan for example, they now consume more adult diapers than baby diapers, which will not be good for the viability of their pensions, etc. I personally decided that I did feel a duty to do my part to continue the human race, and that nothing else I would likely do could ever rival that in terms of lasting consequence. And folks who are interested in making it harder for parents or harder for children because they feel like families get too much slack or something, they are de facto aligned against the mission of continuing the human race, and I hope they change their minds over time.
- shock 6y ago> I personally decided that I did feel a duty to do my part to continue the human race I also feel a duty to do my part to continue the human race, but I don't pretend that I didn't make a choice, that somehow there was no other real option for me to choose.
- CydeWeys 6y agoYou really aren't understanding that we are talking about societal choices writ large, not about individual choices. Think bigger. If enough people make the individual choice not to have children then civilization is kaput.
- shock 6y agoI understand that when enough people do not have children the human race will disappear. Civilization might disappear before then. I'm not talking about that. I'm also not talking about people having children or not. I'm arguing for people to assume responsibility for their choices(whatever the choice may be) and to not go "Oh, I really didn't have a choice in the matter". I especially dislike it when people present their choice as a sacrifice for humanity. Another poster put it better: > People can have children without congratulating themselves for a sacrifice well delivered ... Kinship for species only extends so far and not much at all when there is parental entitlement.
- jelliclesfarm 6y agoGood for you. If you think it’s your duty, there is no contract with society that others should subsidize your dutifulness.
- dctoedt 6y ago> If you think it’s your duty, there is no contract with society that others should subsidize your dutifulness. But neither do the rest of us have any obligation not to band together and vote in legislators who will tax the shit out of the childless-by-choice — because in the long term, the childless-by-choice are the ones being subsidized by those who us who have raised children. Don't like it? Then do something about it, or move elsewhere.
- jelliclesfarm 6y agoWhere does this 2.1 number come from? [..] The single most important factor in population growth is the total fertility rate (TFR). If, on average, women give birth to 2.1 children and these children survive to the age of 15, any given woman will have replaced herself and her partner upon death. A TFR of 2.1 is known as the replacement rate.[..] In other words, if a woman has 2.1 children, she can replace herself and her partner. Even halving this number will not result in ‘the disappearance of society’. There will be a dip in population. Which is actually desirable because we are at 8 billion and our resources are fast depleting as we are in the midst of the sixth extinction event. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sub-replacement_fertility https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sub-replacement_fertility [..] Sub-replacement fertility does not automatically translate into a population decline because of increasing life expectancy and population momentum: recently high fertility rates produce a disproportionately young population, and younger populations have higher birth rates. This is why some nations with sub-replacement fertility still have a growing population, because a relatively large fraction of their population are still of child-bearing age. But if the fertility trend is sustained (and not compensated by immigration), it results in population ageing and/or population decline. This is already happening and impacts first most of the countries of Europe and East Asia.[..] [..] Some governments, fearful of a future pensions crisis, have developed natalist policies to attempt to encourage more women to have children. Measures include increasing tax allowances for working parents, improving child-care provision, reducing working hours/weekend working in female-dominated professions such as healthcare and a stricter enforcement of anti-discrimination measures to prevent professional women's promotion prospects being hindered when they take time off work to care for children. Over recent years, the fertility rate has increased to around 2.0 in France and 1.9 in Britain and some other northern European countries, but the role of population policies in these trends is debated.[52] In Italy, for example, natalist policies may have actually discouraged the Italian population from having more children. This "widespread resistance" was the result of the Italian government, at one point,[when?] taxing single persons and criminalizing abortion and even contraception.[53][..] As a female, I am disgusted by how women’s bodies and reproductive ability is being commoditised. Natalist economic policies are akin to forcing them into flesh trade. And then there is religion. I don’t want to risk a aneurysm and will refrain from that commentary.